Mafiascum.net

Nm, Do you have like any reads at all?

cfj is still my vote and cfj is probably the scummiest person in my view. at the same time im starting to think cfj is just scummy town. thats pure gut though. i still like walter for scum, and could buy gamma, reaver or banana as scum.

In post 601, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Nm, Do you have like any reads at all?

Yes

In post 603, Not_Mafia wrote:

In post 601, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Nm, Do you have like any reads at all?

Yes

That you feel comfortable posting here?

You can take my last 2 votes as some indication of my thoughts

hmm
alright. At least that is something.
VOTE: Gamma
@Gamma
What do you think cfj was going for with the post about gerain?

In post 605, Not_Mafia wrote:You can take my last 2 votes as some indication of my thoughts

Vague, no meaning, meant to inspire confidence in your vague scum whispering abilities?

I don't really care if you're confident in me or not

walter....you seem remarkably unconcerned you have just been voted?
Like...one of the few people I have managed to pay attention to today is not mafia and your interactions with them on this page just leave me confused....

All these hidden roles and real or fake gambits. I wish I could vote for all of you.

In post 610, geraintm wrote:walter....you seem remarkably unconcerned you have just been voted?
Like...one of the few people I have managed to pay attention to today is not mafia and your interactions with them on this page just leave me confused....

I tend to not geet whippedd up about being voted because I recognize if I am elimed if still provides useful info.
You will also note that Gamma also saw this earlier.
I am not really that concerned because as I said in 248, people are free to believe who they see as scum.
I was quite surprised that Nm en posted that after my response, I was just expecting a no.
Plus, I am not certain that pressuring nm will lead to more of a response.

In post 606, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:hmm
alright. At least that is something.
VOTE: Gamma
@Gamma
What do you think cfj was going for with the post about gerain?

The post still doesn’t sit right with me, but he put a good foot forward explaining it
As for what he was going for, it looked like he used an NAI point as a way to leave to wagon. It’s not as sketchy now with the explanation but if geraint flips scum I’ll likely be calling back to that

In post 613, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 606, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:hmm
alright. At least that is something.
VOTE: Gamma
@Gamma
What do you think cfj was going for with the post about gerain?

The post still doesn’t sit right with me, but he put a good foot forward explaining it
As for what he was going for, it looked like he used an NAI point as a way to leave to wagon. It’s not as sketchy now with the explanation but if geraint flips scum I’ll likely be calling back to that

K, that makes sense and is in line with my thinking. Although I think that cfj is town. call it a 70% certainty.

do you think the opposite applies if Cfj flips scum?

I think so, it reads in a way that looks more like partner handling than white knighting

In post 614, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Although I think that cfj is town. call it a 70% certainty.

A random player has a 77% chance of being town

In post 617, Not_Mafia wrote:

In post 614, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Although I think that cfj is town. call it a 70% certainty.

A random player has a 77% chance of being town

i dont think this applies to me

I'm down for a Nosferatu or Banana lynch. I also scumread the CFJ slot because of his early interactions, I'm more interested in lynching the Nosferatu or Banana slots D1 though because CFJ's scumplay seems more helpful.

I have a weak townread on RCE and I never finished my ISO on the SJReaver slot but I have a weak townread there as well.

Helpful scumplay is still scumplay
Why do you think it’s worth keeping active scum alive?

In post 596, Tayl0r Swift wrote:

In post 591, Raya36 wrote:

In post 589, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:I feel a slight tr about the gerain slot after cfj's post and explanation. although such a defense of Gerain seemed very out of the blue.
I find this whole fake guilty thing to be highly suspicious and pr fishing.

I am really tired rn going to sleep.

How was it pr fishing

yeah this. if anything you not being able to get the joke and trying to point out "suspicious" things like this is scummy.

Exactly my thoughts

In post 599, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Because I don't see the purpose of a fake guilty, it just seems really odd to me.
I get it was a joke, but I am not sure of its usefulness.
pedit It does seem very nm, but the fact that it was prompted by nos though? hmm
Something to keep in mind.

But how was it power role fishing?

Fake claiming cop.
I don’t see a purpose unless scum was trying to bait a reaction.
Try to see how town would react. Maybe draw a pr out. That was my thought. Although it Does come from two of the more anto town slots.

In post 623, WaltertheDunce10 wrote:Fake claiming cop.
I don’t see a purpose unless scum was trying to bait a reaction.
Try to see how town would react. Maybe draw a pr out. That was my thought. Although it Does come from two of the more anto town slots.

You can't see the side where it was just town joking/messing around? Or a town reaction test? Scum as far as I know actually aren't that likely to be so obvious when pr fishing. They don't want to openwolf unless that's the overall strategy they're going for. I'd expect them to he more subtle when fishing or not fish at all