Posted: Fri Aug 07, 2020 4:17 am
In post 373, ready2rock wrote:What's the case on ydrasse? I have her as slight town right now
yeah midway is right, this progression does look kinda weakIn post 497, ready2rock wrote:OK put some thought into it, and have 3 thoughts
1. I trust IV and the way he cc'ed
2. I'm trusting of what other people are saying about setup stuff since quite a few people are coming to similar conclusions
3. I think trying to rush to an elim of anyone else at this stage of the day would bereallybad for town
So all of these lead me to VOTE: Ydrasse
I made 4 posts in between thisIn post 527, CantHateAPuppy wrote:In post 373, ready2rock wrote:What's the case on ydrasse? I have her as slight town right nowyeah midway is right, this progression does look kinda weakIn post 497, ready2rock wrote:OK put some thought into it, and have 3 thoughts
1. I trust IV and the way he cc'ed
2. I'm trusting of what other people are saying about setup stuff since quite a few people are coming to similar conclusions
3. I think trying to rush to an elim of anyone else at this stage of the day would bereallybad for town
So all of these lead me to VOTE: Ydrasse
Good point.In post 529, ready2rock wrote:I made 4 posts in between this
So I guess yeah, the progression looks pretty weak if you take away, y'know, any context of a progression
If Dunnstral is Town, Ready2rock looks bad here.In post 391, ready2rock wrote:I mean if I'm outvoted then I'm outvoted, but I think Dunn looks way scummier, and while I think MG's point is the most solid against ydarsse right now, I'm still not convinced
How has Dunn provided any help or benefit to the town? The reason I held off on a scumread or vote was to give him the time to start scumhunting or posting any substantial content, and he just...hasn't
I mean you held this opinion even after the claims came out, so if I'd come out looking bad what would that say about you?In post 457, Blair wrote:I don't like this.In post 452, innocentvillager wrote:I am only as confident as the information I am getting from you guys
Retracting intent.
He's counter-claiming without telling us his roleortaking any responsibility for the outcome.
I'd rather launch Dunnstral today and let the PR claims self-sort.
Of all the ways scum could try to set themselves up to un-bus, that would have to be the worst.In post 534, ready2rock wrote:I mean you held this opinion even after the claims came out, so if I'd come out looking bad what would that say about you?In post 457, Blair wrote:I don't like this.In post 452, innocentvillager wrote:I am only as confident as the information I am getting from you guys
Retracting intent.
He's counter-claiming without telling us his roleortaking any responsibility for the outcome.
I'd rather launch Dunnstral today and let the PR claims self-sort.
Also, someone earlier brought up Ydarsse's interactions with dunn, what do you make of them and how does it affect your read on dunn?
So this went unresponded to and wasn't good enough for you, apparentlyIn post 463, innocentvillager wrote:@blair I mean sure you can launch me tomorrow if this doesn’t flip red lol. I’ve told you I’m a full Neapolitan Gunsmith or Cop. I don’t really understand setup spec. What else do you need from me
And this was followed a few posts later by you trying to get momentum on a counter-wagon goingIn post 476, innocentvillager wrote:This was the only instance I found in the Normal Setups where a Town Gunsmith was in the same setup as a Town Modified Regular Cop. Thoughts?
Moderator:ThinkBig
Current Update:Game Over [Awaiting Archiving]
Player List:
- SergTacos,
, killed night 2Vanilla Townie
- Klazam,
, survivedVanilla Townie
- Trivium,
, lynched day 2Vanilla Townie
- Umlaut
replaced Boonskiies,, lynched day 4Town Odd-Night Cop
- TwoFace,
, killed night 4Vanilla Townie
- Empiricus,
, survivedVanilla Townie
- Mulch,
, survivedVanilla Townie
- Carcalilly,
, killed night 1Mafia Odd-Night Roleblocker
- Tchill13,
, lynched day 1Mafia Goon
- Fykus,
, lynched day 5Mafia Goon
- Branson,
, lynched day 3Vanilla Townie
- Vedith
replaced shuffleplay,, killed night 1Town Vigilante
- Dunkerdoodles,
, killed night 3Town Gunsmith
I admit that all I did was ctrl-f your iso for "Ydrasse," but I don't see anything else that shows much more of a progression. Blair's point about you v Dunn feels good too. This post has an edge of too much defense in it, and I'm trying to decide if that's town or notIn post 529, ready2rock wrote:I made 4 posts in between this
So I guess yeah, the progression looks pretty weak if you take away, y'know, any context of a progression
For the record, I didn't have her read as scum based on the content of her posts at all, nothing really jumped out to me (aside from what I said at 387, which wasn't clear cut enough to me to sway me to a vote), so I don't think I would've voted her if it hadn't been for IV counter claiming
And to answer your question earlier, I think off wagon is more likely, mostly because I read most of the people on wagon as town atm, while the people off wagon have largely been null to scum for me
I explained the progression in my last post, but I'll state it again if it wasn't clear. I was definitely in the camp of Dunn looking scummier, and wanting to push for him to be launched, and probably would've continued to be until the end of the day (as evidenced by my next two posts). Then, the cc happened and was very believable to me, and that made me have to rethink my readings and decide what I thought was the best thing to do, and eventually I decided that not hammering would open the floodgates for some last second flash wagon to try to go on someone, which would have close to zero chance of actually catching someone, and so I liked the chances of IV telling the truth and Ydarsse being successfully cc'ed better.In post 539, CantHateAPuppy wrote:I admit that all I did was ctrl-f your iso for "Ydrasse," but I don't see anything else that shows much more of a progression. Blair's point about you v Dunn feels good too. This post has an edge of too much defense in it, and I'm trying to decide if that's town or notIn post 529, ready2rock wrote:I made 4 posts in between this
So I guess yeah, the progression looks pretty weak if you take away, y'know, any context of a progression
For the record, I didn't have her read as scum based on the content of her posts at all, nothing really jumped out to me (aside from what I said at 387, which wasn't clear cut enough to me to sway me to a vote), so I don't think I would've voted her if it hadn't been for IV counter claiming
And to answer your question earlier, I think off wagon is more likely, mostly because I read most of the people on wagon as town atm, while the people off wagon have largely been null to scum for me
The only interaction between Dunnstral and Ydrasse that I consider noteworthy at this point is when Dunnstral stated intent to hammer on Ydrasse - but Ydrasse claimed Cop two posts later so it really just doubles down my confirmation bias that it looked coordinated.In post 538, ready2rock wrote:I'd still like my second question answered btw about Dunn
In post 535, ready2rock wrote:Previous post is to Blair if that wasn't clear
@Dunn, do you have some substantial reason/case for voting Blair? Because it's feeling pretty OMGUS to me right now
Her push isn't something she believes inIn post 536, midwaybear wrote:yeah, why is Blair scummy?
peepin the meh block aka {launchy, midway, goon, battle mage}In post 268, Ydrasse wrote:also ngl reading this game feels like i'm looking at a blob of "meh" with a few light trs (hi inno, hi blair) thrown in there which makes parsing through it all feel like my brain is turning into goo. i don't know what that means mafia is doing other than either blending in or just... not playing right now which means we're all kind of half-heartedly pointing fingers at each other hoping something sticks.
that sentiment implicates nosferatu, dunn and r2r if going off of like, strictly numbers. of them i like nosferatu the most bc of that dunn/blair thing. i think r2r isn't look the best but i vibed with some of their points regarding bm thus the unvote. i don't think it's foolproof like they are town 100% of the time but i can follow their logic without having to twist and reach for it so i don't wanna vote them rn
In post 415, Umlaut wrote:
wagonomics say its the kiddIn post 501, Umlaut wrote:
oh haha omgus