In post 534, DoctorPepper wrote:Im having problems with people who's readlists have not had solid scum, just people "leaning scum"
I have problems with people that DO NOT provide reasons for their reads.
Me too... which is why I won't get 100% behind my reads. Because they are just my intuition really. Without being able to better evidence my suspicions, there's no way I can declare someone scum and not a) lead us astray or b) get lynched.
I think it's coming from the tone of people's posts. I might sit down later and find some evidence for my scum suspicions, but it's nearly midnight here so I can't be bothered just at present
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 11:58 am
by Timeater
also about doctor before i go, iso'd him
Because only town can have conviction? And it cant be faked? What? Bad reason for a read. Soooo generic.
More votes on this guy please
actually its a pretty good reason. i never said that conviction cannot be faked. did i say that? not at all. there is sort of a discontinuity of logic going on here. this post reeks of casual predation, which is common of scum because they like to latch onto targets a few people already have and throw up shitty reasons so they can feign real activity/effort.
Im having problems with people who's readlists have not had solid scum, just people "leaning scum"
i have a problem with people who semi-random vote and then later play it off as a serious one
I am going to say i think Bert, Sakura and fuzzy are town
Mac is leaning town.
Null on banana, Saki, and aquaman (ETL, prod please, if you havent already done so
leaning scum on GiF and tne.
Scum on timeeater
How could you have a nullread on banana? that makes no sense. banana is super obvious town here. nobody is that bad. this just reads as hesitation to give out townreads.
also spell my fucking name right or not at all. just use tim or time.
goku out
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 12:05 pm
by toxic-banana
In post 552, Timeater wrote:
How could you have a nullread on banana? that makes no sense. banana is super obvious town here. nobody is that bad. this just reads as hesitation to give out townreads.
Hey, hey, chill out man *feels uncomfortable with the sudden love from timeater*
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 12:23 pm
by FSnake
i canĀ“t they i like Timeater but he is probably town. great that leaves tne in my scumpile.
i hate D1
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 12:26 pm
by FSnake
say not they ...
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 1:06 pm
by toxic-banana
Although reading that more closely, I don't think @Timeater showed me much love - correct me if I'm wrong, but was that assertion of me as town based on the idea that I'm playing too badly to be scum?
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 3:55 pm
by RachMarie
I am still here just RL issues yuk I cant wait til my knee is healed and I am a bit sick too slept til 6 PM
thats almost 11 hrs
FS I agree D 1 is never my best day
Yeah I have nana as newb town read... if you look at his posts its clear he is new and I definitely would recommend he sign up for a Newbie game where he has an IC to help show the ropes.
Someone asked about me going all mom and soft ICing... yeah well I am 47 and old enough to be a mom to more than half the MS community lol. So yeah I do tend to mom a bit, also I am an IC in the Newbie games, so when I see someone asking newbie questions it kinda turns on my teacher button. I also am an educator type person in RL.
umm Time feel free to call me Rach it is easier to type than Rachael which most peeps misspell anyways
nana welcome to Mafia a lot of it is logic, intuition, and best guess. Unless you are like a cop with a guilty, none of us are 100% sure of our reads as town.