Newbie 2017: Ducks [game over!]

[JamSV]

Bah posts allowed

bah

Baaaaah

[dsjstr]

Don't have time to really think about the game currently, but Bell why do you not want reads on Dunn and yourself?

Because I'm more interested in figuring out who the last mafia is and I don't think it's Dun or myself.

Well I would hope you know your own role do you have any scum reads?

I'd say the last scum is in Dunn/Echo

[Bell]

You. Jam put me to L1, while not putting his read where his mouth was when it was your turn. They tend to do that with their partners.

[TCowley]

how do we feel about tcowley? obv IV isn’t scum for him to be his partner like i originally thought but i still don’t know about that slot

I feel good about him, but I guess that's no big shock?

I should be blunt that I think the last mafia is within Echo, tcow, and Dst. I would like them all to post and give reads on each other.

I've already said that dsjstr was one of my tier 1 suspects. Would be happy to see that slot eliminated.

As an aside, do we push for the reveal of the second mason? It has no power now but would give us a definite town if not counterclaimed?

[dsjstr]

Then they die at night and there is no help on the final day.

[dsjstr]

Spoiler:

Vote count 2.03

with 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to make a decision. day 2 ends in (expired on 2020-07-19 10:00:00)

.

elimination

engineer [3]:

innocentvillager, TCowley, JamSV

dsjstr [1]:

Dunnstral

Dunnstral [1]:

dsjstr

innocentvillager [1]:

EchoVision

Not Voting [1]:

engineer

King Eider (Somateria spectabilis)

mod notes

• ...

You. Jam put me to L1, while not putting his read where his mouth was when it was your turn.

They

tend to do that with their partners.

I believe this is what you are referring to and I wouldn't call it my time so could you elaborate more about what you were thinking, don't think it came across correctly.

[Dunnstral]

Mason might get counter claimed in 3p limlo

With that said, that's still a better situation than having 3 vt claims. Mafia have to counterclaim vt or Mason, so it narrows down either way.

So no, I don't think mason should claim today

[Dunnstral]

Also why am I potential scum?

[dsjstr]

I don't think it is bell or tcow so poe

[dsjstr]

But we'll see

[dsjstr]

Nah probably just echo, when 1 mafia starts to lurk I find the other one follows

VOTE: echo

[Datisi]

Vote count 3.01

with 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to make a decision. day 3 ends in (expired on 2020-07-28 09:15:00)

.

elimination

dsjstr [1]:

Bell

EchoVision [1]:

dsjstr

Not Voting [3]:

TCowley, EchoVision, Dunnstral

Masked Duck (Nomonyx dominicus)

mod notes

• guess who's back, back again
  
• dual mod ISO

[Dunnstral]

What do you think Echo?

[Bell]

Vote count 2.04

with 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to make a decision. day 2 ends in (expired on 2020-07-19 10:00:00)

.

elimination

Bell [3]:

innocentvillager, TCowley, JamSV

dsjstr [2]:

Dunnstral, Bell

Dunnstral [1]:

dsjstr

innocentvillager [1]:

EchoVision

Not Voting [0]:

Rubber Ducky (Ruberius Duckimus)

mod notes

• ... quack
  
• click here to view this VC along with all of datisi's VCs!

Can the people on the Bell wagon explain why they still think he is mafia. He's been like the only one searching for info.

I was waiting for an explanation behind 187, because he basically expressed intent to hammer, and I wanted to check if it was indeed intent to hammer, or just, if push comes to shove. I felt as if it was him trying to set up a safe hammer on Aray by claiming to do it preemptively, but him not responding to 187 before the day ended made me suspicious to be honest. At the moment I just want to see a bit more from Bell to be sure of if Engineer had anti - town intentions, or if it was just an explanation like DSJ's. I really dislike DSJ's justification for his quick hammer but I really don't know if its scum indicative. The game was dead.

This is what I meant Dst. You chose or missed this vote count and ignored Jam explicitly declining to vote you.

[Bell]

Nah probably just echo, when 1 mafia starts to lurk I find the other one follows

VOTE: echo

Explain what you mean here?

[EchoVision]

What do you think Echo?

voting me bc of "lurking" aka not posting for 36 hours because my life doesn't resolve around mafia is stupid but oh well, shit happens

yall know my opinions on tcowley, i'm stubborn as shit so
dsj's just kinda been coasting in my eyes, hasn't done anything notably positive or negative

i'm certain it's one of those two, and i'm 80% sure it's tcowley but i have worse tunnel vision than a miner so

but anyways i thought i did this earlier, VOTE: tcowley

[Bell]

Why do you think it's tcowley?

[Bell]

He was put to L1 by Jam. Close to deadline. it seems less likely than Dst.

[dsjstr]

Spoiler:

Vote count 2.04

with 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to make a decision. day 2 ends in (expired on 2020-07-19 10:00:00)

.

elimination

Bell [3]:

innocentvillager, TCowley, JamSV

dsjstr [2]:

Dunnstral, Bell

Dunnstral [1]:

dsjstr

innocentvillager [1]:

EchoVision

Not Voting [0]:

Rubber Ducky (Ruberius Duckimus)

mod notes

• ... quack
  
• click here to view this VC along with all of datisi's VCs!

Can the people on the Bell wagon explain why they still think he is mafia. He's been like the only one searching for info.

I was waiting for an explanation behind 187, because he basically expressed intent to hammer, and I wanted to check if it was indeed intent to hammer, or just, if push comes to shove. I felt as if it was him trying to set up a safe hammer on Aray by claiming to do it preemptively, but him not responding to 187 before the day ended made me suspicious to be honest. At the moment I just want to see a bit more from Bell to be sure of if Engineer had anti - town intentions, or if it was just an explanation like DSJ's. I really dislike DSJ's justification for his quick hammer but I really don't know if its scum indicative. The game was dead.

This is what I meant Dst. You chose or missed this vote count and ignored Jam explicitly declining to vote you.

You replaced engineer... so Jam joined your wagon before you put me to H-2.

[dsjstr]

Also EoD he was not really playing which is how the vote ended up switching to him, I suspect that it might have been because his partner echo had started to lurk unlike during D1.

[Bell]

I know he was already voting me. But he rationalized one over the other.
I will hurt my own argument here and point out that I didn't realize how quickly the votes changed from me to Echo. Dun was one of the ones who moved his vote so 'your turn' isn't quite right, as there wasn't much time for Jam to switch his vote.

[Bell]

Dstjstr could you explain based on your play why you aren't mafia?

[dsjstr]

Probably not I don't remember if I did anything to specifically to seem town.

[Bell]

Sorry Dst, I just think you're mafia this game and I'm fairly confident about it. Thanks for playing ball.

[dsjstr]

What answer were you expecting?