Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Thor665]

So your theory and experience with me as a player suggests that if a scumbuddy was in trouble I'd run and hide until i got prodded - and then directly challenge the case upon return?
Shouldn't I either be trying to stall it or directly oppose it, why both? That doesn't make much sense to me, does it make sense to you?

Also, it doesn't answer my question.

[Ranmaru]

You were gone for a little over 72 hours. The last time I have seen you as scum, I think you avoided scum Oomba. Thor, I assume you have caught up. What are your reads right now? Read on me? Why does my answer not satisfy you?

[Thor665]

My last post was Thursday my time and then i posted Sunday my time - you can claim it as however many hours you want - that it was the weekend remains a fact. What are you shopping here now?

I soft town you.
I don't have any screaming scum reads.
Your answer doesn't satisfy me because...well, it doesn't actually address the question of why scum him would push a town Vig, which was the question.
Your answer was "it keeps mislynch options open" which is daft. You're, at best, arguing he went in on a hard push on a town role *with a killing power* and he did so to leave more low lying fruit for later?
That is an idiotic scum plan.
Why do you think it's his scum plan compared to his town play?
Your best answer fo rthat is that Gamma and I are apparently scum derp protecting our scumbuddy in a stupid way.
Ooooh, and 48 hours over the weekend isn't counting Friday and discounts that you posted on Sunday, ooooh!

You're literally just spewing dreck at me when I'm trying to talk to you.
Why?

[Ranmaru]

What made me re-think everything was how weird the A50 kill was. I then thought, what if Orange made a kill on him instead (to implicate klazam marshy and pidgey) which lead me to think: Orange scum may have been killing since Night 2. Which would answer why the kills pointed to Klazam so hard. I knew it sounded crazy but I felt I should have outed that at this phase in the game. I will get to the rest in a bit.

[OnTheMark]

What made me re-think everything was how weird the A50 kill was. I then thought, what if Orange made a kill on him instead (to implicate klazam marshy and pidgey) which lead me to think: Orange scum may have been killing since Night 2. Which would answer why the kills pointed to Klazam so hard. I knew it sounded crazy but I felt I should have outed that at this phase in the game. I will get to the rest in a bit.

I 100% agree it is weird. However it is also weird for Orange too. Why would they draw attention TO the religion spreaders if scum? Even if the theory of there are no religion spreaders if scum is true then that further indicates either
A) Deep Wolf
B) Serial killer

However you just say “No! Shaziro can’t be an SK.” Of which I ask why?

Oh wait you’re calling me scum it can’t be that I have valid points...oh no *rolls eyes*

Also I see your reads request but I am getting ready for work.

[OnTheMark]

It still feels like you’re trying to take credit for what I am thinking then spin it to an entirely different conclusion and that pisses me off.

If the kill is weird for red AND the kill is weird for Orange
Then what is more likely: SK or no SK?

[OnTheMark]

Ran if you're town reconsider what you're saying about gamma and thor.

Mark if you're town reconsider what you're saying about shaziro.

I,hopefully, will have a complete night phase in which to A) reread some portions and
B) If I still believe Shaziro is an SK more eloquently state my point.

[Jodaxq]

It's interesting to see that someone else is growing suspicious of the Joey_ slot. Thor doesn't get lynched today obviously but it needs to be talked about in later days.

[Jodaxq]

I don't buy the 4 man orange team theory. Red wouldn't be close to being balanced. And also I doubt Varsoon is certain of a multiball game if his team were four people.

[Jodaxq]

There hasn't really been much else that's new. This day has run its course I believe.

Also sad to see Gamma go.

[OnTheMark]

There has been a shit ton new.

Wtf? Ranmaru is literally scum claiming all over this thread.

He’s openly destroyed the reasons most people have for assuming an SK is not in the game yet I am still

actively

being tunneled by him for “bad ideas”

[brassherald]

VOTE: Klazam

I've lost interest in this pissing contest.

[OnTheMark]

Proving not scum by not instantly hammering. Will see where the game is after work.

[Thor665]

I think that's better than the Mark wagon.

Shaziro, Ranmaru, Klazam, Jodaxq.

@Brass - which of the above names do you think is most likely scum?
If it's just Klazam we can do that, I just recalled someone making some argument for Klazam town.

[Ranmaru]

Brass, wish you would have waited.

[Ranmaru]

Actually, you can still come back. I think Mark is still scum. I implore you to come back to Mark. I am shopping right now.

[brassherald]

I think that's better than the Mark wagon.

Shaziro, Ranmaru, Klazam, Jodaxq.

@Brass - which of the above names do you think is most likely scum?
If it's just Klazam we can do that, I just recalled someone making some argument for Klazam town.

I hate read lists, but Klazam, Ran, Joda, Shaz in that order.

[Ranmaru]

Brass, I need you to talk to me. I also want you to effort a little more.

[brassherald]

If Thor is on a third 2 person scum team, who is his partner?

[Ranmaru]

Gamma.

[pidgey]

Ran im here

Catching up at the moment but thats a fkn interesting theory

[Ranmaru]

Hey Pidgey. I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on it.

[brassherald]

Gamma.

And why does this pairing work?

I mean, at this time, Gamma just basically left the site for the time being anyway, so maybe a lynch there would not be terrible. I'd only really lynch Thor if the prospective partner flips scum, though.

[pidgey]

You are implying the supposed 2man group was balanced? I love the theory behind your thoughts but it kinda falls flat man. A 2 man group with such weak roles seems too limmited.

And thor as scum would be wild.

But i do think klazam is still misslynch bait a bit

[pidgey]

I mean he is scummy but at times ive felt exactly like hin. Kinda lost