Mafiascum.net

In post 569, Titus wrote:9. Skybird - Strong town lean

Explain this one to me please.

You said earlier she was tonally scummy, but had Town logic. But, to me, both of her pushes were pretty bad, and nothing else has really stood out as feeling Town...

In post 575, Radical Rat wrote:

In post 569, Titus wrote:9. Skybird - Strong town lean

Explain this one to me please.

You said earlier she was tonally scummy, but had Town logic. But, to me, both of her pushes were pretty bad, and nothing else has really stood out as feeling Town...

Skybird tends to have a creepy tone but I don't think her pushes come from scum. Nor do her efforts to get me involved.

This is why I’m voting RR
This and having only me and Dwlee as TRs at one point after expressing town feelings on a number of slots.

That's a bit of a misrepresentation there, Mr. Emerald.

I did not say you and Dwlee were my only townreads, and in fact, I didn't even say Dwlee was a townread at all.

What I said was that you two were my only off-limits eliminations, and indeed my reason for you specifically was a strong townread.

However, I am gently leaning Town on probably about half of the playerlist. I'm still willing to eliminate within most of them though, because I am not terribly confident on most of them, despite my initial feelings, and I'm attempting to remain open to other options as opposed to trying to force my will upon the Town.

It'd be more accurate to say Skybird is my only scumread, with A50 straddling the nullscum line.

I am just about on the same page with Titus though wrt skybird, I don’t regard the tone as yucky but I do kinda have an opinion of “town if you care to actually look” on skybird

I just have certain mannerisms I tend to read as yuck and I'm trying to avoid going too far down that hole when I am stressed the fuck out.

Save The Dragons replaces Momrangal

I stand by my vote on kop here. The entrance screams scum to me.


As for other people I could probably hand out some reads but for the most part its middling.

i like dwlee for town

gamma pings me but i think he always does so i'm ignoring it for now

i like a50 for town

i like radical rat for town

not sure where skybird's attack of RR comes from

hate gamma's read of yuki

yuki seems obsessed with Taroumaru

hate gamma's 309

i'm voting gamma fuck it VOTE: gamma emerald

hate 312 just seems like fluff

i like unwnd for town

i still like RR after talking with unwnd.

starting to like Megazu

don't like 383, Ari scum. i like DOTW's response.

SANDPAPER HANDJOB OUCHIE

@skybird why does ari feel town?

wtf why'd you vote Dwlee

468 seems bad. FOSes are scummy as hell

Hate that taro's reads are mostly null

yeah megazu is town

hate NDMath's DOTW vote

TOWN
A50, Megazu, DOTW, unwnd, radical rat, dwlee

SCUM
Gamma, Yuki, Ari, Taro, NDMath

i'd probably also sheep megazu onto kop at this point

Honestly I'm probably going to be joining a deadline wagon at this point.

Sorry guys

STD did you draw scum with Yuki?

I am not scum.

Welcome STD!

I need to do a bit of re-reading and thinking. I'm leaning scum on Gamma. I didn't like his interaction with me when he wanted to talk but then faded in and out on me. I'm not liking Taro. That slot has 3 posts out of 17 that talk about the game and the rest is junk.

In post 569, Titus wrote:1. Almost50 - Town
2. NDmath - Lean Town
3. Dwlee99 - Town
5. Yuki - Lean Scum
6. Taroumaru - GTMH town would elim
7. Aristophanes - Lean Scum
8. Gamma Emerald - Lean Town
9. Skybird - Strong town lean
10. Momrangal - Wait on replacement
11. Superbowl9 - Need more
12. Titus - Pathetic town
13. Pesto - Who?
14. Radical Rat - Ok with elim to see if town is going in the right direction but not my favorite
15. KittyTacky - Lean Scum
16. Dragon Of The West - Lean Scum

Titus is town <3

Mom!slot is town

In post 585, Save The Dragons wrote:Hate that taro's reads are mostly null

How dare I not have this game solved already on day 1, for shame.

In post 592, Dwlee99 wrote:Mom!slot is town

Be honest, you say that simply because his first words were that you are town.

In post 594, Taroumaru wrote:

In post 592, Dwlee99 wrote:Mom!slot is town

Be honest, you say that simply because his first words were that you are town.

That played a non-zero part in this, yes

In post 566, Gamma Emerald wrote:Thoughts feels pretty sensible
I want more incisive thought on some things later though

But it's just words. I could call a handful of posts town, town, tonally town, and give out reads on who I think is town and who is scum. It doesn't give me any reason to say that I like it.

It doesn't give me any indication to like Titus catch up, yeah her reads maybe likeable, but the catch up to that point, seems mediocre, at best.

In post 593, Taroumaru wrote:

In post 585, Save The Dragons wrote:Hate that taro's reads are mostly null

How dare I not have this game solved already on day 1, for shame.

It's not being asked of you, to have the game solved on day 1.

In post 593, Taroumaru wrote:

In post 585, Save The Dragons wrote:Hate that taro's reads are mostly null

How dare I not have this game solved already on day 1, for shame.

there's definitely a difference between not having null reads and solving the game

In post 562, Titus wrote:

In post 501, Dragon of the West wrote:

In post 491, unwnd wrote:Kop's catchup is very mediocre, but the people who are choosing to treat his mediocrity as something special given the gamestate is troubling

Tbf Kop at least generated content on replace-in and tried to engage with the thread....which is saying something based on how much nothing most of the game has been

Town

In post 569, Titus wrote:1. Almost50 - Town
2. NDmath - Lean Town
3. Dwlee99 - Town
5. Yuki - Lean Scum
6. Taroumaru - GTMH town would elim
7. Aristophanes - Lean Scum
8. Gamma Emerald - Lean Town
9. Skybird - Strong town lean
10. Momrangal - Wait on replacement
11. Superbowl9 - Need more
12. Titus - Pathetic town
13. Pesto - Who?
14. Radical Rat - Ok with elim to see if town is going in the right direction but not my favorite
15. KittyTacky - Lean Scum
16. Dragon Of The West - Lean Scum

Are you calling me or unwnd town in 562?