Newbie 1425 Part Deux -- Game Over

[ArcAngel9]

i ll get my thoughts today
there is no need to rush..we have plenty of time.

[RayFrost]

"I'll gt my thoughts in within the day" - arc and cats.

Please. PLEASE. No excuse for being inactive like this.

[Malakittens]

One could be mafia taking total advantage.

[ArcAngel9]

I rather want to go with Cats than mala...
but the question can we afford a mislynch today?

Cat dies...if cat is scum, we win
if cat flips town.. one of us will die in the night..
it will 2 vs 1

Smug and Ray - who are you comfortable voting today? Mala or Cat?

[Nobody Special]

Smudger has been prodded.

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 3.02

Malakittens - 1 - RayFrost

Not Voting: ObsessedWithCats, Malakittens, ArcAngel9, Smudger

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-23 06:14:05)

[ObsessedWithCats]

I think I have tonsillitis or something

On the 'scum was on the Rach wagon' logic, I'd go for Ray. I'm kind of feeling like Malakittens is more likely though. I'm not entirely sure why. There's still a feeling that she's somewhat avoiding being as informative as she could be in her posts, though they look like they've got a lot more content than they did when she was posting as ER. Her interactions with ns that I could find seemed strangely precise and careful.

[Smudger]

I rather want to go with Cats than mala...
but the question can we afford a mislynch today?

Cat dies...if cat is scum, we win
if cat flips town.. one of us will die in the night..
it will 2 vs 1

Smug and Ray - who are you comfortable voting today? Mala or Cat?

Like you I am suspicious of Cats, have been for a while, but am also suspicious of Mala. but having reread Mala/ER it did not gel together in my mind, her whole play rang bells.

[Smudger]

sorry that should read Ray -"but am also suspicious of Ray"

[RayFrost]

I rather want to go with Cats than mala...
but the question can we afford a mislynch today?

Cat dies...if cat is scum, we win
if cat flips town.. one of us will die in the night..
it will 2 vs 1

Smug and Ray - who are you comfortable voting today? Mala or Cat?

By definition of still having two town people alive if we mislynch, we can "afford" to mislynch today as much as we can "afford" to mislynch day 1. We lose a townie if we do, lynching scum is better.

I will not vote cats. I will vote mala.

[RayFrost]

I already explained why I prefer mala over cats btw.

[Malakittens]

I rather want to go with Cats than mala...
but the question can we afford a mislynch today?

Cat dies...if cat is scum, we win
if cat flips town.. one of us will die in the night..
it will 2 vs 1

Smug and Ray - who are you comfortable voting today? Mala or Cat?

By definition of still having two town people alive if we mislynch, we can "afford" to mislynch today as much as we can "afford" to mislynch day 1. We lose a townie if we do, lynching scum is better.

I will not vote cats. I will vote mala.

So when I flip town who will you look at next? Cats?

[RayFrost]

I will have to reevaluate. Just blindly going "poe says I should look at cats next" would be silly. I'd re-read smudger / arc as well as cats, look for connections to the dead cum / other cum tells, and decide from there.

[Smudger]

Ray your last post is uncomfortable, I see what you are saying but it seems out of context when lined up against your previous posts, it is almost like you just threw it away to appease Mala, in particular you seemed so sure earlier.

[RayFrost]

Would you be happier if I phrased it as "if on the highly unlikely chance that you flip town, my worldview will be so rocked that I will have to reevaluate the entirety of this game to make sure that I'm not letting anything slip by"

Seriously.

[Smudger]

ha ha… no not really…

[Smudger]

and yes seriously… why, is that a problem?

[RayFrost]

I don't seem to understand what you were trying to say in your post.

My understanding is "you seemed so sure about mala being scum, why are you replying to her post in a way that displays you are entertaining the thought of her flipping town?"

In which case my post above is my reply. If not, you're going to have to explain to me what exactly you mean.

[Smudger]

You seemed so sure of your reads early on and that Mala was the correct lynch, and yet you are saying you would re-read. If that is the case then you are not so sure of your reads, surely?

[RayFrost]

What I said was in reaction to her hypothesis of her flipping town.

Not in general

[Smudger]

So do you have a doubt about her lynch or are you solid on the Idea? Because although you are responding to a hypothesis and answering am obvious question that should be asked at this stage, I am not convinced your response is 100% genuine, and so my comment about it appearing to be a throw away line to appease her question.

You know I am still drawn to you or Cats fort earlier stated reasons as the more likely candidates at this time

[Smudger]

That was a terrible post mis spelling etc, am on phone

[RayFrost]

I'm completely decidedly for lynching mala. The comment

was

a throwaway line to appease her question because I don't think the situation will come up. If by some ungodly chance it did, I'd have to reevaluate the game because the reality I am currently living in (aka mala-scum) has been destroyed (aka mala is actually town).

[ArcAngel9]

I will have to reevaluate. Just blindly going "poe says I should look at cats next" would be silly. I'd re-read smudger / arc as well as cats, look for connections to the dead cum / other cum tells, and decide from there.

We have time.. SO do your HOME WORK. If you want to review others once again, its probably not a bad idea.
this much i am sure that Smudger is not scum because of my read on RACH. So I just have to re-check on Mala, Cats and also Ray again. Not that I Ray is scum now but it wouldn't hurt checking on him again.

Again, there is no need to rush this day. We have 8 cool days..so lets just take it slow. We make our lynch with a clear understanding. I expect to each one of you to be cooperative with me on this. Thank you

[RayFrost]

I've done my homework already. I already stated that, in this game day, I feel mala is the best lynch. What I was saying was expressly regarding what I would be doing over the night phase if mala flipped town.

That is all.