Mafiascum.net

ZEEnon wrote:

Gorrad wrote:Yeah, try reading the rest of that paragraph. I didn't find him particularly so either, just a gut. I was simply stating that your sentence in 532, "Notice how PhilyEc is the only person besides me to bring attention to Gorrad?", is completely irrelevant. It's wrong, and even if it was right it would make no sense as a scumtell.

I've gotten night killed for almost knowing both the mafia in my first game.
Ask Green Crayons, he's the one that killed me.

Korlash wrote:The main hollow of the contest was a MG... what do you mean it likely isn't in here? that's complete Bullshit. It's the most obvious choice for any GF or high ranking scum role. It's the main enemy Ichigo and uryu have to take down during their contest. it's the main freaking bad guy of season 1... How can you say you've speculated for a while and done reasearch and have come to the conclusion it's not likely in the set-up?

Korlash wrote:how do you "almost know" both the mafia?

Gorrad wrote:That's nice. How is it at all relevant to the current situation?

GLaDOS wrote:... Processing ...

I want a full-claim from Xtoxm. To this day, I have never seen somebody in a position where they are about to be lynched who was better off not claiming their role, especially this early in a game.

~

I am perfectly fine with posts like the one Mastin just posted. Seeing a thought-process can be more helpful than seeing the product sometimes.

However, please stop speculating what roles you think people might have (such as your Mason group speculation). This definitely seems to be a bad habit of yours in this game. If people drop tells/hints for their roles, it is because they

do not

want them pointed out – and chances are they know more about when information is relevant to point out more than you do. If you finding completely

inconsistent

tells then that could be different, as there you may be dealing with somebody trying to set up multiple avenues for fake-claims. Just be sure to use judgment.

~

I have not yet seen a real reason to suspect Korlash of being scum. I would appreciate seeing some reasoning, or being pointed to reasoning.

GLaDOS wrote:... Processing ...

Short on time, but I do not believe that PhilyEc had a guilty result on Gorrad.

First, PhilyEc made about 4 substantive posts on Day Two before ever voting for Gorrad. Second, PhilyEc switched from Gorrard to Seraphim as Day Two come to a close. Perhaps just as importantly, we

did

just lynch a scum Redirector – this casts doubt onto all investigations done on Night One, even

if

PhilyEc did have such a result.

For the record, though, if I were to speculate as to PhilyEc’s result, it would probably have been an innocent investigation on Albert B. Rampage, given the contrast of language we have from PhilyEc’s last post on Day One, which was Post 252, and PhilyEc’s first post on Day Two, which was Post 283.

Xtoxm wrote:That last bit of it might be onto something.

Not scum, but hows it defend me?

Xtoxm wrote:Spirit Enabler