The subset of players on both mislynches is {Wavemode, JarJarDrinks,
PenguinPower
, Creature}. I think this is a pretty good place to start, and I'd prefer JJD or Wave. VOTE: JJD in particular has been pretty instrumental in our failed lynches. He even set up the awful Dunn lynch before Lala died.
is this forced? or can you expand on why SS is scum?
this is me voting the not-me wagon out of survivalism. I'm pretty donezo explaining shit.
I've had lynches I hate go through 2 days in a row, most of my content doesn't really get engaged with in the thread, and I feel like I'm wasting my breath at this point.
This Town wants to lynch me when I've been on the right side of literally every lynch since I replaced in, and right on PP being Town well before the Wheme lynch. Why? because "hurr durr tgb unvoted wheme", despite it objectively being the correct policy decision to do so and backed up by me seeing a speedhammer in Mini 2010. (and despite the fact that I was one of the counter-wagons to Wheme)
I even debated not unvoting because I knew it could look shady after he died, if he flipped Scum, but I was like, eh, not doing something because you're afraid of looking scummy is literally the #1 scum motivation, so it's better to do it. I assumed someone might not get that unvoting was correct policy, and FoS me for it, but I never assumed it would be the majority of the thread. Dunn had the read on me right, and he knew it was correct policy, so what did the thread do? Lynch him, because they couldn't grasp why
his own
choice was correct policy. It's asinine. I hope y'all learn not to auto-judge policy decisions like this anymore.
you'd think after two straight mislynches, people would realize they've been off-base this game, (and likely steered that way by mafia) but y'all are charging straight ahead with shockingly little re-evaluation, and I'm just done with it. I can't make you listen, and I can't make you pause to think critically. Maybe that's on me for not being strong enough of a leader, or eloquent enough in my explanations, but regardless, I've hit the point of frustration with the gamestate where I'm not willing to put in more effort right now.
Posted: Sat Aug 04, 2018 9:55 pm
by Krazy
I was mostly wondering whether you thought scion really fit a scum team well. I have mixed feelings on his slot, and I dislike having mixed feelings on a leading wagon.
I'm pretty sure if town keeps lynching literally everyone who has ever voted texcat that this town loses to some of the lowest effort scum ever, but that's their perogative.
Scion is like:
-meta does not fit his town profile (this is shit, but he seems super disengaged compared to the wallposts he is clearly capable of)
-mylo vote is shitty and kinda opportunistic
vs.
-he doesn't fit texcat team well
-town is helping scum lynch everyone who has ever voted texcat
-I have no idea what to make of his vote for wheme, but it almost looks 'too scummy to be scum'
Not sure how to sort that. While I have other townreads at the moment, their judgement seems shitty, so you're the only person in this game who actually seems to be making good points and is also clearly town. So do you think scion is scum? Because if so, I'd like help sorting him. And if not, we need to figure out a different wagon.
Is it the fact his subset has a great chance of being all town?
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 2:56 am
by Golden Robster
In post 5624, Gamma Emerald wrote:Um I didn't think context was necessary? It just didn't feel like a real "fake guilty" thought process. Something felt off about it.
okay these feel dissonant VOTE: Golden Robster
Not entirely confident, but from what I've seen both from back reading and this, I'm not too impressed by his content
dissonant = disagreeing
how have I disagreed with myself here today?
I scumread them but some players have a HIGHER chance of flipping scum just by looking at wheme wagon and what happened in terms of stalling
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 3:00 am
by Golden Robster
In post 5637, Gamma Emerald wrote:Myloninja is consistently like this and I'm pretty sure he's overgaming himself
subtle defending by gamma
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 3:06 am
by JarJarDrinks
In post 5491, TehBrawlGuy wrote:The big difference is that I'm not touting Wheme lynch as a thing you should give me townpoints for, but you've been happy to.
In post 5657, TehBrawlGuy wrote:This Town wants to lynch me when I've been on the right side of literally every lynch since I replaced in, and right on PP being Town well before the Wheme lynch.
In post 5624, Gamma Emerald wrote:Um I didn't think context was necessary? It just didn't feel like a real "fake guilty" thought process. Something felt off about it.
what felt off about it?
please explain
It felt like you didn't have any sort of idea of what you were doing
which I'd maybe expect from a newb too but you're not a newb, and maybe if your really bad at it but it just seems like scum that just wanted to throw shit at a wall and see if it stuck
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 8:30 am
by Krazy
Gamma can you expand on why you feel GR bussed wheme?
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 8:33 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 5671, Krazy wrote:Gamma can you expand on why you feel GR bussed wheme?
I think probably for cred
can you explain why this is your fallback question? You asked this about Dunn yesterday and it feels like you're using it as a crutch rather than trying to find actual objections to the lynch
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 8:36 am
by Krazy
What separates GR's vote(s) from anyone else on the Wheme wagon? Anything?
Why are you attacking me for questioning you instead of building a more convincing case on your vanity wagon?
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 8:40 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 5673, Krazy wrote:What separates GR's vote(s) from anyone else on the Wheme wagon? Anything?
Why are you attacking me for questioning you instead of building a more convincing case on your vanity wagon?
I don't know yet because I'm not at that point in the read back. I'll work on that when I get there though, thanks.
As for why I'm questioning you, it's because you kinda feel like you're going Groundhog Day here, just repeating the same shit from yesterday. Doesn't feel very genuine.