In post 563, EspressoPatronum wrote:I'm assuming that's why TL and CSF claimed VT -- it's easy to get away with.
TemporalLich claimed Town Watcher.
He claimed VT as alignment
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 1:01 pm
by EspressoPatronum
In post 574, Pink Ball wrote:Can I get a summary on claims please? I didn't pay much attention since I was getting back to Chile (we did it by the way!! Got extremely lucky)
I'm compiling them all together + will post a big list combined with Micc's card deck.
Eta tonight or tomorrow.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 1:06 pm
by Sujimichi
EspressoPatronum
- Town Rolecop
Checked SirCakez Night 1 - Seer
Checked Pink Ball Night 2 - Roleblocker
Kerset
- Town 1-shot Day Vigilante
Shot Cat Scratch Fever Day 3
Sujimichi
- Town Watcher
Watched TemporalLich Night 1 - SirCakez visited
Watched Cat Scratch Fever Night 2 - No one visited.
GlowingOvineChimes
- Town Vigilante
Shot BBmolla Night 1
Shot Untrod Tripod Night 2
Sircakez
- Town Seer
Checked TemporalLich Night 1 with a negative result
Check EspressoPatronum Night 2 with a negative result
In post 563, EspressoPatronum wrote:2) While it's hard for me to now prove my role, I can still be used to validate existing claims. For what it's worth, I made a comment earlier about SirCakez having a reduced chance of being scum. My thought process there is that picking the seer power as WW is terrible, so he's almost certainly not WW.
Why did you not assume he could have been a Mafia Seer? I would think that it would be a beneficial power as that alignment.
I said 'reduced chance of scum' (meaning any evil faction) because I assumed he would not be a WW seer. He very well could be a mafia or SK seer.
For context, here's my original comment before claims:
In post 480, GlowingOvineChimes wrote:Not sure why there were no scum kills but if it was due to a protective- good job! Keep it up!
As for my reads today, I think suji and CSF are definitely town, kerset and pb are most likely town so that leaves espresso and sircakez as scum
Thoughts?
What makes you think CSF and Kerset are town?
I have a role-related reason to believe Sircakez has a reduced chance of being scum, so I'm interested to see why you think he's scum. More importantly, what faction?
In post 552, Pink Ball wrote:That's great. If game hasn't ended Id suggest lynching the baby seal and if THAT doesn't ends the game then at least it becomes nightless allegedly and we let EP target everyone
How does the game become nightless?
There was only one kill last night, claimed by the baby seal.
We could also no lynch today, I roleblock baby seal and let the investigators get more info. I trust EP; he could tell us if someone is lying about their roles.
Then we could have him check me, because honestly a town vig is very beneficial for town
In post 560, SirCakez wrote:No particular reason he's just not sticking out as a townread to me.
That could really be said about everyone who is left except Pink Ball though..
Then why did you choose me and GlowingOvineChimes specifically if "that could really be said about everyone who is left except Pink Ball?"
Because I was thinking in the context of Kerset Espresso and Pink having claimed provable roles
But I've since reconsidered b/c proven roles doesn't mean town here
That's why I'm hoping for Titus input cuz I'm a bit lost on this one
I can't see a world where the right play for mafia!PB is to CC mafia!TL on D2. In such a high kill power game, it seems like scum numbers mean everything here.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 2:44 pm
by Kerset
There is still unknown Titus n1 action
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 2:48 pm
by Pink Ball
Good catch
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 2:50 pm
by EspressoPatronum
Titus might as well full claim, too. We know she's town, but knowing her alignment card could possibly help us down the line.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 2:52 pm
by Kerset
Sircakez is confirmed to be seer and that he visited member of mafia on n1. He wouldn't visit maf as maf and he wouldn't pick seer as ww so he is top town for me.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 3:35 pm
by Pink Ball
Yeah for me it's between Ovine and EP basically
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 3:37 pm
by GlowingOvineChimes
In post 589, EspressoPatronum wrote:Titus might as well full claim, too. We know she's town, but knowing her alignment card could possibly help us down the line.
Didn't micc give her full role at the flip?
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 3:38 pm
by Pink Ball
I'd say the best course of action is no lynching today and asking Ovine to shoot EP; if EP flips town, we lynch her. But I'm a little impatient and I'd rather lynch Ovine today 'cause I think she's the remaining scum. At least PT called CSF out so he got that going for him.
VOTE: GlowingOvineChimes
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 3:39 pm
by GlowingOvineChimes
In post 593, Pink Ball wrote:I'd say the best course of action is no lynching today and asking Ovine to shoot EP; if EP flips town, we lynch her. But I'm a little impatient and I'd rather lynch Ovine today 'cause I think she's the remaining scum. At least PT called CSF out so he got that going for him.
VOTE: GlowingOvineChimes
Let me shoot EP tonight and you can lynch me tomorrow
In post 589, EspressoPatronum wrote:Titus might as well full claim, too. We know she's town, but knowing her alignment card could possibly help us down the line.
Didn't micc give her full role at the flip?
Unless I'm mistaken, we know that Titus has a town alignment, but we don't know what her card is.
- Nom Imh's role was one of the 3 JK cards (town/WW/maf), but it is unclear which one.
- TL claimed VT alignment but had an unknown mafia card for alignment
- CSF claimed black goo for alignment but had an unknown WW card for alignment
- UT had an unknown WW card for alignment
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 4:03 pm
by EspressoPatronum
@PB I think your earlier no-lynch strat is better. If you keep the killing roles RB'd, it'll allow me to investigate the roles to validate role claims. Meanwhile, Cakez will be able to scan for more WWs. Suji's watcher can be a possible failsafe if the the night isn't deathless.
I learned my lesson from our close call with the 3ps in MM2. Better to play it slow than risk the game over being too hasty.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2020 4:06 pm
by GlowingOvineChimes
PB if you think I'm mafia then RB me so that people can check my role and alignment