Mafiascum.net

↑ UberNinja wrote:Chrimi is town as well btw.

Good lad.

As if there were ever any doubt. C'mon DMS it's Day 1 and you know reaction testing is how I do.

So what do you think of Jal? (not my "case" on Jal... what do you think of Jal herself?)

I like that he (she?) sees me as Town here.

↑ drmyshotgun wrote:I like that he (she?) sees me as Town here.

Do you have anything to say about her alignment?

That's obviously what I want to know; I could care less if she thinks or is pretending to think you are town.

I'm not feelin' this Greywing wagon.

Time is short Uber.

I'll look closer into Jal tomorrow.
Anything I should dig specifically?

UNVOTE: Greywing
VOTE: drmyshotgun

I'm about half-way through, I'll be caught up today.

↑ drmyshotgun wrote:Time is short Uber.

I'll look closer into Jal tomorrow.
Anything I should dig specifically?

All of her posts. Her attitude. Her general uselessness and flying-under-the-radar-ness.

I'm not interested in a BK wagon btw. This is the first game I've ever had a town read on him.



I DID just see a scummy nomination for BK201 and Malakittens for best scum team though...

Have I mentioned Chrimi and Shiidaji are scum together?

Because they are.

↑ Greywing wrote:VOTE: Drmyshotgun

Your blatant buddying of Chrimi is setting off alarm bells.

This is a town post too. Greywing is town. Town, I say.

Also, drmyshotgun is buddying me quite hard as well.

↑ Chrimi wrote:Yes, it's fucking UberNinja, here to somehow know who the fuck is scum automatically <3

I like how Chrimi says this until I point the finger at him, and then all of a sudden I'm scum and terrible at the game.

Haha

↑ Shiidaji wrote:

↑ Jal wrote:@Shiidaji:

In post 63, Shiidaji wrote:
I'm curious as to why though, I can't see newbscum doing this. What are you seeing?


You don't see a newbscum or scum-anything being overly defensive or "OMGUSing?" That's what Arugula voted him for.

There's also no indication LH is newb-anything, as he's made it clear he's played several games prior to this. He's only new to the site.

Oh come on, just look at her posts and tell me that's coming from self-concious, always alert scum, eugh. I know there's always that one game where that one guy that's just "Too scummy to be scum" is actually scum, but I don't think that's the case here. And I do not doubt that he has experience with mafia, it's just that newness to the site that's making him look extremely scummy to the 'scumhunters' that build cases around such golden tidbits like OMGUS and the like. (why)

This post I'm not getting great vibes off of.

Scummy

↑ UberNinja wrote:Chrimi is town as well btw.

What happened to this, Uber?

You are flip-flopping like crazy and besides the bad case on Jal, have given no reason for doing so.

↑ Greywing wrote:Blast is leaning Town right now. We played together in Newbie 1247 (his first game on site I believe) and he was Town. I don't see a difference between this game, and N1247 as of yet. It's hardly a solid case, but that's my gut reaction to him right now.

This is not a scum post

↑ drmyshotgun wrote:Wonderful thing "Gut". You can point out scummy things from a player's posts and yet still conclude with fence-sitting saying "Gut".

So since I buddied Chrimi and it was "confirmed" by Chrimi, I

CAN

be Town?
This is really bad wording from Greywing.

So the suspects are:
Roflcopter
Greywing
Loran
Blastoise

IF shotty is scum, there is at least 1 scum in this list. But probably only one.

My guess is, it's roflcopter.

It's time to play the Process of Elimination game.

Town:
Loranthaceae, obviously
Greywing
BK201
Blastoide

Probably town:
Arugula
Chrimi (he's trying way too hard to appear so, but I'm convinced for now)
Malakittens

This leaves:
drmyshotgun/Hyperion
roflcopter
Shiidaji
Jal

Scum is in there, guaranteed.

Guaran-fucking-teed.

↑ Jal wrote:

↑ Chrimi wrote:He hasn't done anything to make me believe he's scum, so for the time being I believe he's town. After all, it's much more likely given the town to scum ratio.

Oh times have certainly changed, haven't they? But then Uber replaces in and you're all over trying to suck up to him. Makes the mind wonder.

↑ Chrimi wrote:And it's a lot more believable if I switch my vote to someone else, is it not?

To make what more believable, exactly?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Chrimi

Okay this post also makes me 100% sure Jal is scum.
First I wanted to attack Jal with a mix of good/bad reasons to see what people would say (scumbuddy reaction test, obv), but here's the real reason Jal is scum:

It's a common scum tactic of accusing someone of being scummy, BUT, doing it in question form so it doesn't look like an accusation. It hurts other people's opinions of the person being questioned, but also gives them a chance to "redeem" themselves. In other words, its the ultimate in wishy-washy half-accusations while at the same time appearing to look like genuine scumhunting (to the untrained eye, at least). So in a game with less experienced players, it kills two birds with one stone.

Go ahead, look through her ISO. I'm not making this shit up. Here are some selected quotes for your reading pleasure.

↑ Jal wrote:LH, why vote Arugula over the other people you had your eye on?

↑ Jal wrote:

LH

: You admit to things we've found scummy about you. So What? Is that supposed to clear you in some way?

↑ Jal wrote:Hey Greywing. What's up with voting for everyone you think is scummily associated with Chrimi except for Chrimi himself?

↑ Jal wrote:Oh times have certainly changed, haven't they? But then Uber replaces in and you're all over trying to suck up to him. Makes the mind wonder.

↑ Jal wrote:

↑ Blastoide wrote:Everyone, I will try to be more active and more pro town. Usually when I play, I play to survive and I never really scum hunted before. Weird, huh, considering that is what the game is about!

Have you only been scum or something?

↑ Jal wrote:Arugula, do you find it at all weird that you're on a bandwagon for someone for whom you think is scummy and is backed by the other players you indicated you wanted lynched?

Now ask yourself: Why would a townie make these posts?

So, my point stands that Jal is scum and needs to be lynched.

Vote Jal, everyone.

Hey, you... that's right, you. The one skimming right on merrily through this thread.

↑ UberNinja wrote:

Have I mentioned Chrimi and Shiidaji are scum together?

Because they are.

Ignore this post

I now have a
Shiidaji could easily still be scum though.

That's....a really good point. I'm so proud, Uber.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jal