In post 5473, Moongrass wrote:Succint you don't need to read the whole thing - Read the setup and the Mod's ISO to see which events have been played and who's been flipped already.
The current plan is that you repick the coalition event tonight after we veto.
Did this, but still feel lost.
I know today's a shot at instant-win; I don't know the best townbloc to use.
The whole point of yesterday was to get to a place where we can coalition the people who weren't in the first coalition to see if both groups contain scum. Then town can use other events to whittle down the scum further.
We didn't veto 4 from the coalition to try and win today.
We should have gone with my veto. There was no good reason to have PB in the veto but he kept insisting we follow Titus’ plan, so I just gave up fighting it. I’m not blaming anyone but if we had done what I suggested, we would now know which one of Chemist/Creature was the scum in the coalition.
In post 5564, Moongrass wrote:Skygazer, RadiantCowbells, Creature, NanceFloor, Chemist1422.
At least 1 scum in this group.
I scum between Chemist/Creature obviously. I know I’m town and I hard tr RC/Sky. No way anyone who was in 1st coalition but not in veto is scum but it sucks that we don’t know because people didn’t sheep me. :/
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 10:47 am
by NanceFloor
In post 5565, 0verki11 wrote:hi so why did we suddenly take moongrass out of the veto
Because people thought putting almost locktown PB in a 4 person coalition veto made more sense than my plan but TD is lockscum, so that’s why I switched. It really wouldn’t have mattered if Moon had been in veto instead though. The results would have been the same either way.
I wonder if scum purposefully killed two players from the same row to deprive us of info.
Okay your recent posts are confusing me. PB was locktown from his last post and more people were sr both Chemist/Creature over Clemency. I think you’re overthinking it. Odds are unlikely that both Chemist/Creature are scum since they were paired together, so I think two scum outside of first coalition, most likely.
Green = confirmed town.
Pink = Coalition 1 leftovers.
I still think creature is town seeing as he's next to Chemist who is the most likely scum.
I hard town read Taly/Sky.
Reveal should be used on Nance or RC later down the track.
I still maintain my MariaR scum read. If I accept RC and Nance as town my PoE would be:
Chemist, MariaR, TimeDevil.
Why waste reveal on either me or RC, especially since it gives scum an NK, right? If it’s not freaking obvious to everyone yet that me/RC/Sky are never scum here, you’re either scum yourself or have even worse reads than tmck, if possible.
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 10:58 am
by NanceFloor
In post 5570, Titus wrote:VOTE: TimeDevil, MariaR, Chennis, 0verkill, Titus, Moongrass, Succinct
[/quote]
I know this was your original plan but based on dance pairings, it’s extremely unlikely that
both
Chemist/Creature are scum, so odds are high there’s almost certainly two scum in this.
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 11:00 am
by NanceFloor
In post 5572, Moongrass wrote:We could probably win the game if we left out MariaR, Chem, TD, 0K, RC. Dreams are free.
No way TD isn’t scum here. ISO him in Timeshift, where he was obvtown.
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 11:01 am
by Moongrass
It's not about your reads it's about removing one of the people, particularly RC from a doubt pool so scum can't push him late game/Lylo if he gets that far. I'm getting sick of repeating myself. If y'all didn't understand why we veto'd who we did yesterday and what the plan for coalition is today then I give up. You're wasting events and any point in efforting to extract maximum information mechanically.
I’m not tr either Moon or TD but way more confident on TD scum.
Based on his pushes on both our slot and RC, you can either conclude that TD is either horrible at both math and reading comprehension or is just scum.
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 11:11 am
by Moongrass
Hence why we need to reveal one of you to prevent pushes there.
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 11:12 am
by NanceFloor
In post 5583, MariaR wrote:I would've put both of the people that died in my co so I can really care less how this game goes anymore. The votes have been hella bad
If people had gone with my original coalition, the game might possibly have been over because I wanted you over Chemist but it got rejected.
In post 5579, MariaR wrote:VOTE: RadiantCowbells
Moongrass
Creature
Skygazer
MariaR
NanceFloor (Nancy Drew 39 + Dannflor)
Titus
it seems counter intuitive to put surviving members of the veto into the coalition today
- Dann
+1
Posted: Sun May 26, 2019 11:21 am
by NanceFloor
In post 5586, MariaR wrote:And who of the 5 that I left out would you put in.
It’s extremely likely that 2 of the remaining uncoalated 7 - save Succinct obviously contains scum, so it depends if we’re using coalition to succeed or to find scum in it, which is what Titus wanted.
If the former, I think you switch out Creature/TD and maybe Moon with whomever’s left. If the later, leave out TD and Moon and then that would likely mean Moon is town if it failed and last scum would probably be between Chenn/Overkill11.
