Mini 502: Basically Communist Mafia- Game Over. Who won?
Forum rules
First Nocmen was stabbed.
But that was okay. After all, he is a doctor.
And then he was stabbed again.
But that was okay. After all he is a doctor.
And then he was stabbed again.
Nocmen, doctor, is now a bloody heap on the floor. The crime again looks like it came from inside the commune.
It is now day five. With three alive, it's two to lynch.
But that was okay. After all, he is a doctor.
And then he was stabbed again.
But that was okay. After all he is a doctor.
And then he was stabbed again.
Nocmen, doctor, is now a bloody heap on the floor. The crime again looks like it came from inside the commune.
It is now day five. With three alive, it's two to lynch.
SEND THE VECTOIDS
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
setup analysis
pdcakes got an innocent on Jdodge because he is a townie.
pdcakes got an innocent on Adel because she is a townie.
pdcakes got an guilty on pdcakes because he is a SK & a cop
the mechanic of the setup allows for the SK to be a cop, and since the investigations are choosen by the group, it doesn't break the game for the sk to also be the cop
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
and why would pdcakes choose to investigate himself? he said it was to determine his sanity.
that sounds like a really lame reason to me. unless, of course, his SK/Cop win condition didn't make much sense to him, and he was afraid that he had some strange role, where he wasn't quite sane.
that sounds like a really lame reason to me. unless, of course, his SK/Cop win condition didn't make much sense to him, and he was afraid that he had some strange role, where he wasn't quite sane.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
... and couldn't trust his win condition.
idea: pdcakes investigated himself because he is a Cop and a Vig, and he wanted to make sure he could trust his win condition.
I don't trust this one because of the innocent on JDodge.
JDodge is an SK with investigation immunity
setup analysis II
idea: pdcakes investigated himself because he is a Cop and a Vig, and he wanted to make sure he could trust his win condition.
I don't trust this one because of the innocent on JDodge.
setup analysis III
JDodge is an SK with investigation immunity
hey guys. I just got the result on adel and it came up town.
so all three of us have been investigated and they have all come up town. But i still believe my investigations are accurate...i just feel that someone is investigation immune.
And remembering that jdodge filled in for jack leads me to suspect its him. Remember how brash jack was at the beginning? he seemed to basically want to be investigated. Its a smart play. Get investigated so the cop gets an innocent and then all you have to do is not worry about a night kill....
You know i was bothered with jacks play from the beginning. But him being an SK with immunity now makes his play make sense.
Im gonna hold off on a vote for now but I am leaning toward jdodge being the sk.
so all three of us have been investigated and they have all come up town. But i still believe my investigations are accurate...i just feel that someone is investigation immune.
And remembering that jdodge filled in for jack leads me to suspect its him. Remember how brash jack was at the beginning? he seemed to basically want to be investigated. Its a smart play. Get investigated so the cop gets an innocent and then all you have to do is not worry about a night kill....
You know i was bothered with jacks play from the beginning. But him being an SK with immunity now makes his play make sense.
Im gonna hold off on a vote for now but I am leaning toward jdodge being the sk.
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
Alright, here are two examples:
Porly Ritten Flayver, where Jack was town
EXiLE, abandoned game where Jack was scum
Porly Ritten Flayver, where Jack was town
EXiLE, abandoned game where Jack was scum
yeah but its more than just brashly. He would vote and not explain. when he did this i thought he was trying to get us to investigate him.
AND i just went through the list of deaths and the fact that there was no mafia kill on night 2 stands out to me. Jdodge you were investigated night 1. In my mind mafia would probably try to kill you. Well there was no kill? Would that be because they targeted you and you are night kill immune too?
AND i just went through the list of deaths and the fact that there was no mafia kill on night 2 stands out to me. Jdodge you were investigated night 1. In my mind mafia would probably try to kill you. Well there was no kill? Would that be because they targeted you and you are night kill immune too?
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
How am I supposed to know why there was no kill?pdcakes wrote:yeah but its more than just brashly. He would vote and not explain. when he did this i thought he was trying to get us to investigate him.
AND i just went through the list of deaths and the fact that there was no mafia kill on night 2 stands out to me. Jdodge you were investigated night 1. In my mind mafia would probably try to kill you. Well there was no kill? Would that be because they targeted you and you are night kill immune too?