Mafiascum.net

I also bought a cute graphic novel called “The Pineapples of Wrath” which was also a fun read

and that's worst case. best case he's the roleblocker and this game is just over. i think that's unlikely for previously stated reasons, but.

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

it's been a very long time since i've had to argue with a town about whether to lynch the guilty or not in a pre-lylo situation

In post 5316, RadiantCowbells wrote:can you actually read pine's posts?

Are you asking to me

no you don't have to

also uh

if pine isn't scum, why was nomnom roleblocked when she said she was shooting him

i almost forgot that one tbh

Okay. Let's duck out of pure mechanics for a minute and see if I can make subjective reads.



Jingle/Pops

ofhrz

Ausuka
RC

mastina

Pinguin

mastina/Pine is reasonable. Mastina/PP less so. I could see RC/Pine, but I'm frankly okay with losing to that. ofrhz/Pine is ofrhz/PP has some real potential to it. Ausuka/PP leaves us with too little power, I think, assuming that RC/Titus are neutral utility balance wise. Ausuka/Pine is reasonable. RC/PP probably loses here.

So potential scumteams:

RC/PP
Mastina/Pine
ofhrz/PP
Aus/Pine
mastina/PP
Pine/PP

Eliminated from contention

RC/Pine
Aus/PP
ofhrz/Pine

I think town loses if it's ofhrz. So I'm going to stop playing around that. I don't think PP fakeclaims with a hated partner as last scum standing? That seems too risky.

In post 5330, RadiantCowbells wrote:if pine isn't scum, why was nomnom roleblocked when she said she was shooting him

Always rb a vig claim, regardless of who they say they're going to target.

(READ THIS AT YOUR OWN RISK)
If you hydra me I won't read the game but I am online too much so you can chat with me

this is how you overthink a won game and throw it.

if you're worried about RC/PP just treat me as confirmed scum if Pine flips town, done deal.

there's no reason for pine to be able to scrape out another mislynch here and we also loses this a shit ton more often to PP/Pine if we lynch PP first.

Eh, I've talked myself back around to lynch Pine.

And I always overthink games like this. I just usually don't do so in the thread.

Let's overthink the game and lynch JINGLE!

i have considered the possibility of Pine pulling an Elsa Jay and the two hood scum convincing the townie to fake an inno on jingle claiming to bait a nightkill and then kill him.

but it all happened before i was in game so i take no responsibility if that's the reason we lose, soooo

e

i've looked over roster's iso endlessly for a crumb that the inno is fake and haven't found it btw.

i made that up btw.

RC would you be this invested in this game as scum?

no.

if i was scum i'd have posted something about how my contribution to the game would just get who errantly scumread (a la keychain in team mafia) and said deuces.

Did you win at Team Mafia?

i decided that winning wasn't worth the fact that virtually every player in the game that i was in hated the game because of the me/chesskid 1v1.
interestingly despite being the one who tried to tone down the postcount and being the one who stopped I was the one who got shit for it.

the lesson learned is never try to have a conscience in mafia, because no one cares if you ruined the game for everyone if you at least won.

notably i was very clear in scum chat when I said I would no longer be playing to win and at that point chesskid was objectively on a trajectory to being lynched.

It sounds like you didn't have an enjoyable experience.

no one did. TM2018 was objectively a shitshow.