Newbie 1476 - Game Over

[joker443]

Good luck jake

[Jake from State Farm]

Good luck jake

such an odd comment to make

[Not_Mafia]

Is that because you are the scumteam?

[Luca Blight]

I find it funny how the two quietest players suddenly pop up to welcome the new arrival!

Any response to my last post, Not_Mafia?

[Jake from State Farm]

Is that because you are the scumteam?

was this directed at me?

yes I am both scum, you caught me

[Jake from State Farm]

can someone give me a summary of day 1? it will be a couple of days before I can re-read the entire game

[notscience]

I lead a lynch on Zivel

We were wagoning GM at a time

we wagoned Burn and he had an AtE flip out

I was obvtown

[burn_209]

Notty what are your reads at the moment? You too Luca what is your reads list?

[Jake from State Farm]

vote: rach

[joker443]

No it wasn't that I said it like that because half the rubbish on this game is confusing

[Jake from State Farm]

Stepdad just had a stroke. V/la for a day or so til I can figure out what's going on

[serrapaladin]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT 2.04

Luca Blight (2) - Not_Mafia, notscience

notscience (1) - Luca Blight
RachMarie (1) - Jake from State Farm

Not Voting (3) - burn_209, joker443, RachMarie

With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 2 is in (expired on 2014-03-23 22:00:59).[/area]

[Jake from State Farm]

ok so I don't really need a v/la so I am back.

mod can you please prod rach?

your rules state that a prod dodge buys you 24 hours and it has been more than 24 hours since her last post which was essentially a prod dodge. She has had no "game related content" since day 1 and even that is iffy

I like my vote on Rach for 2 reasons.

1. despite her disagreeing, she is lurking in my opinion
2. I do not like her day 1 vote on Burn, she claimed that burn sheeped notsci without any reasons for GM but if you read Burn's post 306 there is no way you can say burn didn't provide some sort of reasoning for GM's suspicion
3 (and the most telling imo) - She did nothing to convince people to vote burn and she didn't even question her main scum suspect yet when deadline was near she says "I do not think we can get a majority on burn"

She didn't even TRY to get a majority on burn.

This is not town play imo. She sat back and let town battle each other and then hopped on a mislynch wagon under the guize of not getting her desired wagon and the classic "any lynch is better than a NL" (paraphrasing of course)

[Not_Mafia]

@ Luca - When did she accept your reasoning. She kept saying she simply isn't a high postcount player

[Not_Mafia]

I'll post something more significant later, this site is borderline unuseable on mobiles

[Jake from State Farm]

I'll post something more significant later, this site is borderline unuseable on mobiles

4+ years playing on a mobile device for me

[Luca Blight]

Burn, I've pretty much given out my reads in my posts today, but I'll go over them briefly (without having read back too much at this stage).

NotScience - Currently looking the most scummy for his erratic day 1 play. He was starting wagons just to see what stuck, it seemed. He obviously lead the wagon on Zivel, but something what struck me was the fact he lead the earlier wagon on GM (who he knew I was suspicious of at that point due to earlier questioning) and then invested a lot of time in asking me questions about GM to try and get me on the wagon. All this seems a little scummy when considering how he changes his scum reads with the wind, but even more so after GM was killed where he tried to make out he knew she was town all along which is BS, and then jumped on mafia's wagoning of me for the reason 'he killed GM' which is the kind of poor reasoning I have come to expect from him this game.

Joker - Has a habit of putting players on L-1 without much hesitation, other than that she has been seemingly very cautious and hasn't provided much content.

Rach - Similar to Joker, as Jake pointed out does appear to be a bit of a prod-dodger, and her silence seems strange considering I have seen her posting elsewhere on the site.

Jake - Obviously replaced Mutt, who was presumed Town after a few good posts early on but went missing for a while before replacing out.

Burn - Looked incredibly scummy at times on day 1, kept mirepping myself and others, quietened down towards the end of the day. I like his start to day 2 but he's one to watch out for.

Not Mafia - I read him as town for most of day 1, but there are a few things which have seemed slightly odd. His argument against me is bizarre to say the least. Will look into him in more detail when I have time.

@Not Mafia, with regards to GM I thought I remembered her saying she accepted my opinion (and it clearly had a positive effect if you compare her activity before and after) so I'm not sure if it was one of the posts that went missing or if I imagined it, as I can't seem to locate it in her ISO! Either way I don't see how the IC thing is even relevant, it wasn't even an argument GM herself used when trying to wagon me.

[notscience]

dodge until tomorrow

[joker443]

Right now, I'm gonna go for rach as I said on day one I don't like her lurking and it continues I'm still convinced she is one of them and burn

vote rach

[joker443]

Apologies for not having much to say ATM as got a lot of personal problems going on ATM, will have a proper read through soon

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: rach

Do something.

Pretty much everyone except Jake is on my scum radar at the moment.

Not Sci needs to actually start putting something substantial behind his wagons as right now I don't want him near lylo and I don't want to mislynch someone for not being able to justify their wagons

[RachMarie]

Jake did you notice that I mentioned I had been sick?

NM It is good to have some to a lot of suspicion on a person, but not everyone is scum, only 2 are. Differentiating between town reads and scum reads is important.

I still have Burn as my top scumspect.

VOTE: Burn


Im town reading Notty why are some of you seeing him as scum, I am not seeing it.

[RachMarie]

Town reads :

Jake, Notty, NM

I know I am town

From weakest to strongest scumspects:

Luca
Joker
Burn

[Jake from State Farm]

I'll look into your posting habits during day 1 when I get to a computer.

Seeing as you are sticking with burn which I already pointed out you didn't have a good reason the first time nor did you attempt to convince anyone to vote him, now is your chance.

Try to convince me burn is scum.

[RachMarie]

Notty what are your reads at the moment? You too Luca what is your reads list?

Why is he asking other people for their reads and where is his?