Mini 1624: Joss Whedon Mafia: The Musical (Game Over)

[GreyICE]

Ooh, here's a project for you to read up on. You can read Boon's ISO, and try to figure out why that post is like yet another nice heap of straw on an overburdened camel.

Add on I think everyone at least want's to give AA9's replacement a chance, and, well... (And Anti, you know I believe in policy. One of my policies is if someone is behaving absolutely incomprehensibly, lashes out at anyone who suspects them, and generally is content to just focus on defending themselves, they should be lynched. This policy, like "lynch all liars" and "fakeclaims are scum" will get you many more scum lynches than statistical average)

[Murder of Crows]

Re Boon's ISO: Its worth a vote, because? He has basically posted nothing. If you want to call him a policy lynch go ahead, but its downright dumb to expect votes will get him to post more, given his iso.

[Murder of Crows]

Other concerns are that MC hasn't contributed to the game

Im going to assume this is a joke.

[serrapaladin]

Does anyone anything about goblin, because his intro posts look a bit fake.

[serrapaladin]

know anything*

[Egg]

Prod dodge. My V/LA should end right around deadline. Might not be caught up, but I've been skimming at the hospital. I probably won't join the Arc wagon unless no lynch is the other option. I just don't see a strong case there.

[Antihero]

yonce = hoopla alt?

[Goblin]

Can someone please tell me the case on boonskies?
MC, can you tell me your reads please?

[Antihero]

VOTE: goblin

can we please kill this?

[Goblin]

He has 15 posts. I'm not going to give scum an easy policy lynch. I'm not asking anything unreasonable.
Then again, you're not exactly staying consisten on your votes, so why should I care anyways?
On the other hand, I'm interested in MC's reads, because they will help me with my own.

Could murder of the crows be an easy target right now? Maybe, I'm not sure.

[Goblin]

Looked back into the game. Arc Angel is wall posting like a mother fucker

[Murder of Crows]

I haven't fully gotten sync'd with ffery since she has personal life things going on, but:

Town: Serra, Anatole, Riddleton (whoever that is now), istott
Maybe Town: Medea (where r u guys?), greyJOY, Arcangel (whoever that is)
The rest: Antihero, LMP (whoever that is), Bassists, Boonskies, Egg

I guess I'll talk a little bit about my bottom group there.

Antihero: ffery and I both seemed to agree that he seems to be all bark and no bite this game, but he has been a bit better recently. Not ready to call him town, but not really wanting to look at him a whole lot right now either. A couple individual posts of his felt off, but not necessarily in a scummy way.

LMP: Early game reads over-aggressive. I'm not familiar with this guy, but feels a little bit forced, alignment aside. I origianlly suspected AH/LMP might be a team because their pushes on each other are rather baffling and neither of them came of looking town at all in it. Dunno. His little jab at Boon in 44 really looks like someone who is confirmation biasing or just determined to think Boon is scum already. He seems obsessed with talking only about those 2 players (one of which has just an RV as content at that point?). Finally branches out into including a fair number of other scumreadsand a couple of townreads. Eh? eh. Goblin looks a little better than LMP did. There is some definite dissonance between talking about feelings and then launching straight into discussion about meta and absolutes.

Boonskies: Is a lurker. Has done nothing. Has sort of implied he may just keep doing nothing. Null. Slight town lean because yolo420blazeit and I think scum wouldnt be 100% useless.

Bassists: I mostly dislike these guys posts which tints my lens a little bit. Im wary of hydras who bash each other after having Katsuki do it to mastin in Anything Goes and them turning out to be scum. Although that was more reads specifically and less other things I suppose. I know I got upset at mastin in our hydra since she kind of committed suicide, even if it was blazingly town the whole time. ANYWAYS, I understand why grey seems to be writing these guys off as town, but I'm not really ready to do that. Post 100 is a great example of a post that Im sure I could divine their alignment from if I had a gram of weed, a massage, and some dedicated time to do nothing but reread it on end. But I also just hate the opinions present in the post (chiefly that an RVS vote is a scandal and must be undone) so yeh. The interactions with egg here seem ~off~ regardless from one or both sides. I don't like this I guess more than anything. I see a lot of questions flying out of these guys and nothing that looks like an internal thought process that looks townish. Mostly just assertions and categorizing events in the thread. The need of whichever head it was to talk about their document felt weird to me too.

Egg: Im gonna be honest, Im off to the gym right now mostly so I can sit in the hottub for like a half hour, which is defo going to be the most relaxing part of my day. Egg is kind of a PoE scumread and nothing in his posts makes me think hes a probable townie, so ya. Lets start there: VOTE: Eggbert

[Murder of Crows]

And for funzies, if I had to gues the scumteam right now, it'd be Bassists, Egg, Antihero.

[Goblin]

I disagree with your opinion on boonskies. Some players purposefully avoid the spotlight in these games.

[Goblin]

VOTE: MurderoftheCrows
Boonskies is probably town and Murder is probably scum.
It is the only thing that clicks at this point.

[serrapaladin]

@AP, you're really gonna go with a PoE scumread at this point?

@Goblin, what do you think of antihero?

[Goblin]

All over the place with his vote and making a lot of noise.
Not saying that scum meta is non-existent. Just rare.

[Murder of Crows]

I disagree with your opinion on boonskies. Some players purposefully avoid the spotlight in these games.

VOTE: MurderoftheCrows
Boonskies is probably town and Murder is probably scum.
It is the only thing that clicks at this point.

[Murder of Crows]

I disagree with your opinion on boonskies. Some players purposefully avoid the spotlight in these games.

I happen to know that lurking is at worst a null tell for him.

[Goblin]

Yet you used his lurking to town read him. Logic...

[Murder of Crows]

@AP, you're really gonna go with a PoE scumread at this point?

@Goblin, what do you think of antihero?

Yes? I don't feel super strongly about any one player being scum. I see some interactions that look off. Eggs lack of anything that looks town in his iso works for me right now. I think my vote is better than the boonskies wagon which is pretty much a policy lynch.

[Murder of Crows]

WWow.hes in my short list of people who could be scum. And I said slight town lean and added a diminutive to my own reason. So ya you are totally on to me. Good reading comprehension.

[Goblin]

Well who would you lynch outside boonskies and egg?
Like seriously, I want you to think about that one.

[Murder of Crows]

Yet you used his lurking to town read him. Logic...

Yes at least a null tell. Could be a town tell but I would never use lurking as a "tell" ever.

[Murder of Crows]

Well who would you lynch outside boonskies and egg?
Like seriously, I want you to think about that one.

I don't know it's not like I just made a reads list or anything.