Mafiascum.net

not shocked at all that Butter is trying to push me as a Scorpious buddy.

I didn't think that that Scorpios had to be scum but his last two posts are disappointing and pushing the masons as scum is lol

Jeff's explanations continue to be poor but we all know he's scum anyways. Even Butter is light bussing him.

I still think Gera is pretty scummy and the posting quality is poor but perhaps Yeezy is right and its just scorp, butter and Jeff. Would sorta make sense with both Butter and Jeff sheeping his Yeezy read.

My guess would be that Scorpious likely wants to avoid giving any information regarding associations with his partners, so it makes sense that he would attack the masons here. Basically a scumclaim, I think he's given up.

I don't at all think it's guaranteed that you're his partner, but surely you can understand how signs would point that way from my perspective? I could definitely see other possibilities, though. Scorp/Jeff/Owl, for example, would probably be my next most likely. What do you think of Owl?

sure but I've been "defending" Scorp for a while now and you are just NOW calling me scum with him the only thing that changed is that I started calling you scum or am I mistaken?

I thought Owl was scummy but he's prob just town.

Also, you are pushing me, jeff, scorp team. Why do I push my other buddy and not just bus for town cred? It makes no sense and I know that you know that you aren't being honest.

In post 565, Nero Cain wrote:dude, yeezy got wagoned and claimed mason. Why are you pretending like that didn't happen?

i forgot, sorry, when i ISO the mod for vote counts there was never a wagon there. i think Mod said it got to 1 vote

In post 569, Scorpious wrote:

In post 561, Quiet Owl wrote:Iso for both Enchant and capo22 is tiny and has very little content of substance in it. VOTE: Enchant

And there is Ahri saying how they liked how capo voted me. I can see an Ahri Enchant team right now.

Town reading Owl

this is the dumbest of posts.

butterchurn long post 573 kinda makes sense - i think there is an argument to be made that scorpious is likely scum, odds over 50 for sure, there are now too few slots left that could be scum and whatever the masons have on them which has caused the push - i think i have to trust them. i know Ahri rolled back their guilty claim but to me at least it doesn't make sense unless someone there checked scorpious out and got something, even if it is only a strong indication that scorpious is likely lying.

VOTE: scorpious

they should have died already, it is weird they haven't and throwing mud at the mason team and spitting off random "this person is town" takes, they helped with the fua elimination yesterday - there is just too much there to make it likely they are town.

In post 578, geraintm wrote:i think Mod said it got to 1 vote

naw, you said Yeezy was scummy and then Jeff and Butter voted there b4 he claimed mason.

In post 579, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 578, geraintm wrote:i think Mod said it got to 1 vote

naw, you said Yeezy was scummy and then Jeff and Butter voted there b4 he claimed mason.

sorry, i missed that. i normally go by mod vote counts to remember wagons to refresh my memory

no worries was just correcting you.

In post 562, Nero Cain wrote:what do you think of Jeff town reading that slot?

Doesn't make sense. Didn't see anything that stood out as town positive from them.
Have a vague memory of someone suggesting in an older game that scum should hide their partners in their town reads rather than their null/scum, but don't feel very confident about Jeff being scum.

I think most players sorta spread them out amongst null/town and scum but generally yes, scum do null read their buddies. Mafia isn't a black and white science where scum do this and scum don't do that.

it's entirely possible that Jeff did chainsaw defend his buddy d1 and is hard defending Enchant and going for the "scum wouldn't do that!" (its kinda working ) but I sorta think Jeff just knows that capo/enchant is town and thats why he's so sure of his town read on that slot.

idk why we still staling, Scorpio naturally called me+Ahri mafia team, while Ahri and thislurkerwhoclaimedasceticvigilantedon'tremembername are claimed masons.

Vote Scorprious.

i guess there's no real point

In post 577, Nero Cain wrote:sure but I've been "defending" Scorp for a while now and you are just NOW calling me scum with him the only thing that changed is that I started calling you scum or am I mistaken?

Because, minus a few weird things you've done/said, my gut says you look like the only other person actually putting in effort to solve the game, and that makes me think you're town. I know you're a very experienced player, though, and I expect you to be able to do that as mafia as well (and my gut isn't particularly accurate), so I decided to look at things from more of a POE/analyzing associations lens to see what possibilities make sense to me. I also wasn't particularly convinced of Scorpious being scum until I worked things out in that post. I don't think I was saying anything new or revolutionary by saying that if he's scum, you're a likely partner, I think everyone can see that.

In post 577, Nero Cain wrote:Also, you are pushing me, jeff, scorp team. Why do I push my other buddy and not just bus for town cred? It makes no sense and I know that you know that you aren't being honest.

What? Where did you get that? No, I'm not at all. It's a possibility, but not a particularly strong one, and I don't think I ever said it was. You/scorp/owl seems most likely to me from that analysis.

My thought process here is that if you are in fact town, we probably will lose if we aren't able to work together. Unless someone is confirmed scum, I'm willing to talk to them as if they're town and hear their side of things. Maybe you don't see it the same way, maybe you just would rather lock in your suspicions and say "gg go next hope I'm right" like everyone else in this game, and honestly, I can see the appeal. But I know that either you're scum or you're town who is wrong, and I'm willing to keep trying in case it's the latter.

This has been by far the absolute worst display of logic and debate I’ve ever witnessed in anything requiring logic and debate … I don’t even want to be a part of it

Enchant, ger, Ahri GG.. if that’s what you wanna call it.

VOTE: Scorpious

HAMMER

You was hammered long ago.

I just hope you are scum because you are soooo bad at being town if you aren’t lol..

Thx, i love my badness.

Just bad joojoo all around this game.

I got a warning for calling out an obvious troll. Well. Obvious to anyone over 20..(who posted twice and got replaced, imagine that)the greeting wagon was atrocious, And just the absolute reluctance for any real gameplay,just a bunch of nonsense.

Butterchurn and Nero, I hope we find ourselves in a better game with each other. I like your styles.

You said i am mafia with only PART of masons. Like.

Wtf.

Vanilla Townie

Welcome, Scorpious, to Mini Normal 2257: Polish Rap! Your role is

Vanilla Townie.

You have no special powers.

You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member remains alive.

Ascetic Mason

Welcome, Enchant, to Mini Normal 2257: Polish Rap! Your role is

Ascetic Mason.

You know that [REDACTED] [is/are] Town-aligned, and may speak to them [in this PT] at Night.

Actions that target you, other than kills, will fail as if roleblocked.

You have no active abilities.

You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member remains alive.

I guess the good news is that masons are confirmed to exist, so there's no need to be paranoid about that anymore. 3 scum hiding among 4 people. As of now, I would lean towards voting geraintm, but I want to take a more in depth look at the thread knowing Scorpious and Enchant's alignments.

Please don't vote anyone right away -- if town votes town here we probably lose immediately. This game is definitely winnable still.

Welp, I was wrong. I was thinking that Owl was the third mason but Enchant being stubborn and useless makes sense as one. So right now I'm thinking scum is maybe Jeff, owl, and one of Butter/Ger or maybe Butter pushing for a Ger elimination means its a Jeff, Owl, Butter team. IDK


I think Jeff is the correct vote today but we should massclaim first off. My proposed order is Owl, Jeff, Ger, Butter but maybe the order doesn't really matter here.