Mafiascum.net

In post 545, skitter30 wrote:i'm not sure that scum!gobble starts by picking a fight with jingle

But I don’t think he is picking a fight with bingle?

What do u think he's doing then ?

MariaR is scum for her page 21 shenanigans. She’s not acting as a proactive town. Everything on that page was reactive and not scumhunting imo

That said, I don’t want her to die day 1 as scum. I’m tired of that

VOTE: Bingle

@datisi, why are you townreading bingle?

In post 508, Menalque wrote:

In post 504, skitter30 wrote:reaction post to your meme readslist

Yeah, okay, I jive with this, that did give me good pings

okay but right after that reaction post was when you said datisi might be scum? how does that compute

In post 514, MariaR wrote:Penguin vote was mostly to see if anyone would react to me joining such a big wagon

? the wagon was a grand total of 2 people before you joined

i think i like skitter for town, her posting feels much more off-the-cuff than city

it’s possible i feel this way only because she’s posting in real time, but i don’t think i felt this way about her posts even when she was posting in real time in city

i’m not sure that made sense, brain still sleepy

@mena you didn’t ask me my take on the bingle thing (thingle?) but ftr i think he’s taken that approach to more than just your posts

as in, i don’t think it’s necessarily bad faith (although it could be), i could see a world where town!bingle is misreading everyone’s signals because he’s off on his own wavelength

that said, i don’t feel anything particularly towny from him

okay spammy spam over. i think i’m caught up

In post 553, lilith2013 wrote:@datisi, why are you townreading bingle?

i think his mena read makes sense and comes from a townie perspective, even if i don't entirely agree with his conclusion

bingle kinda rings more... bold? than what i think i've seen of him before but i kinda don't think it's in a scummy manner

i think probably my biggest issue with bingle’s iso is that he’s using mena’s jokeposts as part of his reasoning for a serious scumread on mena when i think those posts can’t really be included in terms of content because the content was not real content. what are your thoughts on that?

The irony.

what jokeposts were included, other than the "readslist"? i buy 347 as legit for what pinged him.

2 out of the 3 non-datisi posts he referenced were either the joke readslist or directly related to it

actually i’m not even sure why mena is defending himself re: buddying skitter because i assumed that post about skitter was also not real content due to it being based on the joke readslist in the first place

i still think penguin might be scum since he literally comes to this thread just to badmouth me but i know i’m gonna be an asshole if i post my response so i deleted my post.

Lilith gets it. I don’t think town!Bingle scumreads Menalque for what Bingle is scumreading Menalque for right now.

In post 569, lilith2013 wrote:i still think penguin might be scum since he literally comes to this thread just to badmouth me but i know i’m gonna be an asshole if i post my response so i deleted my post.

Potentially!

In post 570, gobbledygook wrote:Lilith gets it. I don’t think town!Bingle scumreads Menalque for what Bingle is scumreading Menalque for right now.

erm that’s not really what i said?

In post 567, lilith2013 wrote:2 out of the 3 non-datisi posts he referenced were either the joke readslist or directly related to it

okay you lost me, can you link what you're talking about please

In post 564, lilith2013 wrote:i think probably my biggest issue with bingle’s iso is that he’s using mena’s jokeposts as part of his reasoning for a serious scumread on mena when i think those posts can’t really be included in terms of content because the content was not real content.

Erm?