Mafiascum.net

↑ Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:Tammy I think you broke the page for me.

Mission accomplished

- Will try to post once or twice between now and then but going to be a busy time (I'm moving).

↑ Zdenek wrote:Nost, what do you think of Shadoweh's 100?

I've answered that in #149.

- Are you voting peta for meta reasons only? (post #439.)
Also, did you read more than two games of his?
---

@BT

BT wrote:Librarian #390 gets a mention for commenting on the big wagons while still sticking to a vote that no one is interested in.

You vote who you find scummy. I don't understand why you're attacking him for doing that 'this early' (#390).
---

@Camn

Also note the hypocrisy of asking me 'why' while delivering absolutely nothing in the way of 'why'.

wtf is this? How is it scummy for him to ask you why and not state why himself? You could easily ask him "why", so I don't see the scum motivation in this. Terrible reason for calling him scummy.

Not useful to the game.
Either spill it.. or shut up about it and just tell us when after you have two-head-approval. Hydra self-reference is not useful..

and although I have townread on YOUR SLOT, I am starting to think it is a scumtell in general.

Not at all a town/genuine thought process. If your townread is doing it you wouldn't assume it's a general scum-tell, you would assume it's more likely null. Also, why is cerrulen still a town read to you if you honestly think it's a "general scum tell"?
--

Why is Camn town exactly?

@plez

You seem to be confusing "things that are annoying" with "things that are scummy".

Wtf, she's not confused, she's scum. Vote her.

Not sure if she's answered after post #467 but what from Vifam's ISO was scummy?

I'll carry on later.

Also, Tu much ta'in round here, niqqas need ta shu' the fuck up, fo real!.

↑ Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:And I find their lack of engagement/interaction and seemingly interest to be appalling. Both of them look like they're forcing themselves to post, esp from Zar who looks like he's being dragged to come and post. I actually find Pless' annoyance at Zar not really posting or conversing with him privately rather genuine - but I can very clearly see it as Pless being annoyed at Zar in a scum slot.

My experience of Zar isn't great, is he usually a more active poster?

↑ petapan wrote:if i had townreads i was confident in, i would state them. i don't. i don't believe anyone here is someone i can easily read as town.

What was your read on McStab, and has it changed since his replacement request?

↑ Cerulean wrote:he hates being unrolled

^What does this mean?

↑ Nostredeus wrote:

↑ Zdenek wrote:Nost, what do you think of Shadoweh's 100?

I've answered that in #149.

has your opinion of Shadoweh changed since then?

↑ Zdenek wrote:

↑ Nostredeus wrote:

↑ Zdenek wrote:Nost, what do you think of Shadoweh's 100?

I've answered that in #149.

has your opinion of Shadoweh changed since then?

Not really but McStab is a better lynch imo.

Through 16 pages:

I'm starting to pick up some town reads, mostly based on gut/sense that their play similar to play when I've seen them as town before on Cerulean, Benmage, Deasvail, Vifam, Shadoweh (although I have more reservations about this one because of ADWD).

I'll need to look into Camn's case on Plessiezarus, but I didn't find it convincing as I was reading through.

I still don't like Absta, and the attention that Safetydance is getting is deserved.

/yawn at Absta.

if I wanted to say something was scummy... I would use that word instead of the word 'hypocrisy'.
And if townies never did scummy things, there would never be any mislynches. But seriously.... the Hydra talk is off topic, out of game, and not relevant. Talk to someone else about it if you want.

↑ Plessiezarus wrote:TGAH -- according to 125 / 141, both your heads have (had?) a town-read on Dayne. How and why did you come to this read?

the terrible attempted wagon on him for the rp. easy target is easy. didn't i already say this? oh, why yes, what do you know:

↑ TheGreatestAmericanHero wrote:dayne is town. his roleplay is the terrible-est, fakest reason to suspect someone ever. its not even hard to understand. its low hanging fruit for scum, something easy and mindless to attack.

↑ sottyrulez wrote:

Unvote: Vote: TheGreatestAmericanHero

No way rolfcopter is the passive head in a hydra as town. I just did a search on him and he's also active in site. The alarm bells are ringing.

holy diversion batman. i didn't buy into kon's jason-sotty theory at first, but you just seem keenly nervous about the prospect of him getting lynched despite the fact, as cerulean pointed out, that he's not terribly likely to get lynched as things stand right now. (hint hint, this is everyone's cue to get on jason. or get back on him.)

i do wish i could vote for more people at the same time though. peta, absta, safety and plessie all need the rope.

... its a little early to be getting apathetic towards the game... post 575 ... I haven't had an issue with your contribution. It is D1, but moreover your posts at least tend to have some depth to them; and if we're going to complain about content you're definitely not the prime offender. I'm surprised you didn't go with that note, but rather the apathy path....

Both Pless and I got a chance to discuss reads together today. we're actually more or less in agreement on most people. In short, we're both confident that Benmage and Cerulean are town, and we have weaker-town reads on sottyrulez, Nostrodeus, Shadoweh and SafetyDance. Our strongest scum-reads are absta, Zdenek/McStab and TGAH. Weaker-scum reads on Arthur, CDB, petapan and Jason. Everyone else is essentially null still (though we're conflicted on BT/Vifam Pless thinks BT's townish, but I thought Vifam was scummy and BT has carried the same trend. While he had quite a few single liners, in collective, Vifam's posts were very little content relevant; My impression of BTs catchup in #394 was that it read fake; his thoughts on TGAH didn't read to me like the natural train of thought of someone trying to discern a player's alignment. Didn't like much of #456 either; felt that his jump on McStab could have well come from somebody feeling the urge to bus and thought that he was giving Arthur an easy pass for stuff that wasn't alignment indicative.

Since people hate Pless' walls, apparently, we'll look at what we think the main points against our scum-reads are in a series of posts. Pless will also take a second look at BT, and come back with thoughts.

~ Zar.

sottyrulez - could you outline your case on TGAH? It seems to me that you're pushing it far harder than you should be considering what you've had to say so far.

Plessiezarus - you can answer that too.

Explanation later.

Wait tammy fill me in on zar-meta in the marvel game (that's the one he played and I'm assuming he was town in?)

camn, why are you voting me and why did you think that Plessiezarus was bussing?

prod aknowledged... post when i get up

↑ Zdenek wrote:camn, why are you voting me

↑ McStab wrote:h8ers gunna h8

This is classic scum.
"Im not bothered, guys See? See how un-bothered I am?"

↑ Zdenek wrote:and why did you think that Plessiezarus was bussing?

because back then I had a scumread on then (which is resolving due to their play since), and they had an isolated vote on you, which is a typical place for scum to lay their buss-vote early on. Then later.. days later, when their partner flips the implication is there that they were totally ready to kill Day 1.


Clear? Now more Zdenek votes please.

Oh please. Town acts not bothered by things all the time, and assuming that isolated votes on people you find scummy are people bussing is insane.

Assuming you're town, here's an example:

↑ camn wrote:/yawn at Absta.