Mafiascum.net

Noting - at this point - both scum wouldn't be voted for same player - too riskly

Rathe (3): T3, Andante, Ivyeo
Andante (2): RationalMadman, Rathe
orctin (2): Clasko, JacksonVirgo
Clasko (1): Demainer

So those players voted on same player - are not teamed together in my opinion - so even if we miss-elim i would lean to knowing a couple of townies

I don't even think Rathe is a good vote here, why would scum tunnel the doc claim? I'm not certain outside these 2 though

Says doc claim rather than Doc.

Says Doc rather than Doctor (Doc would be howbthey chatted in scumchat about the idea, not Doctor but reading a role PM and tellimg it would feel serious, she'd say Doctor)
After it tunnels antone votimg her, now outs a townread on the person she is wanting town to bandwagon

In post 528, RationalMadman wrote:Says doc claim rather than Doc.

Says Doc rather than Doctor (Doc would be howbthey chatted in scumchat about the idea, not Doctor but reading a role PM and tellimg it would feel serious, she'd say Doctor)
After it tunnels antone votimg her, now outs a townread on the person she is wanting town to bandwagon

And you call be conf-biased

In post 529, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 528, RationalMadman wrote:Says doc claim rather than Doc.

Says Doc rather than Doctor (Doc would be howbthey chatted in scumchat about the idea, not Doctor but reading a role PM and tellimg it would feel serious, she'd say Doctor)
After it tunnels antone votimg her, now outs a townread on the person she is wanting town to bandwagon

And you call me conf-biased

Edited

In post 522, orctin wrote:scum can decide to eliminate Rational tonight just to make the game thread less aggressive (and we probably would all shoot him if we could, lets be honest) - and we carry on the next day

Is this a slip?

Whatever poor soul would shoot someone as useful to Town as me is hilarious. Hope that you vote Andante and then them (just kidding this game has no gun).

Rathe flips Town here.

Regardless of them being flat out wrong and acting scummy as bat shit, I don't think scum would push this hard to eliminate a Doc who can get NKed pretty easily with no repercussions. Doctor claim is Town, or at least should not be eliminated today especially with no counterclaim.

{ T3, Ivyeo, Demainer, orctin, Clasko } being the pool we should eliminate from.
I would prefer an Orc flip personally.

In post 532, RationalMadman wrote:Whatever poor soul would shoot someone as useful to Town as me is hilarious. Hope that you vote Andante and then them (just kidding this game has no gun).

What are you saying.

In post 532, RationalMadman wrote:Whatever poor soul would shoot someone as useful to Town as me is hilarious. Hope that you vote Andante and then them (just kidding this game has no gun).

You haven't been useful, you've been antagonistic the whole game, basically playing as if this is a one man game and the rest of us are along for the ride

In post 531, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 522, orctin wrote:scum can decide to eliminate Rational tonight just to make the game thread less aggressive (and we probably would all shoot him if we could, lets be honest) - and we carry on the next day

Is this a slip?

where i play used to mafia shooting people as their night action - no idea how it's worded here, if i see different then i will word different

In post 536, orctin wrote:You haven't been useful, you've been antagonistic the whole game, basically playing as if this is a one man game and the rest of us are along for the ride

From everyone's perspective that is the case. What is your one man ride doing? Why are you voting nobody?

Reading back Rathe's immediate vote on Andante after her Doctor claim is concerning - i think at this point even if Rathe isn't eliminated Day 1 scum will have hard time not night killing them the coming night - it was too quick a reaction to not do so, which if true would make Andante scum. It's the only logic to Rathe's quick vote i can see.

I mean even a scum player should have a pause to the claim instead of the quick vote.

In post 538, RationalMadman wrote:

In post 536, orctin wrote:You haven't been useful, you've been antagonistic the whole game, basically playing as if this is a one man game and the rest of us are along for the ride

From everyone's perspective that is the case. What is your one man ride doing? Why are you voting nobody?

After backing of the vote on you just cause i disliked your playstyle i'm waiting for a reason to vote - hoping to find something more logical than "they scum read me" or "you wont answer me" - or what ever else some quick votes have been based on so far. Plus i was out for couple days so been reading back and letting the couple days allow me some fresh perspective there.

In post 539, orctin wrote:i think at this point even if Rathe isn't eliminated Day 1 scum will have hard time not night killing them the coming night

You are seriously obsessed with the scum NK. Why would that be

In post 537, orctin wrote:

In post 531, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 522, orctin wrote:scum can decide to eliminate Rational tonight just to make the game thread less aggressive (and we probably would all shoot him if we could, lets be honest) - and we carry on the next day

Is this a slip?

where i play used to mafia shooting people as their night action - no idea how it's worded here, if i see different then i will word different

afaik just "eliminate" is used here, or "attack"

Welcome

Welcome!

Hi all!

Does anyone have an update while I read up properly?
I saw juicy claims I think!

In post 546, VFP wrote:Hi all!

Does anyone have an update while I read up properly?
I saw juicy claims I think!

Andante claimed Doctor.
Rational and Rathe both want to wagon them anyway and make Town not cc if there is one.
It's been a general 2v2 attack from Rational/Rathe and myself and Andante. With us trying to explain how stupid it is to not ask for ccs here.

Rational basically choosing to fall into confbias while telling everyone else it's confbias that they are not wagoning Andante. I say plenty of logic as to why ccing here is the best play, why Andante is likely town etc but they choose to actively ignore that every single time.

In post 319, Andante wrote:whatever, I'm claiming, I'm the doctor, I'm literally dead tonight, so go find scum. thanks. I'm actually getting annoyed by the nonstop pushing on me from you

In post 321, Rathe wrote:VOTE: andante

In post 327, RationalMadman wrote:But I am willing to vote this through to elimination without Rathe outing if everyone agrees Rathe is strobgly implying something here.

In post 331, RationalMadman wrote:I don't say I'm not a PR that rules Doc out. I say I am not Doc, just so we are crystal clear what I am claiming. Hypothetically, I am a PR who Pr-reads Rathe here.

Okay, first of all, we never lim the doc claim D1 without any sort of CC.
If we lose a PR to lim a scum, then so be it I couldn't care less.

Second, Andante claiming like this is going to be town. And I might even make them a double voter.

Third, Jackson is 100% town here.

Fourth, Rational is 100% town here.

I got all of that from 319 to 331 while checking Raithe's ISO.

So, Andante, who's scum?

In post 547, JacksonVirgo wrote:Andante claimed Doctor.
Rational and Rathe both want to wagon them anyway and make Town not cc if there is one.
It's been a general 2v2 attack from Rational/Rathe and myself and Andante. With us trying to explain how stupid it is to not ask for ccs here.

Rational basically choosing to fall into confbias while telling everyone else it's confbias that they are not wagoning Andante. I say plenty of logic as to why ccing here is the best play, why Andante is likely town etc but they choose to actively ignore that every single time.

Unlucky for them we aren't going to lim the Doc claim.

I'll also stand strong that Qndante claims early as town PR. I am not going.to discuss further on this though.

Who's scum for you Jackson?