Mafiascum.net

In post 599, Oh wrote:Reads:

So far I like Shoshin, and she brings up a good point against Wisdom.
I haven't been a particular fan of some of Yukz earlier posts - specifically his responses to Wisdom ~287 and his post about S_S in 305 was specifically untrue.
Nacho has been good this game.
Sakura Hana has been leaning on the town side of NAI.
GDGW hasn't done anything I liked (as far as I've seen) and his town reminds me of my own during Anuket.

-E

Also I like Cephrir and gameplay hasn't done anything I like yet.

In post 599, Oh wrote:Nacho has been good this game.

I thought he was underwhelming so far. What did you like?

Isn't Shoshin echoing my sentiments on Wisdom with the addition of her self awareness point?

Oh, who do you want to baton kill and who do you want to be BP?

In post 598, Oversoul wrote:I swear this site makes my grammar and spelling worse.

I used to constantly use big words and talk down to people before I played MS enough to learn how to interact with people properly.
@OH it's fine I felt like you were taking jabs at me for being me wrt wanting a policy lynch on me while refusing to take my reads at all seriously and essentially just setting me up to be nightkilled in a bad way. Not, like, I want someone else to be protected more but it felt like you just specifically wanted me to be a viable kill.

Alright, Dann, ball's in your court.

What are your reads?

Shoshin wrote:

In post 599, Oh wrote:Nacho has been good this game.

I thought he was underwhelming so far. What did you like?

I like Nacho the same way I like Cephrir - their posts are +town gamestate. There's nothing that scum couldn't relatively easily replicate, but it would be suboptimal for a mafia aligned player to try.

In post 600, Oh wrote:Also I like Cephrir and gameplay hasn't done anything I like yet.

I don't like gameplay either.

What specifically did you like from Cephrir, though?

Gameplay was my secret scumread but since Nancy and Dannflor already expressed that as well, I'll out it as well.

In post 604, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 598, Oversoul wrote:I swear this site makes my grammar and spelling worse.

I used to constantly use big words and talk down to people before I played MS enough to learn how to interact with people properly.
@OH it's fine I felt like you were taking jabs at me for being me wrt wanting a policy lynch on me while refusing to take my reads at all seriously and essentially just setting me up to be nightkilled in a bad way. Not, like, I want someone else to be protected more but it felt like you just specifically wanted me to be a viable kill.

I understand. I'm not trying to prevent you from being bullet-proof. My fear was that the game would quickly become overrun by discussion of defending you above all because you provide +town equity if you are town, and I wanted to squash that argument before we reached that point. It turns out my fears were invalid, and I apologize. I don't mind you being protected first, but I would like it to be because people legitimately think you're town and not some overall meta argument.

In post 603, YukzYuk wrote:Isn't Shoshin echoing my sentiments on Wisdom with the addition of her self awareness point?

Oh, who do you want to baton kill and who do you want to be BP?

directed @OH

I mean. I really just didn't have the mental energy to try to self townspew to the point that I'd feel like I deserved to be protected so I was just gonna not bother with that whole thing.

In post 608, Oh wrote:I don't mind you being protected first, but I would like it to be because people legitimately think you're town and not some overall meta argument.

If that's true, why aren't you voting for them?

Yukz, what is your read on Cici?

I believe helping a town RC stay alive increases town's chances of winning.

In post 432, Sakura Hana wrote:I did not even think our reads were that good at the end of D1 in magical girls upick, plus RC saying like 10 million times we were going to be the N1 NK, and yet, we did get shot, except due to our super unkillable ability... we didnt die.

I also did intentionally bait the nightkill in other ways with regards to my approach to the game, notably.

In post 605, Oh wrote:Alright, Dann, ball's in your court.

What are your reads?

Shoshin wrote:

In post 599, Oh wrote:Nacho has been good this game.

I thought he was underwhelming so far. What did you like?

I like Nacho the same way I like Cephrir - their posts are +town gamestate. There's nothing that scum couldn't relatively easily replicate, but it would be suboptimal for a mafia aligned player to try.

In post 608, Oh wrote:

In post 604, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 598, Oversoul wrote:I swear this site makes my grammar and spelling worse.

I used to constantly use big words and talk down to people before I played MS enough to learn how to interact with people properly.
@OH it's fine I felt like you were taking jabs at me for being me wrt wanting a policy lynch on me while refusing to take my reads at all seriously and essentially just setting me up to be nightkilled in a bad way. Not, like, I want someone else to be protected more but it felt like you just specifically wanted me to be a viable kill.

I understand. I'm not trying to prevent you from being bullet-proof. My fear was that the game would quickly become overrun by discussion of defending you above all because you provide +town equity if you are town, and I wanted to squash that argument before we reached that point. It turns out my fears were invalid, and I apologize. I don't mind you being protected first, but I would like it to be because people legitimately think you're town and not some overall meta argument.

These were both -E

In post 607, Celestial Coordinates wrote:Gameplay was my secret scumread but since Nancy and Dannflor already expressed that as well, I'll out it as well.

...Enter and Dannflor?

In post 611, Oversoul wrote:

In post 608, Oh wrote:I don't mind you being protected first, but I would like it to be because people legitimately think you're town and not some overall meta argument.

If that's true, why aren't you voting for them?

Don't read "I think you should be protected first," read "If you're protected first because people are legitimately town reading you, that's ok with me. I'm not opposed to it."

TBH I'm not really sure how you can read it the former way anyways?

-E

Oh is also town and now I have to go pack.

In post 612, Oversoul wrote:Yukz, what is your read on Cici?

Null/ =rand.

In post 605, Oh wrote:Alright, Dann, ball's in your court.

What are your reads?

My most confident town reads are on Shoshin, Celestial, and Oversoul.

I like Gay Dance, Sakura, and Something_Smart to varying levels.

I didn't like your entrance and wasn't impressed by your catch up afterwards but I'm reconsidering that read.

I don't like gameplay or goodies. I find Wisdom's response to Shoshin a little scummy, although I'm not sure I buy her initial case.

Everyone else is some shade of null rnow.

I'll expand on any one of these you want, I just don't have the time to explain all of them right now. I plan on rereading and organizing a proper reads list when I'm done with my uni reading today. Could you expand on Cephrir when you get the chance? I'm still null on them.

In post 615, Oh wrote:...Enter and Dannflor?

You as well but Nancy sent me a discord scumreading them at about the same time.

Sakura's the universal townread I'm struggling with

I don't her. I just don't think I've seen enough to be like gung ho yeah she's town.

She's my weakest town read in my lean town tier

Gameplay pinged me as well.

OkaPoka
Dunnstral
Firebringer
MariaR
Alisae
Kagami
popsofctown
Creature
Shiro

---

I think Yukz is one of the above players.

I think {gameplay nacho goodies} are the 3 people that I like least so far.