Mini 502: Basically Communist Mafia- Game Over. Who won?
Forum rules
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
Did you think Max was scum too?pdcakes wrote:adel: i mainly just wanted to check my sanity. And as I said before I really thought Jack was scum and i wanted to check to see that it wasnt my sanity that caused him to come up town.
and while i do suspect jdodge to be scum i am going to hold off voting him for now.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
i'm sure there are many examples, spare us the links please. change your ratio and i'll change my voteJDodge wrote:You do realize that said signal:noise is normal for me, right? Let me find you some examples.Adel wrote:many words, little information
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
Why is there any reason on day 2 to try to paint me as having investigation immunity?theopor_COD wrote:Yep JDodge is innocent "presumably" but I feel it's a better move to protect the person we investigate.
and that's all i've got at the moment
ok here is what i am thinking right now:
my gut is telling me to vote jdodge because of the reasons listed earlier.
HOWEVER:
Adel replaced theo. And for awhile now i have suspected that theo was mafia and figured out i was the cop and thats why he kept trying so hard to get me lynched.
so im gonna go do some post analysis.
my gut is telling me to vote jdodge because of the reasons listed earlier.
HOWEVER:
Adel replaced theo. And for awhile now i have suspected that theo was mafia and figured out i was the cop and thats why he kept trying so hard to get me lynched.
so im gonna go do some post analysis.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
"always assume there is a godfather" and "never thrust a cop's sanity until he gets a guilty and an innocent and one is proven correct."JDodge wrote:Why is there any reason on day 2 to try to paint me as having investigation immunity?theopor_COD wrote:Yep JDodge is innocent "presumably" but I feel it's a better move to protect the person we investigate.
and that's all i've got at the moment
theopor_COD is a good player. my scumgroup killed him N1 in another game, even though he wasn't one of the claimed powerroles.
Game Over; Town Wins. Roles, Status, and Full Nightchoices Below.
Roles and Status:
Alive:
pdcakes, cop, wins
Adel (replacing theopor_COD (replacing Rhakith), townie, wins
Adel (replacing theopor_COD (replacing Rhakith), townie, wins
Dead:
Kate, mafia goon, Lynched day one
undo, townie, Shot night one
Kilroy8679305, townie, Stabbed night one
Jennar, townie, Lynched day two (replacing Green Day)
White, townie, Stabbed night two.
gorckat (replacing SilverPhoenix), mafia goon, stabbed night three
Max, townie, shot night three
The Fonz (replaced Snow pregame), mafia goon, lynched day four
Nocmen (replacing Qman), doctor, stabbed night four
JDodge (replacing Jack), kill and investigation immune serial killer, lynched day five.
Investigations and Protections:
Jdodge investigated night one.
Jdodge protected night one.
Max investigated night two.
Max protected night two.
pdcakes investigated night three.
pdcakes protected night three.
Adel investigated night four
pdcakes protected night four
Game in Full:
Kate, mafia goon, lynched day one.
Night one:
pdcakes, cop, investigates Jdodge (fails)
Nocmen, doctor, protects Jdodge (useless)
Jdodge, serial killer, kills Kilroy
Gorckat, mafia goon, kills undo
Jennar, townie, lynched day two.
Night Two:
pdcakes investigates Max (town)
Nocmen protects Max.
Jdodge kills White
TheFonz kills Jdodge (fails)
No lynch day three.
Night three:
pdcakes investigates pdcakes (town)
Nocmen protects pdcakes
Jdodge kills gorckat
gorckat kills Max.
TheFonz, mafia goon, lynched day four.
Night Four:
pdcakes investigates adel (town)
Nocmen protects pdcakes.
Jdodge kills Nocmen.
Jdodge, serial killer, lynched day five.
Last edited by Simenon on Tue Nov 13, 2007 2:23 pm, edited 2 times in total.
SEND THE VECTOIDS
Comments:
No criticisms for the town: they did very well considering the number of replacements.
I think all the scum did fine as well and I was puzzled by the gorck lynch.
The setup was in the favor of any scum, I know. In the future I would take out a scum or kill the sk's immunity. I liked the sk because it added dimension and surprise to the game without sacrificing elegance, but the setup was too slanted.
I am very pleased with those who stuck with it and very, very grateful for all of the replacement support. Thanks for making this a fun game!
No criticisms for the town: they did very well considering the number of replacements.
I think all the scum did fine as well and I was puzzled by the gorck lynch.
The setup was in the favor of any scum, I know. In the future I would take out a scum or kill the sk's immunity. I liked the sk because it added dimension and surprise to the game without sacrificing elegance, but the setup was too slanted.
I am very pleased with those who stuck with it and very, very grateful for all of the replacement support. Thanks for making this a fun game!
SEND THE VECTOIDS
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
woot! it was
I liked the flavor, and the mechanic. I think all of those extra votes for the investigation and the protect really helped my analysis.
really
hard for me not to write pages of text inditing JDodge in the endgame. I think me arguing for a JDodge lynch would've resulted in my lynch, and a town loss. I'm very proud of myself for not typing!I liked the flavor, and the mechanic. I think all of those extra votes for the investigation and the protect really helped my analysis.
- Adel
- Adel
-
Adel
- Crystalline Logick
- Crystalline Logick
- Posts: 6743
- Joined: May 23, 2007
- Location: Central Oregon / High Desert
...don't be so sure. My cases often have a habit of backfiring on me (look at how many times I've been lynched) and I suspected that Jdodge would be able to twist my words beter than I could unwist them. The one exchange we had didn't go so well for me. So I posted enough to show that I was following the game and involved, and I deleted at least 80% of what I wrote before I hit "submit".