i have no issues with this.
i would add sakura and jjh as well
The only thing I want to townbin
Sakura
for is to see the resolution of her claim and not based off her play thus far, so I'm wondering what people see there.
And as for
Jjh
? The logic-mindmeld is very strong and their responses to me have been on-point and that somehow is what makes me fearful.
When I read
jjh
, I feel like I understand why most people are paranoid upon townreading me because there is a sense of competence that overshadows a concrete motive.
Like, how is he so candid with townlocking majority of the playerlist - it can't just be because he wants to race to solve the game first? How does he have the best answer to
Gypy'x
IC claim but 180'd from pushing them while he somewhat spiraled with a carousel hypothesis for mech? Why doesn't he second-think the fact that our scumreads are largely consensus - or does he see value in rethinking?
He just seems confident and I don't know if it's powertown or informed and I really, really want to figure out sooner than later.
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:17 pm
by Good Luck Buddy
but im not going to scumread u for this mod speculation shit. I never verified it because i know rc has used post restrictions before
@ydra yes i know, and he might have thought he needed to continue the posting style. But now im going into conspiracy thinking
i have no issues with this.
i would add sakura and jjh as well
The only thing I want to townbin
Sakura
for is to see the resolution of her claim and not based off her play thus far, so I'm wondering what people see there.
And as for
Jjh
? The logic-mindmeld is very strong and their responses to me have been on-point and that somehow is what makes me fearful.
When I read
jjh
, I feel like I understand why most people are paranoid upon townreading me because there is a sense of competence that overshadows a concrete motive.
Like, how is he so candid with townlocking majority of the playerlist - it can't just be because he wants to race to solve the game first? How does he have the best answer to
Gypy'x
IC claim but 180'd from pushing them while he somewhat spiraled with a carousel hypothesis for mech? Why doesn't he second-think the fact that our scumreads are largely consensus - or does he see value in rethinking?
He just seems confident and I don't know if it's powertown or informed and I really, really want to figure out sooner than later.
Throw GLB and CW out.
I have read some more and my scumreads are currently (GLB, Gypyx, CW)
My only townread is Datisi.
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:22 pm
by Good Luck Buddy
In post 5975, Taly wrote:The only thing I want to townbin Sakura for is to see the resolution of her claim and not based off her play thus far, so I'm wondering what people see there.
And as for Jjh? The logic-mindmeld is very strong and their responses to me have been on-point and that somehow is what makes me fearful.
When I read jjh, I feel like I understand why most people are paranoid upon townreading me because there is a sense of competence that overshadows a concrete motive.
Like, how is he so candid with townlocking majority of the playerlist - it can't just be because he wants to race to solve the game first? How does he have the best answer to Gypy'x IC claim but 180'd from pushing them while he somewhat spiraled with a carousel hypothesis for mech? Why doesn't he second-think the fact that our scumreads are largely consensus - or does he see value in rethinking?
don't tell this to sakura but i forgot why i townread her. i think i reaction tested her early day 1 and just really liked her response.
as far as jjh, if he is mind-melding he is doing so for me before i even get words on page. So good job on his end. I mean if ur paranoid of his townblocking manner and mindmelding did u check his scum game out? i can't say i looked into his scum game but i feel he would treat me alot differently here if scum. Like i don't think he would be eager to townblock me or even push same reads as me
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:23 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 5972, Good Luck Buddy wrote:i don't like ur fake post restriction. and you haven't pinged me.
what would u think my read on u would be right now
It Is A Real Post Restriction Trust Me I Would Never Do This To Myself Voluntarily
The Reason I Asked Is Because I Am Pretty Disengaged And I Feel Like My Play Is Not That Different From The People You Are Calling Lost Scum
In post 5972, Good Luck Buddy wrote:i don't like ur fake post restriction. and you haven't pinged me.
what would u think my read on u would be right now
It Is A Real Post Restriction Trust Me I Would Never Do This To Myself Voluntarily
The Reason I Asked Is Because I Am Pretty Disengaged And I Feel Like My Play Is Not That Different From The People You Are Calling Lost Scum
I Don't Have A Confident Guess That's Why I Asked
i feel ur playing differently than the lost scum. i would say i think u seem genuinely disengaged? if that makes sense. and not to be rude, but ive seen u kind of behave in this disengaged way alot as town so like ur not really out of ur element in my eyes.
Can you tell us why you think he should stay alive?
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:26 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 5984, Good Luck Buddy wrote:i feel ur playing differently than the lost scum. i would say i think u seem genuinely disengaged? if that makes sense. and not to be rude, but ive seen u kind of behave in this disengaged way alot as town so like ur not really out of ur element in my eyes.
It's Not Rude It's Completely Accurate
Assuming We Actually Get To Play After The Trial Bullshit I Think It Will Get Better To Some Extent
i have no issues with this.
i would add sakura and jjh as well
The only thing I want to townbin
Sakura
for is to see the resolution of her claim and not based off her play thus far, so I'm wondering what people see there.
And as for
Jjh
? The logic-mindmeld is very strong and their responses to me have been on-point and that somehow is what makes me fearful.
When I read
jjh
, I feel like I understand why most people are paranoid upon townreading me because there is a sense of competence that overshadows a concrete motive.
Like, how is he so candid with townlocking majority of the playerlist - it can't just be because he wants to race to solve the game first? How does he have the best answer to
Gypy'x
IC claim but 180'd from pushing them while he somewhat spiraled with a carousel hypothesis for mech? Why doesn't he second-think the fact that our scumreads are largely consensus - or does he see value in rethinking?
He just seems confident and I don't know if it's powertown or informed and I really, really want to figure out sooner than later.
Throw GLB and CW out.
I have read some more and my scumreads are currently (GLB, Gypyx, CW)
My only townread is Datisi.
This doesn't feel like
Nancy
scum and
Cheeky
reads as pretty sensible. Is there something I should focus on with this slot?
Why
Datisi
-town?
~
Fire
Noted on both fronts.
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:30 pm
by Taly
How do I describe my
Nancy
read?
Nancy
-scum feels like a hot knife slicing through butter (everybody else)
Nancy
-town feels like a magnifying glass in the sun glaring down at an insect (everybody else again)
I feel like the latter when I read her posts.
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:31 pm
by Good Luck Buddy
good description
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:34 pm
by Not Known 15
The red flag on CW was the datisi read progression, that's a really bad flag.
There are multiple red flags on GLB: Their double explanation of the Ircher vote change, and their defense tied to Gypyx.
Gypyx has a really scummy role claim that screams "I need to survive" and lied during explanations.
Gypyx is tied to GLB as well.
Datisi on the other hand... this play doesn't look to me like it comes from scum. It is the one really not only pushing sensibly but also just feels like town to me, but I can't really explain that. I rarely have townreads but they have been accurate so far(when I was town, of course!).
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:50 pm
by Sakura Hana
In post 5980, Good Luck Buddy wrote:on't tell this to sakura but i forgot why i townread her. i think i reaction tested her early day 1 and just really liked her response.
In post 5966, Good Luck Buddy wrote:nothing and thats problem. T3 is pretty active in responding/solving even if he has bad takes. This game he feels like he is going for purposeful or maybe he can't keep up.
Ydrasse targeted gypyx but T3 and Clemency got frozen instead. I think that points to T3 being likely town, besides this looks like their town meta to me here.
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:59 pm
by Taly
reaction test? never heard of it, those things only happened in 2016 mafia
: wink : at
fire
Posted: Wed Nov 24, 2021 12:59 pm
by Cheeky Wings
In post 5973, Good Luck Buddy wrote:i could be wrong about my mod meta on rc games but if i remember right he doesn't like putting in post restrictions because they are annoying. so unless u explicitly asked for one (who does that), i have no idea why he would include one for u to do this robot speak
No, he did that both in the other uPick I was in and he also did that in Labrynth and Undertale as well. RC loves this shit, so I don’t know why you’d think it’s fake?
The only obviously fake post restriction is Victorine’s.
In post 5973, Good Luck Buddy wrote:i could be wrong about my mod meta on rc games but if i remember right he doesn't like putting in post restrictions because they are annoying. so unless u explicitly asked for one (who does that), i have no idea why he would include one for u to do this robot speak
No, he did that both in the other uPick I was in and he also did that in Labrynth and Undertale as well. RC loves this shit, so I don’t know why you’d think it’s fake?
The only obviously fake post restriction is Victorine’s.
i know he has done post restrictions. and i could be misremembering our conversations of them and inserting my own opinion into his. But thats besides point. it really doesn't matter if its fake or not to me. It only matters if SS is using as a shield to hide.
