Page 25 of 135

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 4:30 am
by Andante
Ok, So I've actually had time to look at stuff, and not just come in to react. Eyes's ISO is TERRIBLE I mean, I genuinely liked the "Early TRs on A and B for getting out of RVS so fast" but then it jumps straight into replacement talk?

I'll summarize the ISO as I read it.

Starts off not bad
Replacements are more likely to be maf!! not saying all are maf!! but they're more likely!!!
I don't like "a certain someone's personality"
then the irrelevant talk I didn't like

@Eyes, do you have any game related thoughts?? like, I don't want a read like "well these replacements are scummiest" ok, if you sr only replacements, can you give reasoning?



@Frozen, ok I think I understand why you asked about meta, but in this case for someone with 0 game related content, do you really think meta would help? I really feel like reads with reasonings are better for reading people.. not "how did you play in past games" cause I'd almost guarantee you no town!Eyes games look anything remotely close to this game.


And, I don't have a problem with not voting a SR, I have a problem with not seeing any strong reads in that ISO

Like, I read that.. WHY ARE 2 PEOPLE VOTING ME??? HAVE YOU 2 LOOKED AT EYES???

Eyes ISO is terrible, if it doesn't improve I'm voting there today


In post 587, Frozen Angel wrote:@Andate
In post 582, Andante wrote:Cause to me, obv I'd need to go ISO, at least 1 of yall is maf, cause it's much easier for maf to argue about non game related stuff than anything pertaining to this game
He specifically said that he has a scum read on a slot but will not vote on it cause it brings heat to his slot.
In post 562, Eyes without a face wrote:because that would have been used against me by scum and ignorant town alike. It would have been portrayed as an OMGUS vote nno more.
earlier in this same game, he said a theory that replacements are more likely scum even though he knew it will bring hit to his slot and he admitted that it probably will.
In post 408, Eyes without a face wrote:Well I know this is going to bring a lot of heat my way but I should let you all know I tend to suspect replacements more. I guess it was DGB (if memory serves me right) that once said if we eliminate all replacements town always wins (or something to that effect).
That's why I said I want to see his town games meta, just searching for his early game, never saw him being so conservative about swapping votes so far.

what do you think about this switch in the attidue?

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 4:30 am
by Andante
heck yeah. page top!!! leggooo

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:13 am
by Stephen A Smith
We should make FaceBoy and HockeyDude pick teams for the superbowl and yeet the one that picks wrong

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:13 am
by Stephen A Smith
Rams are a four point favorite but Joey B is my Boy

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:31 am
by Scorpious
In post 603, Stephen A Smith wrote:Rams are a four point favorite but Joey B is my Boy
Joe “cool”.

Bengals 27-21.

I’m that note. I also will be participating in football festivities today. So I’ll try.

But game related

Adante
my vote on you was based on that how awful list you put up. Somewhere I said I’d like to see how it’s evolved since then and would keep/remove my vote. I have bigger suspicions but I want to hold you to that.

And holy crap I just pulled a Taly.

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:46 am
by Andante
Alright, looking at Hockey next.

Hocky was one of the ones that hated my "I hate rvs stage and yall are doing it wrong"

Post "Why do you want only pressure on 1 person to start the game? Doesnt make sense, a wagon shouldn't be formed on page 1 for the most part imo"
> I mean like, how is it beneficial to have 1 vote on everyone? that's not pressure. Wagons make pressure. Pressure makes people act, and for the most part, my early "rvs read" was a legit read at the time. Pressuring 1 person is a start, if you get a solid read on 1, you move to another... better than whatever the heck is happening this game
> also in , says townpings from fire's RVS vote

Post
In post 39, HockeyFan wrote:
fireisredsir wrote:i actually kinda agree with the hockey suspicion, i scoped out the starts of his games and the early buttering people up doesn't really feel like his town play, which is usually more fluffposting, banter, and discussing mechanics. i only see one scum game in his history but he acted closer to this. it's not an open so there's no mechanics to discuss here
Litreally what lol. I have "buttered up" people(if tring ppl early is what this means) in other games too. In Newbie 2067, I had about 2-3 reads within the first 4 posts(And I was town that game). Another game is Mini Normal 2234(Once Again town) where I townread someone within the first 2 posts so i'm not sure what meta diving u did?

About the bolded, First of all, I don't do it ALOT(yes I do it I will admit), but secondly the game was off of RVS on page 1 so what are u getting at? Am i suppsoed to do the bolded with 3-4 votes, and get even more votes cuz that doesnt seem like a good plan to me?
fireisredsir wrote: but still, he feels like more of an outsider. and like he's forcing himself to make a meaningful post with commentary on the game even when not much has happened, so he can look more town and get people off his back. feels like he's doing it because he thinks he has to instead of because it's his honest thoughts.
Ya, I like making meaningpul posts when 2 ppl have said they don't like RVS(and want to move on it quickly). Whats the deal with this? Also, yes I do have to do with it cuz I have 3 votes!! How can you tell that they're not my "honest" thoughts?
> Just pulled the whole post on this cause yeah. So I mean, 12 posts ago you go "townpings for fire's rvs" and it looks like that's what fire's referring to, but not certain I'd call it buttering up. For that comment though, your reaction here feels odd.. like it feels like an overreaction tbh like if someone went "Andante is trying to pocket me" my reaction would be a simple "lol you're funny" not linking games... this early like if it was late game (or now...) I'd understand going "I'm not buttering people up what??" not post 30 though lol
" secondly the game was off of RVS on page 1 so what are u getting at? Am i suppsoed to do the bolded with 3-4 votes, and get even more votes cuz that doesnt seem like a good plan to me?"
> sounds like you're complaining we got out of RVS so fast... like, maf should be more mad than town RVS didn't last long... RVS is an easy excuse for maf to have minimal effort...

I was asked why I SRed and , was explained
In post 28, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 16, Dwlee99 wrote:What is different between fireisredsir and surye in that regard?
I like this question a lot, dk if I would call them town already tho
> and here, this just doesn't feel like it comes from town. Like Dwlee brings up a valid point, and you're just kinda like "yes. good. idk if town" like, your post after this one is all this explanation for why you're not pocketing someone.. I feel like town you would've added more to Dwlee's thought there. idk how to really explain it.

Post - You declare a TR on Dwlee off of 3 posts. In my opinion before 100 posts is too early to be declaring TRs... but whatever

** Post - what you say to Overkill feels odd. I'd understand it if the 2 of you are maf partners, but if you're not partners I'm not sure why you'd even interact with that post tbh like "Whats the point of making this post? Just dont post lol" doesn't feel like the nicest thing to say to someone when we're still in this get to know each other phase. It's like going to the family dinner and telling someone to shut up cause you don't like the story they're talking about. Why does town you tell someone to not post? Like, what if Overkill is new, sometimes something like that is enough to scare people off... just saying
In post 55, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 52, 0verki11 wrote:
In post 45, HockeyFan wrote:~snip
(I think this is the end on how what i wanted to reply to god reading BBCode makes me want to die)
Doesn't townreading people for reasons that you acknoledge arent very good just confuse town as a whole though? Spreading things that you don't beleive in, particulary when theres really not much going on in terms of game talk.
Are we reading the same post? I said my reasons in the OTHER games werent very good. I do believe that my reasoning(at least from my perspective) regarding post was good for me to make a baseline
> I liked this post from Overkill!!! Hockey's reaction is odd. I'm mainly just quoting it cause I like this from overkill, and I want this in my notes.
In post 56, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 52, 0verki11 wrote: god I forgot how to play mafia at all.
Alright, heres how you play mafia. Just tell me your mafia partners and it should be fairly easy!!
> I want to know why Hockey is like only focussing on Overkill here, like, it feels awkward.. Almost like Overkill was in maf chat like "Idk what to do" and Hockey is like "easy. I'll bus you" cause nothing about any of these Hockey +Overkill interactions really look like Hockey considering Overkill town.

dang... I feel bad for not being here... I wish I talked to overkill :/

Post - Umm you go back a LOT of posts (this might be the dwlee stephen 1v1 so ehh) to ask why Greeting is a SR. Not curious why Surye is a SR off of no posts? Or curious for the reason Dwlee is #1? Only curious on the greeting read?

Post - you get really defensive of Greeting... Like, "how dare you sr greeting for an RVS vote!!" uhh Surye is on that list too with ONLY and RVS vote, why is it only greeting from that list we care about?

Post - Stephen comes back with stuff, and you just back off like, you had all this conviction "GREETING SHOULD NOT BE THERE!!!" Stephen refutes your points made, and you're like "oh ok.." like, what? were you just doing that to look towny? maf that went "I know Greeting is town. there shouldn't be a reason to SR greeting there. I'm gonna look real towny!!" then "oh.. I guess yeah greeting doesn't look towny.. I just have TMI.."

Post - you encourage Stephen's gimmick... most likely as a way to distract from your awkward Greeting "read"
Post - then you ask stephen for his TRs... and after this you move on like, ask a question, no follow up. shows you never cared about the answer.

** Post - your post 40 TR on Dwlee comes into question, it feels like you're afraid of stephen tbh which would make yall not partners, but Stephen has a way of making you say stuff that like completely contradicts other stuff you've said lol like here for example. You've been all "heck yeah! Dwlee town!!!" Stephen is like "you sure about that?" and you're like "well umm.. no??"

Post - cause you mention me, so of course I talk about it. You're all "16 seemed like a good clarifcation question and not let Andante pick and choose what they want to see" like, if you actually READ THE POSTS AROUND IT, it was part of my conversation with them.. feels like a really odd thing to be like "Dwlee town for this!!!" that question wasn't clarifying anything.. it feels like you're making stuff up tbh. "20 is towny cuz i mainly agreed with it" 20 is just a post saying something is awkward... Like it feels like you're handing out TRs like I hand out candy on Halloween.. "here's a tr for you! and one for you!!" the question is, why is Dwlee the only one here you're fascinated with, like you keep going "yeah I tr Dwlee!!" what about literally anyone else? cause all these Dwlee posts are reactions to someone else saying something, so it's not even like you're actively making a read on them, you just keep going back to the 3 points you have.

** Post - This feels like a recurring theme, you'll ask someone a question, they answer very well, then you like back off/go yeah I agree BECAUSE...I honestly wanna call this maf indicative like, you ask a question, then feel the need to defend yourself for talking about that person. First Stephen and greeting now this...

Post - Easy you go after me! cause when you start going for anyone around, your "plan kinda back fires" You find a bad read from me and attack it
"??? Out of all things to SR scorpious for, you choose this?!?! Also, I don't like your recent posts cuz you made a list(b4 u finished skimming). I'm assuming that list had some merit and some reasoning behind it, so its weird for u to dismiss peoples questions about those reads."
> like, don't like my posts made before I finished reading... hmm my bad for trying to interact with people in live time. I've been playing marathon games, no attention to this game really. Lose track of time when playing them, like the one night I started playing at 3.. look up, it's already 11pm!!!
Anyways. back to this post, you're all "OMG WHY SR SCORP FOR THIS REASON!!!" but in the same post, cause you know I'm town, you go "I'm sure your list has meaning behind it!!" like, it just feels like you're trying to appear towny. Trying to raise some point that everyone else would agree with, all without stirring the pot too much... cause you are very selective in who you out a SR on/who you interact with lol

Post - You try to win Scorp over to your side, like "see!! I just acknowledged Andantes bad read!! I'll pocket uou now!" that's kinda how that reads tbh

Post - Voted me when I wasn't here. Cause we're trying to look busy without causing any controversy... Oh, Andante isn't here, this is gonna be an easy push... oh my friend... I caught you off guard and that was a fun interaction. Like, you vote me going "people I wanna kill rn are Andante(explained a bit in ), but its also thier unwilligness to post content(Im aware they're still catching up but ehhh deosnt sit right with me)"
You literally said you want to vote me for not posting. I've been around multiple times going "I am here, catching up!" if you had anything you needed to tell me, literally just go @Andant, just TRY to get my attention.. and maybe.. I'll interact with you. wow what a concept. I literally think you're trying to pick me off cause you know I'm LHF (or uhh was at the time) if you wanted the reason I've been gone so much, you literally could've just asked...it's not like it's a secret




TLDR: yeah this post is super long, left some of the last posts off. There is no way Hockey is town. I don't think I could be convinced this is a town slot, too much about this slot just screams maf, like, VERY concerned about how they look to people, yet have no porblem telling overkill to shut up? like, what? even in a post "SRing me" it's like "this is so bad!!! but like, I think you have a good list.." like, do you want me to not SR you? like, what was that plan.. feel free to tell me why I'm wrong on any of this, but look, those are my reactions, and if I ask you right now on post 605 why Dwlee is town, I bet you go link the 3 posts before post 50 again...

VOTE: Hockey

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:47 am
by Andante
In post 603, Stephen A Smith wrote:Rams are a four point favorite but Joey B is my Boy
GO BENGALS!!!

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:55 am
by Frozen Angel
Why did you have eye as your third town read in the list you posted before Andante?

I will read your posts in detail and will try to break down your reasoning and and answer to stuff you asked in a bit later when I'm home

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:58 am
by Andante
In post 217, Eyes without a face wrote:Early townreads on both Andante and Dwlee for seemingly being the driving forces of the game getting out of RVS so quickly.
literally said in the post I just gave.. I liked this post a lot, thought it came from a towny mindset. Also ummm I wonder if maf is simply just Eyes + Hockey, both seem to be glued to the Dwlee townread, Hockey doesn't interact with Eyes... this might just be a dumb argument lol like I think both end up flipping maf. want hockey first though

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:18 am
by Scorpious
I’m going to take my vote off
Adante
[b/]

I’m satisfied enough for now.

However. Could you do me the courtesy of explainy why you just smashed down a weak and lazy list initially? Obviously that above is a testament to why one would expect more from you.

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:19 am
by Scorpious
UNVOTE: andante

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:21 am
by Scorpious
Umlaut,

Have you had the opportunity to make any intitial observations? We’ve gotten nothing from that slot.

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:28 am
by fireisredsir
eyes looks not great here but my gut reads it more as town just having a weird mindset and maybe being a bit intimidated to share thoughts due to some of the personalities in this game. i see consistency in his inconsistency, if that makes any sense

i do not see what frozen sees at all, it did not read to me like he was specifically calling you out as a suspicious replacement, it still doesn't, and everything he has said has been consistent with the way i read the interaction. i guess you could say that it's because he just copied what i said, but meh, that's an additional assumption when to me the more obvious answer is that what i said was true. seems like a huge leap to me to think otherwise, maybe it's hard for frozen to see that because it is about her, but it's weird that dwlee sees it that way too

would much much rather lim hockey here, don't think both being maf is too likely (i think maf team could have done a better job of finding an alternative wagon, maybe they're that bad but i doubt it) andante's big post is pretty good imo

@scorpio you have so far mostly ignored the main two wagons, what's up with that? a few little things with hockey but never much of an opinion, and a lil bit of on the fence with eyes. i know it's football day but could you at least give some quick thoughts of where you are currently at with both of them por favor

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:33 am
by HockeyFan
Andante post 605
Spoiler:
In post 605, Andante wrote:Alright, looking at Hockey next.

Hocky was one of the ones that hated my "I hate rvs stage and yall are doing it wrong"

Post "Why do you want only pressure on 1 person to start the game? Doesnt make sense, a wagon shouldn't be formed on page 1 for the most part imo"
> I mean like, how is it beneficial to have 1 vote on everyone? that's not pressure. Wagons make pressure. Pressure makes people act, and for the most part, my early "rvs read" was a legit read at the time. Pressuring 1 person is a start, if you get a solid read on 1, you move to another... better than whatever the heck is happening this game

I never said I wanted *only* 1 vote on anyone, I just wanted to have multiple smallish wagons on diff ppl. Those mini wagon also make pressure
[/b

]> also in , says townpings from fire's RVS vote

Yes I've explained multiple times why I look for townpings early on into the game


Post
In post 39, HockeyFan wrote:
fireisredsir wrote:i actually kinda agree with the hockey suspicion, i scoped out the starts of his games and the early buttering people up doesn't really feel like his town play, which is usually more fluffposting, banter, and discussing mechanics. i only see one scum game in his history but he acted closer to this. it's not an open so there's no mechanics to discuss here
Litreally what lol. I have "buttered up" people(if tring ppl early is what this means) in other games too. In Newbie 2067, I had about 2-3 reads within the first 4 posts(And I was town that game). Another game is Mini Normal 2234(Once Again town) where I townread someone within the first 2 posts so i'm not sure what meta diving u did?

About the bolded, First of all, I don't do it ALOT(yes I do it I will admit), but secondly the game was off of RVS on page 1 so what are u getting at? Am i suppsoed to do the bolded with 3-4 votes, and get even more votes cuz that doesnt seem like a good plan to me?
fireisredsir wrote: but still, he feels like more of an outsider. and like he's forcing himself to make a meaningful post with commentary on the game even when not much has happened, so he can look more town and get people off his back. feels like he's doing it because he thinks he has to instead of because it's his honest thoughts.
Ya, I like making meaningpul posts when 2 ppl have said they don't like RVS(and want to move on it quickly). Whats the deal with this? Also, yes I do have to do with it cuz I have 3 votes!! How can you tell that they're not my "honest" thoughts?
> Just pulled the whole post on this cause yeah. So I mean, 12 posts ago you go "townpings for fire's rvs" and it looks like that's what fire's referring to, but not certain I'd call it buttering up. For that comment though, your reaction here feels odd.. like it feels like an overreaction tbh like if someone went "Andante is trying to pocket me" my reaction would be a simple "lol you're funny" not linking games... this early like if it was late game (or now...) I'd understand going "I'm not buttering people up what??" not post 30 though lol

I already had a couple votes and guess what! 1 more person was adding on to that at that point


" secondly the game was off of RVS on page 1 so what are u getting at? Am i suppsoed to do the bolded with 3-4 votes, and get even more votes cuz that doesnt seem like a good plan to me?"
> sounds like you're complaining we got out of RVS so fast... like, maf should be more mad than town RVS didn't last long... RVS is an easy excuse for maf to have minimal effort...

what was I trying to get at is, "why do u suddenly expect me to fluffpost,banter and take the game not seriously when its page 2 and I have like 3 votes"


I was asked why I SRed and , was explained
In post 28, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 16, Dwlee99 wrote:What is different between fireisredsir and surye in that regard?
I like this question a lot, dk if I would call them town already tho
> and here, this just doesn't feel like it comes from town. Like Dwlee brings up a valid point, and you're just kinda like "yes. good. idk if town" like, your post after this one is all this explanation for why you're not pocketing someone.. I feel like town you would've added more to Dwlee's thought there. idk how to really explain it.

How much more I am suppsoed to explain on post 28? Early trs are just a baseline again. I explained again anyways in why I trd them


Post - You declare a TR on Dwlee off of 3 posts. In my opinion before 100 posts is too early to be declaring TRs... but whatever
Ok I'll tell you why(and since u want shit after post 50, i will give it to u)

- I feel like mafia would want ppl to rush with thier reads faster
Thier whole Interaction with Frozen/Eyes seemed towny, it looked like they genuinely wanted to solve there(,,,



** Post - what you say to Overkill feels odd. I'd understand it if the 2 of you are maf partners, but if you're not partners I'm not sure why you'd even interact with that post tbh like "Whats the point of making this post? Just dont post lol" doesn't feel like the nicest thing to say to someone when we're still in this get to know each other phase. It's like going to the family dinner and telling someone to shut up cause you don't like the story they're talking about. Why does town you tell someone to not post? Like, what if Overkill is new, sometimes something like that is enough to scare people off... just saying

"Scare people off??" LOL, asking why someone posted about them "not being here" is not SCARING them off. I interacted with it cuz it was thier post, and I thought it would entail a more(esp on post 50)

In post 55, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 52, 0verki11 wrote:
In post 45, HockeyFan wrote:~snip
(I think this is the end on how what i wanted to reply to god reading BBCode makes me want to die)
Doesn't townreading people for reasons that you acknoledge arent very good just confuse town as a whole though? Spreading things that you don't beleive in, particulary when theres really not much going on in terms of game talk.
Are we reading the same post? I said my reasons in the OTHER games werent very good. I do believe that my reasoning(at least from my perspective) regarding post was good for me to make a baseline
> I liked this post from Overkill!!! Hockey's reaction is odd. I'm mainly just quoting it cause I like this from overkill, and I want this in my notes.
In post 56, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 52, 0verki11 wrote: god I forgot how to play mafia at all.
Alright, heres how you play mafia. Just tell me your mafia partners and it should be fairly easy!!
> I want to know why Hockey is like only focussing on Overkill here, like, it feels awkward.. Almost like Overkill was in maf chat like "Idk what to do" and Hockey is like "easy. I'll bus you" cause nothing about any of these Hockey +Overkill interactions really look like Hockey considering Overkill town.

I interacted with them because they were the only one ....there? Between and , me and him were the only one there. Saying I bussed is also pretty ridiculous. Why would you even think I need to bus there? Just makes little sense and it seems like you're making stuff up as u go


dang... I feel bad for not being here... I wish I talked to overkill :/

Post - Umm you go back a LOT of posts (this might be the dwlee stephen 1v1 so ehh) to ask why Greeting is a SR. Not curious why Surye is a SR off of no posts? Or curious for the reason Dwlee is #1? Only curious on the greeting read?

Post - you get really defensive of Greeting... Like, "how dare you sr greeting for an RVS vote!!" uhh Surye is on that list too with ONLY and RVS vote, why is it only greeting from that list we care about?

Cuz Greeting Is the only read I didnt understand/like. Suryve read is like "meh whatecver putting pressure on someone with 0 posts". I didnt care about Dwlee since it was expected from stephen after thier interaction. I got defensive of Greeting cuz I did town read them and there was no previous interaction between them and Greeting. I didn't comment on the wavemode read because I did NOT tr them at that point


Post - Stephen comes back with stuff, and you just back off like, you had all this conviction "GREETING SHOULD NOT BE THERE!!!" Stephen refutes your points made, and you're like "oh ok.." like, what? were you just doing that to look towny? maf that went "I know Greeting is town. there shouldn't be a reason to SR greeting there. I'm gonna look real towny!!" then "oh.. I guess yeah greeting doesn't look towny.. I just have TMI.."
Lol. I never said greeting DOESNT look towny, I agreed with thier point of "it looks touch-and go", but I still saw no other reason to sus them sicne the touch-and-go seemed pretty NAI. TMI??!?!? Wtf, yes because I would totally choose ONLY greeting from the list if I had TMI. I could have also trd wavemode who had 1 post at the time!! "TMI" seems bleh

Post - you encourage Stephen's gimmick... most likely as a way to distract from your awkward Greeting "read"
You are just grasping at straws here lol. How was my greeting read "akward". Also, responding to someone right after is NOT a way to distract, sorry.


Post - then you ask stephen for his TRs... and after this you move on like, ask a question, no follow up. shows you never cared about the answer.

He said he had NO tr's, what I am supposed to expand on that with lol


** Post - your post 40 TR on Dwlee comes into question, it feels like you're afraid of stephen tbh which would make yall not partners, but Stephen has a way of making you say stuff that like completely contradicts other stuff you've said lol like here for example. You've been all "heck yeah! Dwlee town!!!" Stephen is like "you sure about that?" and you're like "well umm.. no??"

DUDE. I never said I didn't TR Dwlee there. I basically said "I havent played enough games with Dwlee, but I still think they're town" Where Did I say the "well umm.. no??"


Post - cause you mention me, so of course I talk about it. You're all "16 seemed like a good clarifcation question and not let Andante pick and choose what they want to see" like, if you actually READ THE POSTS AROUND IT, it was part of my conversation with them.. feels like a really odd thing to be like "Dwlee town for this!!!" that question wasn't clarifying anything.. it feels like you're making stuff up tbh. "20 is towny cuz i mainly agreed with it" 20 is just a post saying something is awkward... Like it feels like you're handing out TRs like I hand out candy on Halloween.. "here's a tr for you! and one for you!!" the question is, why is Dwlee the only one here you're fascinated with, like you keep going "yeah I tr Dwlee!!" what about literally anyone else? cause all these Dwlee posts are reactions to someone else saying something, so it's not even like you're actively making a read on them, you just keep going back to the 3 points you have.

** Post - This feels like a recurring theme, you'll ask someone a question, they answer very well, then you like back off/go yeah I agree BECAUSE...I honestly wanna call this maf indicative like, you ask a question, then feel the need to defend yourself for talking about that person. First Stephen and greeting now this...

Post - Easy you go after me! cause when you start going for anyone around, your "plan kinda back fires" You find a bad read from me and attack it
"when you start going for anyone around, my plan "backfires". lol pls This was the first serious SR i had, so where tf did I "go after anyoen around" b4 that


"??? Out of all things to SR scorpious for, you choose this?!?! Also, I don't like your recent posts cuz you made a list(b4 u finished skimming). I'm assuming that list had some merit and some reasoning behind it, so its weird for u to dismiss peoples questions about those reads."
> like, don't like my posts made before I finished reading... hmm my bad for trying to interact with people in live time. I've been playing marathon games, no attention to this game really. Lose track of time when playing them, like the one night I started playing at 3.. look up, it's already 11pm!!!
Anyways. back to this post, you're all "OMG WHY SR SCORP FOR THIS REASON!!!" but in the same post, cause you know I'm town, you go "I'm sure your list has meaning behind it!!" like, it just feels like you're trying to appear towny. Trying to raise some point that everyone else would agree with, all without stirring the pot too much... because you are very selective in who you out a SR on/who you interact with lol

???????. having some sort of MEANING behind a list does mean you automatically become town. Let's give you the benefit of the doubt that what you said in bolded is TRUE. how does that make me scum. Not stirring the pot can come from either alligment.


Post - You try to win Scorp over to your side, like "see!! I just acknowledged Andantes bad read!! I'll pocket uou now!" that's kinda how that reads tbh

Wtf. How is pocketing in ANY WAY. I asked them if thier read on wave has changed based on the content he just produced , that is NOT pocketing


Post - Voted me when I wasn't here. Cause we're trying to look busy without causing any controversy... Oh, Andante isn't here, this is gonna be an easy push... oh my friend... I caught you off guard and that was a fun interaction. Like, you vote me going "people I wanna kill rn are Andante(explained a bit in ), but its also thier unwilligness to post content(Im aware they're still catching up but ehhh deosnt sit right with me)"
You literally said you want to vote me for not posting. I've been around multiple times going "I am here, catching up!" if you had anything you needed to tell me, literally just go @Andant, just TRY to get my attention.. and maybe.. I'll interact with you. wow what a concept. I literally think you're trying to pick me off cause you know I'm LHF (or uhh was at the time) if you wanted the reason I've been gone so much, you literally could've just asked...it's not like it's a secret

You said you were "catching uP" at least 3 times at that point. Also I was not looking for an "easy" push. If I was, i could have sussed eyes alot more since there was already alot of sus on them.


VOTE: Hockey
TLDR: My read on Andante hasnt changed, and even If it did change, it would go into SL


Also, lol @ . Im not "glued" to the Dwlee TR, I didnt even it mention it until u brought it up in the post above

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:36 am
by HockeyFan
In post 602, Stephen A Smith wrote:We should make FaceBoy and HockeyDude pick teams for the superbowl and yeet the one that picks wrong
lol.

I'm gunning for the bengals to win, Joe Burrow deserves a SB.

I just reread the frozen/eyes stuff, did not get much out of it, but I like the way Frozen is playing, and I dont think the 2 are partners here

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 7:49 am
by Scorpious
In post 612, fireisredsir wrote:
@scorpio you have so far mostly ignored the main two wagons, what's up with that? a few little things with hockey but never much of an opinion, and a lil bit of on the fence with eyes. i know it's football day but could you at least give some quick thoughts of where you are currently at with both of them por favor

Fair question.
I’m never a fan of the first wagon to be completely honest, I’m. It going to throw around words like “always” and “often” but it’s a rarity. I see newb, not scum in the posts. Almost like I “why are people finding these things I’m saying as scum. It’s also LHF .

As far as the Eyes wagon. Again, seems like a lazy vote, granted one I’m leaning toward making. It’s curious to come into a game with a statement that is obviously going to drum up some sort of disagreement. Maybe it’s a huge reaction test. I really don’t know. I’m going to attempt to trudge through the two pages of them and FA, but I can already see myself getting bored with it.

Last note. i did have my vote parked on Adante because he initial list was so be beneath her, and I had not planned on moving it until she at least addressed the evolution of her thoughts since it. I’m satisfied so I did remove it.

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:12 am
by Frozen Angel
In post 600, Andante wrote:@Frozen, ok I think I understand why you asked about meta, but in this case for someone with 0 game related content, do you really think meta would help? I really feel like reads with reasonings are better for reading people.. not "how did you play in past games" cause I'd almost guarantee you no town!Eyes games look anything remotely close to this game.
When investigating about how someone behavior makes a shift from not caring about heat to express theory - to not vote cause worried of gaining heat, meta helps to understand if it's because of their personality as a player - or maybe if they have another reason to not want to vote
In post 600, Andante wrote:And, I don't have a problem with not voting a SR, I have a problem with not seeing any strong reads in that ISO

Like, I read that.. WHY ARE 2 PEOPLE VOTING ME??? HAVE YOU 2 LOOKED AT EYES???

Eyes ISO is terrible, if it doesn't improve I'm voting there today
What about not having a strong read in day one makes the slot so scummy for you?

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:31 am
by fireisredsir
a few people have said that hockey is looking more newbie than scum (FA, greeting, and now scorpio, i think, off the top of my head), and i wanna push back on that a lil bit. imo he's played enough games to not be a newbie, most of them as town. look through this ISO from one of his more recent town games (it's not that long, come on, just do it):
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13048257

even when he got elimmed on day 2 there i don't think you can say it was cause of newbie mistakes, at least that's not how i read it. and he is just behaving so differently there to how he is here.

buuut he has a lot fewer maf games, one on site and at least one or two off site. here's the ISO, and he already linked another one:
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13047489

he just feels awkward and fake in the same way he does here, saying things that don't really make sense for town to say, laying it on too thick sometimes. i think you could safely call him a newbie maf (conspiracy theory is that maybe he called himself one in scum chat and so his partners think he is a newbie overall), and i think he is making newbie maf mistakes

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:38 am
by fireisredsir
i just noticed/remembered this actually, maybe that's why people thought he was more of a newbie than he is (conspiracy theory ruined, sadness):
In post 370, HockeyFan wrote:I have like 4-5 played fourm games(so really not that much)
when he has played i count 11 completed on site and enough offsite to be mafia at least twice (the one he linked and another one where he was partners with koba). kiiinda weird to get that so wrong

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:38 am
by Frozen Angel
the one thing I see in adantes big post and I saw it too about hockey is his branching/backtracks with questions and pursues and his weird assurances and appeals to people, especially when it's about him making reads or others reading about him. Like post 50 was one the biggest posts I suspected when I was catching up.

I don't know hockey enough out of this game - just did a very fast look on links he sent and stuff to judge if its him being new or not.

stuff like this stand out to me too

Spoiler:
In post 383, Frozen Angel wrote:
In post 379, HockeyFan wrote:I can not for the life of me figure out how to ISO(sorry!), so you can just have the link(this is the site i played on) -> https://mafiascum-closedgame.freeforums ... waterfalls
How can someone who played as mafia and lived till later phases, not know that scum can fake their town play and to look as aggressive and pushy to gain town read, even after it was directly mentioned in the thread as the reason by someone believing that could have been the fake play in response to the same post?

and I mean this post:
In post 170, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 160, fireisredsir wrote:stephen looks a lot worse off that than dwlee does to me. pushing a pointless point and acting like you caught someone in something? hmm. i can see a certain type of scum player doing that, whether because he really thinks he has a point (he doesn't, dwlee is right here) or because he knows that dumb extended fights like that a lot of times will make others skim and assume both are town
I need you to expand on this. Why would Steven do this as scum? He spent 2 pages trying to get an answer for a mostly "mild" sus from Dwlee. If stephen is mafia, he can really just ignore dwlee's read(or play it off), what is the benefit of doing what stephen did as scum there?


And his answer was "he doesn't expect scum to do it right when they replace in - which didn't answer the concern I had with it.

but for me hockey is like consistent with his inconsistencies (the same you said about eye fire :D) so I'm a bit conflicted about how to approach my read on this slot

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:43 am
by Frozen Angel
about eye I think I believe him about how he didn't mean to flag my slot with mentioning the theory after his answers earlier today. I was about to remove my vote but then he said he doesn't want heat for voting dwlee when its like his only scum read and it just alarmed the hell out of me specially in other few games I looked he felt way more vote/opinion happy in early games as town and someone who dumps a theory like that to reaction test (as he made reads on replacements reactions to his theory) wouldn't hesitate to actually make a push on someone he was persuing by throwing out a theory like that

So his idea and general game play are inconsistent with each other

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:45 am
by Frozen Angel
In post 558, Eyes without a face wrote:Dwlee's reaction was by far the worst. 4Yours was weird and tilted I can't decide for sure but I think it's a personal trait. Nero's was the best and Stephen didn't address it I don't think
In post 560, Eyes without a face wrote:
In post 559, Frozen Angel wrote:what about greetings, Hockey's and fires takes on it

can you elaborate on why you think Nero's reaction was the best and dwlee's was worse?
Greeting, Hockey and fire are not even replacements so the intended pressure wasn't directed at them. Nero's reaction was good because he acknowledged the existence of a=such a theory even if he personally didn't believe in it. Dwlee was bad because they voted me without trying to engage or discuss the theory at all. It looked like a reason they used to place a vote on someone they thought might be an easy lim
He even refused to even comment on the rest of people engagement about his theory.

then why would he care to get heat over making a push about the only read he claimed he got from his reaction testing?

Just feels inconsistant

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:48 am
by Scorpious
In post 614, HockeyFan wrote:
In post 602, Stephen A Smith wrote:We should make FaceBoy and HockeyDude pick teams for the superbowl and yeet the one that picks wrong
lol.

I'm gunning for the bengals to win, Joe Burrow deserves a SB.

I just reread the frozen/eyes stuff, did not get much out of it, but I like the way Frozen is playing, and I dont think the 2 are partners here
Not crazy about this post man, But yeah Go Bengals!!

If you re read and got nothing out of it, why tell us. That changes the gamestate literally 0. Not even needed to be typed. But, you continue on saying you like FA’s play and that you don’t think they are partners.

So you..did “get something”, and the quotes on get something because that something would be the most ineffectual “something” to take from the exchange..



You just pulled ahead of eyes for my vote unless you can explain this.

Actually. You can explain this to get my vote off.. this was bad posting man..

VOTE: Hockey

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:50 am
by Scorpious
Not 100% sure how many votes he has but I feel I’m in the realm of courtesy posting how close to yeet he is.

Posted: Sun Feb 13, 2022 9:11 am
by fireisredsir
hockey at 5, eyes at 4, i think