Mafiascum.net

Oh! I was fucking right. Grrr Pooky. Fen was a surprise. But I think we got this.

In post 5420, SirCakez wrote:Top of my list are Xof and Raya

Town list or scum list? :I

Scum

Am I 3rd then?

I dunno with you honestly

ngl I'm not used to seeing Flow live this long.

So again I'm not seeing the Xof read, and honeslty raya seems to have a natural scumminess to her so you might have to help me with that one.

Given we might be out of cat mafia, me claiming at this point might not actually be bad idea. It just seemed like a particularly bad one yesterday. So if that's what people need from me, I am willing to do that. Because I'm not scum, but I don't think I've done a particularly good job at my role.

Well now that you've said that, you probably should. And yeah I think it's likely that we are out of cat mafia.

In post 5429, SirCakez wrote:I dunno with you honestly

Usually it goes Scummy->Towny->No Clue but we can skip the middle step ;P

In post 5431, xofelf wrote:Given we might be out of cat mafia, me claiming at this point might not actually be bad idea. It just seemed like a particularly bad one yesterday. So if that's what people need from me, I am willing to do that. Because I'm not scum, but I don't think I've done a particularly good job at my role.

I don't oppose this if you want to

Okay so, I'm Curious George, and I'm the opposite to Farkran in that I protect against cat attacks only. I don't think I've stopped anything so far, and we never had anyone claim to be a cat cop or anything so mostly I've just been putting protection on people I liked having them post, and a couple nights ago I protected Shiro because Titus suggested leaving them alive.

What is your full selection?

Kazyan>kdowns>Shiro>kdowns>something_smart

Like I said, not been doing a great job >.>

You protected only town so it seems like a pretty good job to me. In multiball that's more important than guessing the kill correctly.

Though I do think Psyche was a really obvious cat kill the night they died. Obviously the dogs were going for kdowns.

I suppose there is that! I do remember that I picked kdowns that second time solely because the way the day had gone before, I was unsure on pretty much everybody *except* kdowns, and better than not submitting. I didn't want to protect somebody that i'd regret protecting ya know?

...you didn't want to protect the person I had just cleared because you didn't trust them?

No, I was also a little bit behind and didn't catch up until the next day so I hadn't caught that you had cleared them. So bad play on my part.

In post 5438, xofelf wrote:Kazyan>kdowns>Shiro>kdowns>something_smart

Like I said, not been doing a great job >.>

Do you remember the reasoning for each

Kazyan I really really liked how they were posting and I wanted more of it. kdowns the first time "well, it's a power role and i may not be good against dogs but it's something, right?", Shiro was because of the thing Titus said about keeping them alive, kdowns again was "I'm real busy atm, and game focus is shot, and this is at least a person i *know* is town and what else does he got, maybe this will work?", S_S was "Okay who still in this game do I think is good and solid and *needs* to be here tomorrow for us to win this."

In post 5445, xofelf wrote:S_S was "Okay who still in this game do I think is good and solid and *needs* to be here tomorrow for us to win this."

Why did SS need to be here?

As I said, good and solid. S_S and cakez kinda feel like the two people who have been talking about the game in a way that I both understand, and articulate their thoughts in a way that if they are saying or doing things that don't make sense given the state of everything, you can probably figure it out. And I flipped a coin between them. Like the people left in the game, Pooky I personally wasn't jiving with so if he went whatever he flipped that problem would be solved and I didn't exactly want to protect him. You flow trap are an enigma, but a harmless one, so I didn't have that feel of needing you around. Flea too fits in that box. BHL I still put in that box of concern, so I wasn't going to protect them. Raya I figured would carry into the next day and likely not be targetted at all as if she's town, she's a good suspicion magnet for any scum around. And I don't think I can protect myself(I never asked and it doesn't explicitly say I can't), and I wouldn't anyway. Shiro was like fine and didn't feel like a somebody I needed to protect, though it seems I was wrong about that. And Fen didn't feel like he was contributing in a way that him staying was super important, I didn't even consider he could be scum. So yeah, that's... my thought process on last night.

Xofelf's claim sounds believable as long as we don't get a counterclaim. I need to reassess my reads. I was really thinking they were the alien

In post 5448, Raya36 wrote:Xofelf's claim sounds believable

Is it a puddle or a piece though