In post 5116, Titan wrote:Penguins pretty much going to bat for bro being town, depending on how he plays it today I guess, but she's talking me down fro
1) You
just
modded a game where I was mislynched as town, and a lot of my emotionality (at least the genuineness of it) is the same in this game as it was there.
2) You also saw the dead QT for that game where penguin and I had a fairly extensive convo about how neither of us can read each other to save our lives.
1) I
modded
the game. I didn't have to read you in that game because I already knew your alignment. If you'll note my suspicions of you continued because you didn't feel like the Wicked game or our talks afterwards in the dead thread.
2) She's in part leaning town on you because she said the meltdown was genuine. At first she said that the meltdown looking genuine wasn't necessarily alignment indicative but then as she read she said she thought you were town.
In post 5207, Titan wrote:I'm not the running around calling Cassandra on him.
Is it wrong I'm feeling slightly amused that someone is declaring KNOWLEDGE I'm scum when I'm as town as I've ever been.
I mean for someone so attuned to my meta, it seems extraordinarily unlikely I'd get paranoid about someone over night. Shit how many times have I paranoid voted someone, then talked it out. For someone who knows I get paranoid?
Point out a game where you non-RVS voted me ever before?
Point out a game where I was saying there was scum in your neighborhood, haven't had you strong town, and you looked like you were setting me up for something that I can't even imagine coming from scum you.
And just so you know this oh I knew it I knew it is completely wrong.
Like seriously, if you actually think I'm scum here, you've definitely lost the right to read me.
And nacho shut up. Yes, I'm suspicious but I'm hella far from ready to roast him over a pit.
I am not the one voting you, you are.
What the hell was up with the whole "he's not playing like AoT or Wicked but still could be scum because Nacho showed him shit?"
Nacho and I were hydra'ing in your modded game. It is not like we went to a far-off island where he taught me ninja tricks or something. It all happened right under your nose. You still said I was bad as scum in the dead QT while you watched. Like seriously, what did you expect that I supposedly learned that I didn't show right in your game?
I'm not the one shouting from the rooftop you're scum you're scum you're scum either.
YOu don't think it's possible you could learn some confidence about your scum game from hydraing with nacho? And if, as I was toying with, that you're scum with him again? I don't remember calling you bad at scum, there were some obvious scum posts TO ME but I knew your alignment there and as I pointed out most times with people I had confirmation bias there because I already knew your alignment.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 2:59 pm
by CarbonFiber
Ugh, just got back. Tammy as scum doesn't make any sense whatsoever. I'm going to respond to all of those posts in a bit.
In post 5140, Titan wrote:I can't believe you of all people are asking me about that hammer. It was two days until deadline. The lynch wasn't going anywhere else. The games over 290 pages long, and the most of the discussion has been after mastin and then mastin making a fucktin of walls tha weren't giving anyone a clear read on him except more suspicions. What the hell do you think was going to happen in two days especially with the only person you trust to run the town and des/bro REFUSING to d anything else besides sit in that fucking neighborhood.
I personally would have hammered. I didn't expect you to hammer because it's not what you do. You wait and wait and wait until the very last second before you make a decision.
It looked like you didn't want the lynch to switch to AP and wanted to grab this lynch while you can and also not let Mastin react to your vote on him.
Why did you never, ever, ever vote for days and days and as soon as he was brought to L-1, immediately claimed the hammer?
How now?
Do you really think the lynch would have switched to AP? Are you serious? For two entire days Mastin was the discussion of the lynch. AP is a claimed cop, your neighborhood wouldn't do anything besides lynch Mastin, you only trusted Pie to lead the town in the first place, where do you actually think that lynch would have switched to AP?
I just don't understand how you can't see how Mastin was going to be the lynch. There was going to be nothing but two more days worth of the same thing. Noone was changing their minds.
You know what I love. Pere accused me of distracting from the Mastin lynch, while I was trying to read Mastin. And I hammer and you're accusing me of distracting from some other non existent happening lynch.
Quite frankly when you unvoted Mastin at the end of the day, it looked suspicious to me after Mastin flipped town. I thought you were trying to demonstrate fake uncertainty on the lynch you'd been pushing the entire time and that you decided that actually the noise would be more beneficial to have around than lose.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:07 pm
by magenta_thegreat
Hey, Tammy would you mind leaving carbon alone for a while and entertain me?
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:10 pm
by Titan
In post 5306, magenta_thegreat wrote:Hey, Tammy would you mind leaving carbon alone for a while and entertain me?
Do you want me to do cartwheels?
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:12 pm
by magenta_thegreat
assuming you're young enough as it won't break any bones, sure!
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:13 pm
by CarbonFiber
In post 5116, Titan wrote:It's nice to know my one and only certain town read is town, and not dead so thank iomedae for that!
So, you guys gonna come out of the neighborhood now and stop circle jerking about how right you are. I still feel like there's scum in that neighborhood.
Penguins pretty much going to bat for bro being town, depending on how he plays it today I guess, but she's talking me down fro
M my des/bro bloodthirst so it's up t you boys. Do something!
VOTE: carbon fiber
I'll answer you when I'm at my computer.
If there is scum in the neighborhood, it is probably Nacho.
I don't trust Penguin at all and I think she's scum defending town.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:14 pm
by magenta_thegreat
^ Mara
But I'd also like to know where your other scumreads are outside of falcon
I am Yuri Lowell, Town Lone Wolf (modified vig), Tales of Vesperia (you can guess the modification). I didn't shoot last night because I wanted to see Rancid's flip. I shot him night1 because he was total scum (even if he flipped green).
Going home, but want that out there for discussion. I'll try to check in tonight.
You shouldn't have claimed. Scum know to roleblock you now but at least that's one additional person we can eliminate as being scum.
Breakfast is probtown but I don't trust AP obviously so I'm not buying the "result."
In post 5229, AngryPidgeon wrote:Also, someone is being ridiculously dead-pan about events in the thread and I think they are skyrocketing to my favorite lynch rather quickly.
I kind of expected someone to bite on this or at least play 20 questions with me.
Buuuuut no one has, so I'll say that these posts have stuck out like a sore thumb:
Its like Magenta became a robot over the night phase.
Did anybody use a robot-izer on Magenta or are they just scum?
I thought at the time you were referring to JSU and was waiting to see how that played out.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:20 pm
by CarbonFiber
In post 5140, Titan wrote:I can't believe you of all people are asking me about that hammer. It was two days until deadline. The lynch wasn't going anywhere else. The games over 290 pages long, and the most of the discussion has been after mastin and then mastin making a fucktin of walls tha weren't giving anyone a clear read on him except more suspicions. What the hell do you think was going to happen in two days especially with the only person you trust to run the town and des/bro REFUSING to d anything else besides sit in that fucking neighborhood.
I was tired. I'd had enough. The distraction wasn't going to end and on top of that I'm fucking sick as shit and didn't have the patience for another 50 pages of the same damn thing.
I thought he might be scum and if you read any of m posts you'd know that I was a the pit that I thought his lynch would be the best thing regardless.
And your asking me why I hammered?
Spoiler: why I hammered
Penguin told me someone would be opportunistic and come after me for that hammer. What I'd like to know is why'd you unvote? After pushing him all day and then going we should lynch angry pigeon? And why did nacho never vote even whoe pushing the worlds largest case on him?
I laughed when penguin said someone would be opportunistic and come after me for the hammer, I just never in a million years thought it would be you.
Okay. I didn't read this post earlier but it makes more sense to vote me once I questioned you about it.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:20 pm
by CarbonFiber
In post 5142, AngryPidgeon wrote:Wait so BOTH Stalin and RG are claiming that they are 100% sure they were blocked.
I was not blocked.
CF, you use your power any time during the day right?
Can everyone not yet in a hood claim their game? I need to look mine up...Tales of HEarts / Spir Maze.
I agree. Let's make a list first.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:21 pm
by fferyllt
In post 5298, magenta_thegreat wrote:Not really, no. The reason is largely selfish, but I've no doubt there are townspeople with age limitations to their PR's.
Also assuming all the scum have age limitations to their roles, they already have at most, 8 people in this game who they know are adult/child while those who are town have at most, two
Can you explain the bolded?
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 3:21 pm
by CarbonFiber
In post 5144, Titan wrote:This is fucking bullshit. On the off chance you're town and actually think there's a snails chance I'm scum, you should give up playing mafia.
In post 5298, magenta_thegreat wrote:Not really, no. The reason is largely selfish, but I've no doubt there are townspeople with age limitations to their PR's.
Also assuming all the scum have age limitations to their roles, they already have at most, 8 people in this game who they know are adult/child while those who are town have at most, two
In post 5298, magenta_thegreat wrote:Not really, no. The reason is largely selfish, but I've no doubt there are townspeople with age limitations to their PR's.
Also assuming all the scum have age limitations to their roles, they already have at most, 8 people in this game who they know are adult/child while those who are town have at most, two
Can you explain the bolded?
Assuming scum roles only work on one of kids/adults, the fact that they have fail/success during the past two nights would lead them to the conclusion of what age group their target belongs in. If each scum targeted different people (which is very likely) the past two nights, they would have age groups of 8 people (2X4=8) while townspeople with same limitation only have the age groups of those they targeted.
with mastin gone, I am unsure who teammember 4 would be, thoughts?
I had AP as scum earlier based on prohawk's posting, but then he claimed that weird cop role so IDK.
Arthur had DV/Ceph as scum on day one due to his buddying of me. They're someone I wanted to reread as day one when I started to think that rancid and mastin were town, I thought that scum were town reading me. DV usually scum reads me when he's scum or throws up fake paranoia, but they seem a little too sure that I'm town.
I'm paranoid of Penguin, but know part of her role is true because it's been confirmed. I don't want to go into that. That part makes me lean town. I don't know if Penguin!scum comes in so strong against Mastin upon replacement. Her reaction to her flip seemed a bit genuine.
I don't even know if I buy Falcon as scum. I just don't want to believe as scum he'd basically tell me knowing that I'm town that I've sucked this game, am deluded and can do better. I just don't think he'd go there. I just think that if he was scum, he'd know that when I say I'm lost I really mean that, and that he'd try to manipulate me in another way.
I don't know. I tossed around you guys being scum but I still liked Orci's interaction with me day one, so it's not something I feel good about. I worry about nacho but Bork's posting around and about Mastin looked town so I keep going back and forth. I worried about Pere but I do like my potential town tell for the quicktopic thing.
I just don't know. I'm hoping this weekend to see if I can make some sense out of things now that the question of Mastin is gone.
