Mafiascum.net

Me healing DEB when we're partners would be a ballsy move that neither of us have the skill to make work.

Especially since I explicitly didn't even want him healed and was doing it to see how people would react to it.

In post 599, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 598, Adorable wrote:Who did they think was going to get killed?

Oversoul.

I could only be so lucky

In post 600, Something_Smart wrote:Me healing DEB when we're partners would be a ballsy move that neither of us have the skill to make work.

Especially since I explicitly didn't even want him healed and was doing it to see how people would react to it.

So you think Deb is town?

Not particularly.

I have a scumread that isn't him, though.

If you’re thinking who I’m thinking then you might be town after all

Are you Empking, SS?

I'm not an alt, if that's what you're asking.

Does Volxen always lurk?

Don't know, but I doubt this qualifies as a lurk anymore. It's probably RL-related.

If Volxen replaces out, will you still tell us what you’re holding u til after he gets here to answer my question?

Votecount 4.1

Kill votes:

Something_Smart -----(0)
Oversoul --------------(0)
Dr Easy Bake ----------(1) Oversoul
volxen -----------------(0)
Adorable----------------(0)

Spare votes:

Something_Smart -----(0)
Oversoul --------------(0)
Dr Easy Bake ----------(0)
volxen -----------------(0)
Adorable----------------(0)

Voting for a Kill (1):

:

Oversoul

Voting for a Spare (0):

:

Not voting at all (4):

Something_Smart, Dr Easy Bake, volxen, Adorable

With 5 unspared alive, it takes 3 votes to make a choice.

Deadline: (expired on 2019-08-30 02:00:00)

In post 582, Oversoul wrote:Volxen, opinion on SS?

I’ve been busy IRL and I’m low on sleep at the moment, so I’ll elaborate more on my thoughts on SS in a later post. But in short, I don’t think that pushing for your own slot to be spared in and of itself is scummy, but I think that SS’s for pushing for his own slot to be spared (that he could read Chennisden in the spare PT and vice versa) is sketchy. Especially considering that he had all of Elements/DDL/Adorable as townreads, and Elements in particular was already townread a lot by the start of day two, yet SS started off day two pushing for his own slot to be spared. If SS is town, I think that he would realize the importance of sparing consensus townreads before they can be nightkilled, and that that’s far important than sparing someone based on their supposed ability to read the other spared player in the spare PT. I mean Chennisden was only spared in the first place on day one because he was the most townread player in the game, and it’s really only been Oversoul who has been calling him scum. So why push yourself as the optimal day two spare on the grounds that you can read Chennisden in the spare PT, when almost everyone is townreading him to begin with? It doesn’t make sense, especially when you take into account that SS said that he has a solid town game (241) and yet he thinks that the best use of his slot is sorting Chennisden in the spare PT, rather than staying in the game longer so he can sort everyone else and have more of an impact on the game.

I’m strongly townreading Chennisden, but I also think that SS’s argument for why he and Chennisden couldn’t possibly be scum together (that they can’t be scum together because SS didn’t heal-vote Chennisden) is equally sketchy as well. There are a number of legitimate reasons why scum would want to avoid heal-voting their partner, and he used this argument of Chennisden/SS being ruled out as a scumteam to further justify pushing for his own slot to be spared on day two (258) (if he is scum then he was taking advantage of the Oversoul vs Chemist PR dispute at the time to try and get his slot spared).

I believe that all of {Chennisden, Elements, Adorable} are town, which means that the scumteam is two out of {SS, DEB, Oversoul}. And regarding today, I think that we should spare Adorable and continue on the Pacifist route.

sounds like a plan mah man

HEAL: Adorable

I am pretty obviously not scum, so I should be the 5th player spared if it comes to that

This happened fast during my absence and when I come back I see myself getting spared. I've already explained why I have been suspicious of SS and DEB and I have been town reading the players who spared chennis.

HEAL: Adorable

In post 615, Adorable wrote:This happened fast during my absence and when I come back I see myself getting spared. I've already explained why I have been suspicious of SS and DEB and I have been town reading the players who spared chennis.

HEAL: Adorable

Did we lose!? please tell me we lost so I can be rid of these ppl

Votecount 4.Final

Kill votes:

Something_Smart -----(0)
Oversoul --------------(0)
Dr Easy Bake ----------(0)
volxen -----------------(0)
Adorable----------------(0)

Spare votes:

Something_Smart -----(0)
Oversoul --------------(0)
Dr Easy Bake ----------(0)
volxen -----------------(0)
Adorable----------------(3) Oversoul, Adorable, volxen

Voting for a Kill (0):

:

Voting for a Spare (3):

: Adorable, volxen, Oversoul

Not voting at all (2):

Something_Smart, Dr Easy Bake

Deadline: (expired on 2019-09-02 02:00:00)

(expired on 2019-09-02 02:00:00)

pop you silly you don't need to unlock the thread to post in it as mod but ninja'd

wait what. wtf is happening

Volxen is scum. That's what I was waiting to say. I'm pretty sure 581 was him explaining why he killed flippy, because that explanation was not clear at all.

After what just happened, it's probably with Adorable...

Probably adorable. She’s been my pocket scum read since I asked why everyone was townreading her.

Actually

HEAL: Something Smart

I don’t want this loss on my hands so I’m sending you to the Shadow realm. I will watch from the dead thread