Mafiascum.net

I've explained it thoroughly over the course of this game. If you were actually reading the game you'd know it. I'm not busting my butt to explain it again when you can look at my iso.

I find you both beautiful - one of you should put Karnos on L-1.

In post 539, tojam2 wrote:

Kcdaspot is being replaced.

Ego post, pending mod confirmation of sub and actual receipt of role pm (he offered me the slot).

In post 542, Transcend wrote:

fuck

off

In post 544, Transcend wrote:Read the game you

turdbasket

.

In post 549, Rosske wrote:You don't want to explain it because its a

shitty

empty scum read. And the more you talk about it the more likely you'll reveal that its contrived.

since phantom answered it late, don't waste your time with the rqs, smith. it's not super important any more (there are wagons to discuss!!), but that's not to say i made it to waste people's time or that i didn't find it helpful, because i actually did.

both of my scumreads are parked on the two highest lynches

In post 555, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:because i actually did

find it helpful. i did find it helpful.

i just reread that post and it sounds like i was admitting to wasting everyone's time ,':K

@all: current thoughts on Luna? For the #1 volume poster she sure seems to be saying not very much interesting/helpful.

In post 558, mhsmith0 wrote:@all: current thoughts on Luna? For the #1 volume poster she sure seems to be saying not very much interesting/helpful.

Kind of a null read (just below KTS and Phantom for me), her PoE playstyle is fakeable as scum but believable and consistent with her meta. I think she's better as a person of interest after a flip unless there's something I'm missing here.

In post 558, mhsmith0 wrote:@all: current thoughts on Luna? For the #1 volume poster she sure seems to be saying not very much interesting/helpful.

Scum.

In post 559, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:

In post 558, mhsmith0 wrote:@all: current thoughts on Luna? For the #1 volume poster she sure seems to be saying not very much interesting/helpful.

Kind of a null read (just below KTS and Phantom for me), her PoE playstyle is fakeable as scum but believable and consistent with her meta. I think she's better as a person of interest after a flip unless there's something I'm missing here.

so do you mean that simply the approach of using PoE is consistent, or is there a deeper consistency you're seeing?

In post 561, mhsmith0 wrote:so do you mean that simply the approach of using PoE is consistent, or is there a deeper consistency you're seeing?

I haven't done a true meta read of her but she's at, the very least, it before, so no there's nothing really deep there.

It's just that if I scumread her with my perspective of the gamestate, I feel like I'm scumreading the playstyle and not the motivations. I want to see how she adapts when she's wrong because I think regardless of alignment she's not going to nail both scum because that will help me understand her better.

i'm currently comparing isos between this game and a game that i just learned was completed that luna was in and i will get back to you with thoughts

I was thinking of Summer Waltz since I /inned for it but /outted because I decided to replace into this game.

I really don't know what to make of this actually, which is exactly why Luna is sticking in null for me. I like her activity more in the linked game but I'm worried it's just confbias? I might need a few days to mull this over actually, I might be able to make sense of it after my plate is a bit clearer.

My opinion hasn't really changed, I don't think I have the information I want to gauge Luna's motivations.

FYI this is Luna's scum game
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

if you want to compare/contrast. Imo she's closer to her wolfing than her town game at
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
(I hadn't read waltz)

Probably because this game has been a wallfest of arguing the same thing and i can't seem to stop it.
Not really saying that makes me town, but im not happy that i have a hard time getting reads this game.

So mhsmith is kcdas.
I had a townread on that slot and he hasn't dissapointed. I think his assesment is valid considering that's how i feel about this game right now, even tho the conclusion leads to the wrong result.

Why did your read of Thor v karnos go from tvt to voting karnos?

In post 568, mhsmith0 wrote:Why did your read of Thor v karnos go from tvt to voting karnos?

One of Karnos posts felt like reaching

I've said it before and I'll say it again.

I'm not reading games that I wasn't a part of to gain meta on someone.

So stop posting past games.

And if you're wondering why i didnt vote him at the time, at the time i still had PC as possible scum, then giga linked a game and i read his ISO and checked his activity via timestamps in that game so i felt i could be wrong here, and then switched my vote to my suspect with the highest wagon.

In post 571, Transcend wrote:I've said it before and I'll say it again.

I'm not reading games that I wasn't a part of to gain meta on someone.

So stop posting past games.

Close investigating suggests that there are many players in this game other than you, some of whom may actually bother. And given that you'd already stated a read on Luna, you weren't really who I was talking to.

Just an FYI.