Mafiascum.net

In post 542, Vasex wrote:If I'm not mistaking, Andre is the only one, who consider Cabd is townie. And he did it very early.

And Cabd doesn't townread Andre. So Andre has more chances to be scummy than Cabd. And Andre was also among defenders of Kitty.
So to elim today Kitty or Andre seems a good plan.

VOTE: Andresvmb

In post 547, Save The Dragons wrote:you haven't really explained why wagoning cabd is a good idea anyway so

difficult

I fail to see how that makes Andres scum and not town defending slots.

Also guys miller is not a normal role

In post 552, Artemiana wrote:I fail to see how that makes Andres scum and not town defending slots.

What does make a player scum on the first day, m?

Definitely not defending slots

Why Mark is a scum?

Vibes so far, I don't like pushes so far.

Nero lock town. All pushes there needs to stop

Marky, etine, vasex, ???, ???

Have fun with this hero solve

Ok, zoomer

Zoomer?

I'm old af

Really? So you are mafia then

In post 554, Artemiana wrote:Definitely not defending slots

I disagree. Defending slots oftenly is mafia thing in the first day:
- if both are mafia = defending the partner, rather risky in open-dead-role-game;
- if only the defender is mafia = Player knows the sides of the other players (mafia definitely knows who are townies and who are mafia), player can be pocketing someone, saying that this is a townie, defending him.
- and also they can be both townies or the defender is just mistaking, defending a scum...

but there is no sense to say, that strange unexplained defending cannot be mafia thing

Andresvmb considers:
- Cabd is townie (nobody thinks like that except him)
- NDMath is townie (nobody thinks like that except him)
- Vasex is more mafia than townie in the first posts about Kitty!

And Kitty is most possible mafia here right now for me.

In post 556, Artemiana wrote:Marky, etine, vasex, ???, ???

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm.. this is also very BOLD defending of Kitty

So Artemiana, are you really a mafia scum with Kitty?

You really want to elim anybody of these three today, this is your plan:
1) Mark right now is voting Kitty, and this summons you in the thread
2) Etine, probable PR or just a townie, that has more votes, than Kitty (and you are hoping that your top-townie Nero will finish Etine; you are adding oil to that idea, ignoring his pr claim)
3) me, who attacks Kitty and has more votes, than Kitty

you are also have much thinking about prs, you also have bad argument about defending slots...

Well well well. So what?

Kitty, Artemiana, Andresvmb, ???, ???

And you are so sure about 5 bodies
Nice

Marky and Nero are solid townies in that case

and for god sake Etine is also townie ??

In post 552, Artemiana wrote:I fail to see how that makes Andres scum and not town defending slots.

Also guys miller is not a normal role

Miller is normal.

In post 470, Etine wrote:It was crumbing my role very obviously. To which i realized the scumteam wasn't brainless.

Can you point this out now that you've claimed? (kinda confused why you haven't)

In post 478, Marky Mark wrote:

In post 451, KittyTacky wrote:Good point but explain how that is alignment-indicative

Townies can post at face value. Scum have to construct their posts to look townie so have more chance to overthink stuff.

I'm confused how ndmath is seeing this as a town tell

I am more likely to post something similar to that as town than scum. I also believe that holds for other players at the more self-conscious end of the spectrum, which is the only group that bothers with phrasing in the first place. (my disagreement is with the assumption that town posts at face value).

In post 542, Vasex wrote:

In post 268, Andresvmb wrote:I’ve been pretty pinged by T3, would blow it up. {Cabd, WindowsXP, NDMath} seem like Town to me so far.

If I'm not mistaking, Andre is the only one, who consider Cabd is townie. And he did it very early.
I think that NDMath considers Cabd townie too, though he didn't say it loud.

I am quiet in general.


I townread Vasex. Disagree with their general approach to the game but do think who he's pushing and respective confidence levels comes from town.

Sorry I was busy yesterday evening.

UNVOTE:

Will read back through the thread a bit and place my vote.

Etine's claim is weird. Definitely an overreaction but I... kinda see how a townie would overreact there.

I believe Vasex is town. Still don't trust Etine. Smells like an awkward claim tossed out to relieve pressure.

VOTE: Etine

hey ive been lurky on purpose, wanted to check in. i used an alt for a reason when joining the large so it would be harder for me to spam the thread when i log on.


artemania is my new townread.

In post 478, Marky Mark wrote:

In post 451, KittyTacky wrote:Good point but explain how that is alignment-indicative

Townies can post at face value. Scum have to construct their posts to look townie so have more chance to overthink stuff.

I'm confused how ndmath is seeing this as a town tell

Or haven't you thought that maybe it's my style of posting?

Etine won't be eliminated today. It is obvious.
Kitty is the best option.

In post 571, WindowsXP wrote:artemania is my new townread.

I wanted to say smth likethat and was preparing the post about "Marky, etine, vasex, ???, ??? --- this doesnt look like a mafia plan"...but then i realised that it DOES look like a mafia plan and nothing else. Because for a townie this list of players is too random and rather stupid (etine and me together? She doesnt think much about that), but if to look at that as on defending the partner Kitty (who is top3 on the voting after etine and me, and with a vote of Mark in Kitty), tge puzzle is almost finished, every thing fits well. While reading people I always ask a question "why does they do that? What the porpose?". And in Artemiana's case the porpose is very clear.