Not Quite Normal Multiball II (Game Over)

[MegAzumarill]

FL should probably be out of contention for killing today and reexamination tomorrow seems wise. (Extra kill data will be nice)

[Nashville Dreams]

Separate from the guilty, there's two players I want today. Meg due to the overwhelming consensus that they were scum yesterday and their awkward push onto FL. Butterchurn due to his repeated and unjustified counterwagoning everything but catboi and tictac.

There's also the no voters who are bad. Normally, I'd say a vig could handle them but there's a push on the alleged vig.

[Nashville Dreams]

so 8 ball
frankly I'm more liable to think FL is mafia than vigi

FL should probably be out of contention for killing today and reexamination tomorrow seems wise. (Extra kill data will be nice)

What exactly is your position here?

[MegAzumarill]

That I find FL probable to be mafia/malefactor but there's no point limming there when we can get much more info about the nature if the catboi kill based on kills tomorrow (determining whether the kill was likely a vig shot or a factional kill for instance)
FL can be tunneled town but I find it less likely since they wouldn't have made that much of a stink yesterday and just quietly shot if they were actually vigi. Course I could be wrong.

Effectively FLs claim gets a lot more or less believable depending on tonight's kill(s) and tomorrow nights kill(s)

[MegAzumarill]

Additionally I'm fairly sure it's just you and FL actively scumreading me for the most part so "overwhelming consensus" is a bit of a misrep

[Nashville Dreams]

So who do you want to eliminate?

[Nashville Dreams]

Additionally I'm fairly sure it's just you and FL actively scumreading me for the most part so "overwhelming consensus" is a bit of a misrep

Oh ok.

VOTE: Meg

Quote retrieval time.

[Klick]

If you find FL to be probable scum you should *not* want him to be in the game longer considering the sheer amount of influence he is capable of having on Day play

That is much more impactful than the info that might be gained by waiting until Night play gives us confirmation or more concrete info

[Nashville Dreams]

VOTE: Flavor Leaf
Vanity mostly

This is viggable.

VOTE: Flavor Leaf
Vanity mostly

This is viggable.

For the first time in a while we are in agreement

VOTE: Flavor Leaf
Vanity mostly

This is viggable.

The 4 stragglers of Catboi wagons were Toogeloo, Tictac, MegA, and Cat Scratch Fever.

Toogeloo and Tictac were the townier ones of those 4, and they're the ones who were wagoned.

We tried to get Cat Scratch going at one point, and it didn't work.

MegA would be who I'd vig if I had a vig, possibly Catboi, but I tend not to vig my main scum reads, but this might have been a special case.

But yeah, Vig Mega.

#vigmeg

[MegAzumarill]

Probably the ydrasse guilty but besides that it'd probably be you

I plan to reread catboi ISO as some not werewolf verdicts should be applicable

[SCP 682]

people really intentionally ignoring the fact FL claimed vig during the night phase before any of these "guilties" came out

[MegAzumarill]

you did pull the people I said + 2 people with 1 line.
So not actively scumreading

[Nashville Dreams]

reading some posts does not mean they have been reading most posts.

But reading some posts should be enough to have some opinions.

Yet you're fine with Meg hinting she has reads she won't disclose, giving no reads, defending Toog and dodging a catboi read?

That should die over honest drowning.

MEG IS ALSO SCUM

we can't eliminate 3 people in 1 day here

there are NINE SCUM

we cant get them all at the same time.

[MegAzumarill]

ok fair enough

[Klick]

If you find FL to be probable scum you should *not* want him to be in the game longer considering the sheer amount of influence he is capable of having on Day play

That is much more impactful than the info that might be gained by waiting until Night play gives us confirmation or more concrete info

This was

@ MegAzumarill

[Nashville Dreams]

meg can totally be scum. That whole "but we need to use more of the clock" is LAMISTT.

[MegAzumarill]

If you find FL to be probable scum you should *not* want him to be in the game longer considering the sheer amount of influence he is capable of having on Day play

That is much more impactful than the info that might be gained by waiting until Night play gives us confirmation or more concrete info

True but I dont expect FL to live very long regardless of alignmentand if they are in fact scum this is more associative to look into

[SCP 682]

klick wont address it bc he is also scum btw

[Enchant]

Why claim vig at night phase though.

Like, aren't it safer on day.

[SCP 682]

inconvenient facts as they say

[Klick]

people really intentionally ignoring the fact FL claimed vig during the night phase before any of these "guilties" came out

klick wont address it bc he is also scum btw

My honest take is that FL's impact on the Day state is negative enough that eliminating him now is what is most likely to help the town start working towards a win. I ALSO think he's rather likely scum at this point, and that FL's claim is entirely conceivable from Mafia who suspects a Gunsmith could exist. But I'm valuing the first bit much higher than the second bit at the moment.

[SCP 682]

scummy

[MegAzumarill]

You do know vigis can be scum aligned right?
And why wouldn't you claim in night phase if you were planning on faking vigi and knew Noone in the monastery could kill you for it?

[SCP 682]

you vote FL on the basis of the GS claim -> get proven that FL crumbed a role already -> still maintain the push based on hastily drawn reasons

thats a scumclaim folks

[SCP 682]

You do know vigis can be scum aligned right?
And why wouldn't you claim in night phase if you were planning on faking vigi and knew Noone in the monastery could kill you for it?

No