Mafiascum.net

Guys gotta stop leaving these pagetops open

hello mr.

In post 574, schadd_ wrote:VOTE: cows love sushi rolls a lot of these things i've heard from you have been like you're almost explicitly speculating on possible motivations behind your posts from a sort of external perspective

yeah i tend to do that when there's someone who is taking a group of my posts the wrong way
which has like, happened multiple times this game, ur correct about that
why does it make me scum again

as town: there's stuff that's going on in your head, and youre posting. if you get into a little argument about what the things were in your head, it's pretty painless to set things straight and give specific anchors as to what your intentions were. sometimes people even do so intensely! like: ahhh, can't you see what i was thinking, it was so clear to me, etc. etc.

as mafia: when you post you are possibly going through a set of possible motivations you might have and choosing the one that seems most true to form. and when you write the posts, you hope that there is a line of thoughts/motivations that makes sense that it would map to your posts. if someone argues with you, thats spooky. i think a way to approach it that feels safe is to be vague and try to close off as few of those potential thoughts/motivations to your posts as possible rather than pin yourself down to one thing. i think you have been playing very unpinned.

i keep rereading the post and all i can think about is the fact that i've never thought about doing this as mafia in chat
and therefore wouldn't use in forum even with the massively increased deadlines which'd allow me to do whatever

and i feel like in forum i'd much rather do the opposite of what you've said as scum, if i have it understood correctly
i think the average townies (or at the very least, me? i haven't taken notes) reward consistent and clear solving a lot and if they can glean one or two descriptors from a skim of my entire ISO or recent posting then i'd make it those

and that's exactly how i play as town too
you could make a case that the failure to keep up with that sort of thing is scum-leaning as i'm trying to mimic my previous towngames and failing

but this whole game has been sort of a failure for me LOL that likely transcends alignment

if this was too off topic then lmk i think i mightve missed your point

In post 579, cowsloveSushirolls wrote:i keep rereading the post and all i can think about is the fact that i've never thought about doing this as mafia in chat

which is "the post" and what is "doing this" referring to

In post 580, schadd_ wrote:

In post 579, cowsloveSushirolls wrote:i keep rereading the post and all i can think about is the fact that i've never thought about doing this as mafia in chat

which is "the post" and what is "doing this" referring to

p#578 and the idea of playing "pinned" vs "unpinned"

In post 97, cowsloveSushirolls wrote:

In post 85, Radical Rat wrote:I don't really consider trying new things to be meta manipulation, I meant more like picking out certain tendencies and attitudes to attempt to replicate as scum. Which is what it reads like you were setting yourself up for.

And I don't really see the general statement of new players not having much established history/reputation as a specific claim about you that necessitated refutation, so I didn't consider it relevant enough to include in the quote.

I can somewhat understand where you're coming from here, but it still feels off to me. It just reads too much like scum trying to cover their bases, with a sprinkling of AtE for good measure.

it's a bit of a double-edged sword, yeah? if i'm trying to replicate something from my past games (which i actually have two of now, one finished about 30 minutes ago) then it would be pretty blatant and it would take an ISO or two to completely knock me out of the water. missed opportunity to try and catch me doing something evil, :wink:

you can talk about how irrelevant it was to the point kennyk was making but the point stands that the only reason i made that post was because of kennyk, so it was important to leave on

that's fine, i just care if my point was made to you or not

just looked at the most recent finished game of yours i happened on & found the first moment you seemed to be staging a defense of yourself. the second line of yours here seems like its almost exactly what i'm talking about: somebody is shading a certain thing you did in a post and you are simply and declaratively stating your reason for having done it. moreover i think its just like comfortable and townie in a way that i dont feel like you've been in this game

i'm going to continue to vote you for now

wondering if it is just too steep of a luxury to hear someone else share a thought or reaction here

dead game

you are literally game

does my line of inquiry intersect with your reasons for scumreading this person which is supposedly your true calling in this game? or perhaps i'm like distracting from those reasons with unnecessary chatter? or like literally anything? i am eating shit and dying here

i am allergic to reading but what i did read looks p good

ok imagine me taking your post about the game being dead and ripping it into a hundred pieces and spitting into it and drabbling ketchup and barbecue sauce on it and putting it in a blender and then lacing it with borax to trap fruit flies and then throwing the dead fruit flies + your post into a horrible swamp where they go on to get cursed by one hundred witches

ok

i understand that you are trying to apologize profusely to me but the witches' curses have stripped you of the gift of verbose language

true

probly my mistake then

of course it's when I feel like shit physically that this game gets active. Not sure I'll be catching up tonight. But from a quick skim I see there's a new wagon on Pooky I'm not sure I understand, which may be because my brain is only semi-functional right now. Also I'm flabbergasted that NO ONE else sees Pav as scum? Maybe I'm tunneling too hard but I just keep seeing a scum mindset behind his posting.

In post 594, numberQ wrote:of course it's when I feel like shit physically that this game gets active. Not sure I'll be catching up tonight. But from a quick skim I see there's a new wagon on Pooky I'm not sure I understand, which may be because my brain is only semi-functional right now. Also I'm flabbergasted that NO ONE else sees Pav as scum? Maybe I'm tunneling too hard but I just keep seeing a scum mindset behind his posting.

I looked through their ISO after reading this, but I don't see the continuous scum mindset you're seeing behind his posts. Can you please explain that a lot more?

In post 582, schadd_ wrote:just looked at the most recent finished game of yours i happened on & found the first moment you seemed to be staging a defense of yourself. the second line of yours here seems like its almost exactly what i'm talking about: somebody is shading a certain thing you did in a post and you are simply and declaratively stating your reason for having done it. moreover i think its just like comfortable and townie in a way that i dont feel like you've been in this game

you're right that i've been uncomfortable in this gamestate this entire time
i can't really name someone who wouldn't
it's why i'm not consolidating despite people's wishes for the phase to be done during the weekend
i look at pooky and i'm like "he just like me fr"
terrible way to townhunt because both alignments are going to feel that way but ramble ramble
there's a diff between

In post 81, Radical Rat wrote:This is a bad post though. Self meta doesn't work, because if you know your meta, you can manipulate it. Maybe if it's to refute a specific claim, but unprompted like this? Just reads real fishy. Especially the bit about getting killed for being a dick.

this sort of pressure for an entire game

In post 98, charlemagne wrote:

In post 79, cowsloveSushirolls wrote:i was completely unaware pavowski had posted and i suddenly have much better feelings for t3


UNVOTE: t3

VOTE: cow

serious vote, not a single post in this game has pinged me more than cow's entire iso, this post especially is +scum

and this sort of pressure for an entire game
and i mean for an entire game
i'd categorize the NQ wagon and the current pookywagon as those kinda wagons also (despite being jumpstarted by clemency)
like i'm happy that you're right here pushing, actively interacting with me and continuing to justify your vote
better treatment than the rest of this plist

In post 567, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 565, innocentvillager wrote:pooky can you give a list of some potential partners of cows

in this game you just kill the people who werent voting for him on d1 duh

okay let's just look at the list then

In post 369, Not_Mafia wrote:

VC 1.08

Pavowski (1)-

numberQ

schadd_ (0)-

T3 (1)-

StrangeMatter

innocentvillager (0)-

charlemagne (0)-

cowsloveSushirolls (5)-

PookyTheMagicalBear, Pavowski, T3, Clemency, charlemagne

(E-2)

PookyTheMagicalBear (1)-

Almost50

Enchant (0)-

numberQ (2)-

innocentvillager, schadd_

StrangeMatter (1)-

cowsloveSushirolls

Almost50 (0)-

Clemency (0)-

Not Voting (1)-

Enchant

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to instantly eliminate.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2021-10-30 21:00:00)

- Oct 30th 21:00 GMT

Enchant, schadd, innocentvillager, A50, Strange, numberQ

this is the list of players who haven't voted cows

if cows is scum, we'd expect the two partners to be here right under this logic?

If Pooky is town then i don't see why Enchant is being so vitriolic about defending Pooky so it's probably not cows/Enchant/non-pooky, also Pooky is just town for the votepark

schadd seems fine and at least is defending you and now is even pushing back to cows when the wagon on you is very unstable. Again schadd/cows/non-pooky doesn't make sense.

I'm not scum, ive been p townie on dayplay i feel
A50 is clear town on dayplay

leaves like, exactly Strange and numberQ

The only like, maybe scum voting for scum!cows is clemency? but it seems too theatre so i don't really believe it

are there parts of this people disagree with

schadd i did read your interaction with cows and it is like slightly pingy but not enough to make cows into a SR for me. i think id need to see a bit more

i resonate with the idea that when people go like "this is what i was thinking, it's very clear, how can you not understand that" it's a towntell

im less convinced that mafia are intentionally playing "unpinned" to keep their options open as a hedge. it feels like if it is true that mafia play as you described then it is more just like reflective of a subconscious "trying to explain away their actions/hide guilt" mindset

but the fact that it's still a towntell definitionally implies the absence of that when questioned about mindset is a weak scumtell so regardless you might be right

i just don't feel that it's particularly strong, i find that the other side would've been stronger for me personally. and it does seem like between the two games the way he's been getting pressured feels p different, in the game you linked it was more direct and so he could give more of a direct response.

i think 596 seemed like a pretty reasonable reply that feels at least consistent? i also have felt like the shade towards cows is like very nebulous this game, and also many people are treating this like a meme game

also for some reason townies IN GENERAL are totally okay being the d1 elim for some weird reason, like hello we literally win 25% of the time if you swing it onto someone that's not you?? id be PISSED if i were getting seriously wagoned this game lol

but ya idk

i will admit that: it is weird that cows has posted so much and i can't get a read off him on dayplay, it always feels like there's just this dripping dry somewhat self-deprecating humor in all of his posts which is actually by default kind of scummy because i don't see him going through all the emotions of getting pressured and stuff it feels very flat. Which actually maybe now that im writing this makes it feel town!indicative/NAI again because scum feel way more pressure being run up despite being weird. could just be playstyle specific idk.

i also feel like i put more stock into what i think is going on in the gamestate as i underlined above and i think there are not many people that make sense as cows partner at this point in time.

i am very open to my mind being changed about that though