Mafiascum.net

Cabds, and yours.

I reread over night and struggle to see where you started scumreading bell but iirc it was after he mentioned it.

While I was locked from posting I saw the same exact cycle start again with me.

Like I understand I could just be off a cliff like I’ve been all game but that’s the first time thing a have actually made sense this game.

I expected dunn and a50 to die though.

In post 5573, Brian Skies wrote:SB9, who do you think could potentially have killed NachoTammy N1?

Idk who nachotammy is, much less do I know who executed that specific kill. I don't even know who scum is in general atm and clearly neither does the rest of the game

In post 6592, skitter30 wrote:Sb9 pushing dunn is awful

WHY

I feel like I'm the only one in the dark here

In post 6593, petapan wrote:it's possible it was done to escape pressure yeah although somewhat eh on spiffeh wanting to turnstile immediately. pretty fuckin mediocre reads from him though

Both of them wanted to turnstile from the get go, so I don't think them wanting to turnstile to escape pressure makes much sense here.

Hello? Can someone answer me as to why dunn is unpushable

@SB9

Bell is claiming to be a Doctor that protected Imperium (the IC) on Night 1, but Imperium died anyway. Which means something probably interfered with that connection (either by roleblocker, strongman kill, or something else) or Bell is lying.

You literally went right after two of the slots (Dunn and Annie) that are unlikely to be the interfering role since they're pseudo-clearing each other from that Night Action.

? Nothing about Annie's claim precludes them from being a strongman

-E

I want to respond to that, but I honestly don't know what to expect from Cakez this game anymore.

In post 5580, Brian Skies wrote:@SB9

Bell is claiming to be a Doctor that protected Imperium (the IC) on Night 1, but Imperium died anyway. Which means something probably interfered with that connection (either by roleblocker, strongman kill, or something else) or Bell is lying.

You literally went right after two of the slots (Dunn and Annie) that are unlikely to be the interfering role since they're pseudo-clearing each other from that Night Action.

Again that sounds like a lot of setup spec bs to me. Strongman kill is just 1 way to easily explain this - so are people implying Annie/Dunn town and Bell scum who I'm defending? I'm just going after what I see as scummy posting.

Hench I’ve responded to your case and would really appreciate if you indulge me and just go back and review and see if you can see my POV instead of keeping up the incessant tunnel.

In post 5584, Annie Edison wrote:Hench I’ve responded to your case and would really appreciate if you indulge me and just go back and review and see if you can see my POV instead of keeping up the incessant tunnel.

Who's scum in your book?

Yeah, but Annie claimed to have a track result from Dunn leading him to Cabd. I don't think it makes sense for scum to be able to Neighborize AND Strongman kill in the same night. Regular kill, maybe. Strongman kill, no.

So it wouldn't really make sense for Dunn to be scum there unless Annie was lying. But Cabd already confirmed that result, so...

I’m trying to figure out which view of the gamestate I go with.

So putting a pin in this, but I did post a reads wall at daystart that’s pretty on par with where I am.

Well, I guess Dunn could still be scum here. But not the one I'm looking for right now.

In post 5586, Brian Skies wrote:Yeah, but Annie claimed to have a track result from Dunn leading him to Cabd. I don't think it makes sense for scum to be able to Neighborize AND Strongman kill in the same night. Regular kill, maybe. Strongman kill, no.

So it wouldn't really make sense for Dunn to be scum there unless Annie was lying. But Cabd already confirmed that result, so...

I don't think it makes no sense for scum to neighborize and strongman same night with the amount of power we have + an activating IC.

I still think unwnd was probably town though. And Dunn hasn't changed that for me.

It's true that if Bell was scum this would make a lot of sense

Dunn is scum in my “separate side scum pt” land

Every single bell post has felt ultra townie to me since his first one though I just can't see it

How many actions do people think scum get to make in the same night?

Because I definitely don't think it makes any sense for scum to Neighborize AND Strongman in the same night. Or Neighborize AND Roleblock. Or Neighborize AND whatever.

I would think annie's scum except for her separate PTs announcement

Weird. I didn't care much for that separate PTs announcement and thought he could've been scum for it.

Hey I qualified it as tinfoil land ffery

In post 5594, Brian Skies wrote:How many actions do people think scum get to make in the same night?

Because I definitely don't think it makes any sense for scum to Neighborize AND Strongman in the same night. Or Neighborize AND Roleblock. Or Neighborize AND whatever.

??? Why not? Give scum 1-shot whatever abilities and let them decide when to use it does not seem at all unbalanced especially in a game with this much town power.

You're focusing a lot on setup spec but do you have reads that don't stem from this stuff?

In post 5596, Brian Skies wrote:Weird. I didn't care much for that separate PTs announcement and thought he could've been scum for it.

Why? Seems like an unnecessary risk and TMI leak from scum