Open 768: C9++ [GAME OVER]

[Menalque]

That moment when norwegian is being sarcastic but actually nails the scum strategy perfectly

Not if it was Volpe's PLAN all along that we lynch him, and when he flips red we think Wooper is scum but in actuality he's TOWN!

I’m actually quite worried that skitter might see that and even tho it’s sarcastic it will give her enough of a prompt to realise that’s what we were going for

God, if we don’t lynch on the wicked/me side then a chem lynch is actually the worst case scenario here

Thank god ddl is pushing for doing wooper first so we don’t have to

My thoughts when that happened

[Menalque]

good game scum. you played the town division at day 3 really well. It really hurt, but it was definitely the play with the highest winrate.

again so sorry town. I just messed up. Like I can't make statements: wooper scum means volpe scum when its false. that's what it was. i was wrong and that cost the game :<

Dude you had like 3 people actively trying to manipulate you directly or indirectly and you were still damn close to correct. Mechanically you’re were super on it too, that was p scary. We were hoping that town would miss that skitt had to be SK or town but you basically blew that possibility out of the water as soon as you started running numbers, and had me as mech!scum for the same

[Menalque]

I

really

liked this PL

I just wish I could have been town D:

[Volpe14]

This is almost officially the longest open game in the forum history!

go go go one more page of post-game commentaries!

[Volpe14]

Ah right, I talked about it in scum PT norwegian, but I really meant to say I enjoyed playing with you this game

I feel like we would mindmeld a lot as town too

I don't think I would have much different reads this game as town other than not SR'ing teacher/bingle that hard.

I probably would have tunneled wooper/egix though

[Wooper]

wp scum, someone should nom this for goodfellas. I've never enjoyed xylo of a game as little as I enjoyed xylo here.

literally in awe that DDL and skitter were town

[Wooper]

little bit angleshooty but volpe referencing his replace out itt and then NOPEing out because he didn't get his way was like intensely wolfy and killed what was left of my wim. I didn't think actively pushing a volpe/wicked scumteam would have really changed anyone's mind.

[Blatant Scum]

222 pages.
I think town lost because of spamming so much.

[Wooper]

Thanks for your input. Town lost because scum played a very good gambit, and nobody was paying attention to the zepellin-sized shadow of scum agenda looming over our good town.

but thanks for your input!

[Almost50]

Town lot because:

A) Scum (Wicked) played it very well, and
B) Town sucks at

basic

Mafia play.

I mean, check the dead thread. The first thing to do when someone claims Cop and give results is to go back and see how they treated their own innos. Volpe voted Teacher not once, and not twice, but THREE times on D2. An Teacher was supposedly his inno from N1??

[Wooper]

fair bit then
lynching his inno
rather than lynching into a mech dichotomy that had 1-2 scum in it
was the stupid thing they did

[NorwegianboyEE]

Town lot because:

A) Scum (Wicked) played it very well, and
B) Town sucks at

basic

Mafia play.

I mean, check the dead thread. The first thing to do when someone claims Cop and give results is to go back and see how they treated their own innos. Volpe voted Teacher not once, and not twice, but THREE times on D2. An Teacher was supposedly his inno from N1??

Maybe you should have told that to Skitter before she shot you.

[Wooper]

Nor - do you think you could have seen wicked/volpe?

[Volpe14]

I mean, check the dead thread. The first thing to do when someone claims Cop and give results is to go back and see how they treated their own innos. Volpe voted Teacher not once, and not twice, but THREE times on D2. An Teacher was supposedly his inno from

Actually A50...I would have done that as cop if I had claimed from frustration to fake out not being the cop because you know, I was 1v1 against someone I thought was scum and didn't want them to notice it?

I only claimed cop exactly because I could play out my play in day 2 like that. I wouldn't have acted much different if I was really a town cop back there.

When I was jailkeeper in a newbie game one of the first things I did in day 1 was to talk a lot about directing PRs/d2 talk about "guessing the town PRs" in the setup to fool mafia into thinking I was VT.

That's like, how I play as PR and I would have backed it up.

[Menalque]

Ftr I think town lost bc you couldn’t find enough other town successfully in time. Town had correct reads on town but a bloc never really managed to appear, and by the time a townbloc was really needed it was too late to manage to form one.

[Wooper]

The polarising gambit did a v v good job of dividing out the towncore.

[skitter30]

I got at fake!cop!nibbui eventually

I just didnt think scum would cc each other

Sorry a50, i absolutely can't read you anymore :/

Wooper ... yeah. Didnt mean to make it unenjoyable, apologies if i did. Scum!you was the simplest solution to everything from my pov, and i felt like a lot of what was said by you was either in bad faith or deliberately ignoring facts to push a narrative.

I wish i could have read you better, not sure what would have gotten me untunneled tho.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Nor - do you think you could have seen wicked/volpe?

Wicked/Volpe
Probably not.

Chemist/Wicked
Maybe. I was actually starting to consider voting Chemist because he literally did nothing. But there were already a bunch of votes on you + Egix/Skitter already signalling intent so i just sheeped them.

[Almost50]

@Nor: I was shot on N2, and he claimed it on D3. How would I have known he intended to fake claim before he actually did it?

@Menalque: You do that as a real Cop and I lynch you on the spot 10 times out of 10. NO COP ever votes their own inno in a Normal.

[Menalque]

Did you mean to @ me there, A50?

[NorwegianboyEE]

@Nor: I was shot on N2, and he claimed it on D3. How would I have known he intended to fake claim before he actually did it?

Because if you're not psychic, why are you even playing in a mafia game?

[Almost50]

Sorry a50, i absolutely can't read you anymore :/

Like, I dunno what I could have done more than outright crumb in my old-fashioned way for you to TR me. I mean, it was you and NSG in specific that the crumb was intended for.

[Almost50]

Did you mean to @ me there, A50?

No. that was @Volpe. Sorry (but you were his p so you can still pass it on)

[Almost50]

@Nor: I was shot on N2, and he claimed it on D3. How would I have known he intended to fake claim before he actually did it?

Because if you're not psychic, why are you even playing in a mafia game?

Ah! Noted.

[skitter30]

I got that you were crumbing vt, and felt that you would be in the lynchpool after day2 (esp. The hammer)

Since you were strongly softing vt i figured that wasnt the worst thing i could do