The Dresden Files - Early Days Mafia (Bastard) - Over

[Sixty]

Sixty, do you honestly 100% believe jason is town?

No, we wrote that post and then re-quoted it for

ball!

kicks.

Yes, we "honestly 100% believe" jason is Town.

[pidgey]

I think the play for the day, as a general town consensus, is GreyICE since that slot would just cause us troubles in general even if he's town. Although Grey isnt even in my top 3 scum picks right now.

That's why im asking him to claim. If its any role that could be potentially incredibly dangerous to lose for town then i wouldnt want him dead for today.

[pidgey]

And if not him then i want Thor dead.

[sword_of_omens]

Ok, had time to re-read a bit…

Not sure of Swords vote on me, given he seems to defend me in this post viewtopic.php?p=4447654#p4447654

Please explain to me how you think I am defending you?


What cracks me up are the people saying that they don’t believe Klick’s claim,
yet Jason’s claim somehow seems to be god’s honest truth.



Klickscum would have no reason to come out claiming a vesty with a guilty on Day1 when he did. With Grey at L-1 it would bring too much attention to him. He would have to be trying to save his scumbuddy Grey from lynch, or trying to win town-points by giving up Thorscum. The first would be insanely stupid, and given Thor’s rep, the second reason would be equally as dumb.
What it probably means though is that there is scum in at least 1 of the 3 (Klick, Grey, and Thor)
And I really doubt Klick would tie himself to his buddies this early in the game…
He also states that his flavor suggests that his results would be accurate…
I’d be willing to test out his findings..

Unvote

Vote: Thor

[Thor665]

Yeah, it's not 'claim that it's valid and I can sac. for conf. scum lynch' play at all.

And if you know how I play you'd know I don't give up ever and would never do that sort of pansy 'meh, should I give up, plea - I'm still scumhunting over here - go meta me and come back with wisdom.

Except you

do

this kind of thing as scum to gain time and cause Town to doubt themselves, dahling. Do you want wisdom?

Yeah, except I didn't self vote, did I, dahling?

What? The town reaction I generally see and expect regarding fake investigations is "WTF I know I'm town, X is lying, vote X."

Well...

1. This is a claimed Bastard setup.
2. It looked like a gambit to start.

So, yeah, that reaction would have been derp.

In other news: Sword's current vote is actually less derp than his previous vote. go figure. Pidgey should move now.

[ICEninja]

What? The town reaction I generally see and expect regarding fake investigations is "WTF I know I'm town, X is lying, vote X."

1. This is a claimed Bastard setup.
2. It looked like a gambit to start.

So, yeah, that reaction would have been derp.

^ Exactly why I didn't insta vote.

But SoO is right, there IS scum between Thor, Grey, and Klick. Klick feels the least likely to be scum of the 3, so I've decided to trust him on this.

Unvote, Vote Thor665

. Sorry, Thor. Assuming you do indeed get lynched here, you've hardly had any time to play here and I legitimately feel bad for lynching you just a few RL days after you replace in. Hopefully we can play again someday.

[Thor665]

Let's at least let him explain his confirming fluff first.

[ICEninja]

Let's at least let him explain his confirming fluff first.

Actually...yes I second this. I need to hear the full claim. The fact that you're a day cop and not a tracker as Georgia is really bothering me.

Until then,

Unvote

.

[Shamrock]

Prod dodge while we wait for a full claim...

[curiouskarmadog]

i am mostly caught up....skimmed the rest.

little time to post anything big.

I still think grey is scum

but klick says he has an investigation on thor. if thor flips town, grey and klick are scum together....if grey flips scum, klick is his buddy.

klick when did you investigate thor?

thor, why didnt you immediately vote klick..

if someone came out and said I was scum, I would vote their asses because it was a blatant lie. not understanding why you are not having this reaction.

not moving vote until my questions are answered.

[sword_of_omens]

@ICEnin,
Look at Klicks timing...it doesn't make sense as scum...
The way it's going, we are aiming for 3 full claims on Day 1?(Jason+Klick+Thor/Grey)
Not to mention the soft claim that someone else already dropped...
at this rate we'll be mass claiming by day 3.
Klick doesn't have motive to lie right now, unless he's an idiot, which I doubt...
i don't see the need for a full claim...

Also be careful of how much you read into flavor,especially in an MOI game...
after all, he did make Gau a traitor in FF6...

[Thor665]

@CKD - already answered that very specific question. Read m0ar.

@Sword - the flavor is important because Klick claims it suggests his sanity - making it highly relevant to hear.

[curiouskarmadog]

post number please

[ICEninja]

Its on this page, dude...604

[greenknight]

Also be careful of how much you read into flavor,especially in an MOI game...
after all, he did make Gau a traitor in FF6...

This. The roles in Dr Who were a MASSIVE stretch from the flavour as well, and that wasn't even a bastard game. But fine, Klick might as well claim his flavour.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Vote Count 1.17 - As of post 615

GreyIce (8) - curiouskarmadog, Sixty, Shamrock, Albert B. Rampage, Shmugen, kortul, Thor665, StefanB
Thor665 (5) - Konowa, Zdenek, Klick, greenknight, sword_of_omens
curiouskarmadog (3) - fatlikepig, GreyICE , jasonT1981

Not Voting (2) - ICENinja, pidgey

The Current deadline is Friday, Novemeber 9 at 10:00 am EDT. Countdown is (expired on 2012-11-09 10:00:00).

With 18 active votes - 10 are required to lynch.

Activity Check -
Albert B. Rampage has been prodded. He will be replaced if he receives another prod today.

Mod Notes -
GreyICE is V/LA til Monday, November 12th
fatlikepig is V/LA until Wednesday November 7th.
kortul is V/LA until Sunday, November 11th.

[Konowa]

Fully catching up probably won't happen until Night. I think given Klick's early play, I'm inclined to believe the claim. I endorse him fully claiming everything. If all of this plays out correctly, there is prob scum in those, beside Thor, that originally wrote this off as a gambit. Can't remember who off the top of my head.

[Thor665]

That would be half of the active players.

I've got a prediction about that one too.

[Thor665]

curiouskarmadog (3) - fatlikepig, greenknight, jasonT1981

Not Voting (2) - ICENinja, pidgey

Also, with three ays to deadline these people should get votes into play, as after the clarification from Klick you're theoretically going to want to L-1 and hammer threat me, or L-1 and hammer threat Grey. People should be in play for that.

[Konowa]

Actually talking about StefanB, pidgey, and Sixty for post 539, 540, and 541.

[pidgey]

Rofl if you think me and thor would be scum together if this game then what can i say you totally completely fail at reading people.

[pidgey]

Also by all means thor here is my vote dont yah worry

Vote thor

Though i still want greyice to claim

[Klick]

Alright, I'll paraphrase the flavor for my Daycop. It says that I can use my powered senses along with my psychology skills to my advantage and judge whether someone is town-aligned or not town-aligned.

However, I refuse to full-claim.

[Konowa]

Do you disagree with that assessment that scum would be in that group? Why wouldn't you be scum with Thor? Just saying, if all plays out I wouldn't mind a bullet to any of you.

Pedit: Yeah.
PPedit: I'm happy.

[pidgey]

I wouldnt mind a bullet to you either after this little exchange. You focus on one point of my content when i have been discussing with thor shit for like 5 pages but cool go ahead and throw your little rock from afar so you can try to wagon me later and use this as an excuse.

I dont think asking if what kondi did is a gambit a tell at all btw. Cause you know, people do it all the time and it loooked like a gambit.