Mafiascum.net

The 3 guitarists are Holcomb, Mansoor, and Bowen?

Bois, Murphy, and GEtgood were also guitarists for a long period

You don't know which 3 specifically?

In post 5424, TiphaineDeath wrote:Am I the only sane one left in this game? I think the answer must be yes because it was just me and DGB and some idiot killed her....

yes let the hate flow through you

In post 5412, a2rudeboy wrote:

In post 5409, pisskop wrote:Who is scum. Can we not play the willing victim here?

Since I have currently voted Dave, one would believe that that is who I think is scum.

lol

VOTE: dave dave is scummy enough

In post 5445, a2rudeboy wrote:Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

So, maybe I wasn't paying much attention before, and I think it'd be damn too hard for me to reread 200+ pages, so I decided to read from where I am, and mix that with some logic (at least it's logic from MY PoV).

- Gamma: Very likely Town. Proof: I am still alive
- Pooky: Who the hell knows with this guy. He's "good company" regardless, but I can't read him for shit
- Lav: Town: Reason: Inexplicable visit claim to FGB which instantly made the latter conf!Town her. I'll go with that.
- Bambi: Again, who the hell knows? His win con could literally be "Love long enough to have used up all your abilities and you leave the game a winner"
- TD: Nothing so far. I remember having TR's him earlier, but I don't remember why. Currently NULL
- Grendel: I remember he made a string entrance to the game that doesn't come from Scum IMHO. Ton Lean
- NPOM: The Towniest Townie that has ever Towned in this game. This "untidy" thought process combined with such loudness and a touch of "not caring how it looks on me" NEVER comes from Scum. Lacking conviction and flip/flopping is also more likely a Town trait, because there simply doesn't seem to be any agenda or pre-planned objective behind it.
- A50: That guys is scummy to me. He barely beats Lavender activity-wise.
- pisskop: Overall, that's a townie slot. Don't ask for specifics because with PK everything can be interpreted either way. It's probably WHEN he says/does things that matter, so it's more of a matter of conception rather than solid reasoning
- Drew: Believe it or not I can't make up my mind about this one. He sometimes comes across as pretty townie and other times comes across as vaguely scummy.
- rude: I don't remember why exactly I town!binned this guy, but it has been a steady read all over and I never had him below a Town Lean, so not gonna go for his elimination any time soon. (Gun-to-head he's my 2nd strongest TR after NPOM)
- dave: He's been town!binned just because it's easier that way. With dave I do NOT look for "town tells"m but rather for "SCUM tells" and he hasn't shown any (unless I missed it while skimming)

Som you see my dilemma is still that I have nothing solid to push anyone in particular, and way too few SRs than O probably should have.

I probably should do some ISOing next, although I suck at it (reading posts out of context and natural sequence is often misleading to me), but I shall try anyhow.

Btw, I probably shouldn't count this game towards my stats either way because I really didn't actually play in it. Maybe I can change that and consequently convince myself I did something on D6?? Remains to be seen

In post 5431, Grendel wrote:Well... why not be that ray of light who'll jump start thread activity?

Im sure you could if you pushed yourself.

Sure. How about we cross-vote and have a fight (and I mean the "you, no you" kind of fight that leads to nowhere)?

In post 5445, a2rudeboy wrote:Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

Juicy! Did anyone flip from that band yet?

P-edit: I guess not. So a massclaim of flavour should do the trick. Yes?

A massclaim of flavor might have worked before the reveal. Doesn't work now for what should be obvious reasons.

Holdup, did rude just say that he has role info that NPOM is scum and hasn't been voting him? What? I am so lost :/

No, rude said he has flavor information that two other flavors (from a set of larger possible flavors) are in the game and different alignment.
I think this implies 3p must be in the game so would be a good idea to look at rude for evidence of either pushing or dismissing the idea of 3p.

In post 5461, TiphaineDeath wrote:Holdup, did rude just say that he has role info that NPOM is scum and hasn't been voting him? What? I am so lost :/

That's not how I interpreted it, although I can see that as a valid interpretation from your PoV.

What I got is "3 guitarists of the same band are in-play, and they're not ALL aligned", so it's a 50-50? It could also be that rude thinks one of them could be scum and the other is 3P (i.e. NONE of them is aligned with the other 2).

Yeah, I would appreciate an explanation from rude there, although I am inclined to think he has "more info than he is telling us" based on his D1/D2 behaviour towards NPOM. This is also where I thought rude was hinting NPOM might be 3P (and precisely a Jester, iirc).

But anyway, NPOM already said his flavour is NOT the same as rude's, so that is now mute.

Disclaimer: I am responding from memory, so I can't guarantee everything I said was 100% spot on. Better be checking facts if you intend to use any or all of what I said as basis to make a case one way or another.

In post 5463, Almost50 wrote: I thought rude was hinting NPOM might be 3P (and precisely a Jester, iirc).

Exactly.

Rude, according to the info you have, NPOM MUST be either 3P or Scum, given that you are town, yes? Either that or you are lying to us? Is there a third option here I am missing?

In post 5465, TiphaineDeath wrote:Rude, according to the info you have, NPOM MUST be either 3P or Scum, given that you are town, yes? Either that or you are lying to us? Is there a third option here I am missing?

False. NPOM's claimed flavour does not match mine.

npom as jester would make a lot of sense

In post 5467, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:npom as jester would make a lot of sense

particularly the part he spent just saying "get rid of me"

In post 5445, a2rudeboy wrote:Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

VOTE: Rude

Im Misha Mansoor from Periphery! Im also have the "Big brain" modifier, I was also informed that the other two guitarists from Periphery were not of my alignment.

Im not VT, but i have no reason to out what PR i am.

SO I WAS RIGHT ABOUT NO POWER AND RUDE FLAVOR STUFF???!

Where the heck did No power get that obscure Japanese guitarist he outs his flavor to be the other page?!

Well, I'm going to say I was 100% wrong about both Grendel and Rude being scum xD.

All aboard!

what ever, we should flip one then the other. I dont really know what my preference is???

If one is 3rd party i guess they should cliam. but its entirely possible that they could both be scum.

God! I feel so dumb for hard town reading both of them for like 90% of the game! lol

lol i guess that we solved the mystery.

1v1 grendel and rude

gogogogo