Newbie 2095 | Game over

[Greeting]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Mala

Into the darkness I go.

I've been thinking about this as well, but I'd rather see the

Alianna

flip first.

[Greeting]

I can’t with you anymore.

See you post game ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Not going to base an entire scumread off this, but this feels really sketchy, as if they knew Roden was dying because no doc.

Oof I dig that

How would you know there's no Doctor in the game,

Alianna

?

[whiskey delta]

So what you're saying is that Mala and BBT are highly likely scum?

Coming back to this. What I am saying is that if I am right about you being Town, and Alianna is Town and right about hutmeil being Town, then that only leaves three players for the scum to be in. 72(BBT)/Greeting seems unlikely. If Greeting is the last Townie then that only leaves 72(BBT)/Mala left over.

What do you think?

[Alianna]

I can’t with you anymore.

See you post game ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Not going to base an entire scumread off this, but this feels really sketchy, as if they knew Roden was dying because no doc.

Oof I dig that

:neutral:

How would you know there's no Doctor in the game,

Alianna

?

I mean, I don't technically. But if there is, neither of the two scenarios is likely.
Scenario A is that the doctor targeted someone other than Roden. Why would they ever do that?
Scenario B is that scum were certain enough of who the doctor was to shoot Roden anyway and hope they could RB the doctor.
I can't see into the scum PT, but Occam's Razor says we're just in C1.

[whiskey delta]

I read the game. I got 2 scum reads in 5 pages, why read more?

Fighting between 3 people on D1 and 2 of them are conf town? Highly unlikely to be 3 townies, me thinks.

I expected Mala to be off the wagon because Furtive was obvtown in the first 2 pages. I think Mala probably picks up on that.

Normally I'd agree but I know I am Town this time so if that's possible, so is anything as far as I'm concerned.

Maybe check out the Mala ISO and see what you think. Also remember takot syndrone was their alt to start the game

Read up to page 15, Whiskey is still scum.

Also, the timing of Greeting's push on Furtive as it looks like an Alianna wagon could potentially take off is noted.

Feel good that scum is here; Whiskey, Alianna and Greeting.

You keep calling me scum but show no reason trolling me will not get me to TR you if that is your aim

Whiskey had a good couple of pages there, 16 and 17. Really liked your posting.

Hmm, Alianna is still a scum read and she has to go Today.

Thank you. I rather liked those ones too. 396 in particular felt like a slam dunk and still might be. 400 is gold if correct but also the sort of narrative that scum can run with to end game. D1 was so weird that I have come around to thinking I shouldn't discount anything. Like I have said before, it's impossible that there is more than two scum in [WD, hutmeil, Greeting, Alianna] but it's also possible there is none.

[whiskey delta]

Alianna, do you think everyone on the Roden wagon is Town?

Roden - (whiskey) hutmeil, Greeting, FG, Alianna

The game is riding on this question lol

[whiskey delta]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Mala

Into the darkness I go.

I've been thinking about this as well, but I'd rather see the

Alianna

flip first.

I can see where your head is at and I understand. It makes sense for a lot of reasons but feels kinda bad? Logic says to elim Alianna but my soul read is less sure.

I overlooked Mala D1 but they have trended downward quickly. Hutmeil SR is the same one they have had from intro and I don't see much process going on to figure it out. Tidus might have nailed this one.

[whiskey delta]

I'm caught up. Greeting has been scum reading Alianna for a while now with no vote. Interesting.

I'm only eliminating between Greeting and Alianna Today. Nobody else.

In your own words, why are each of them scum?

[whiskey delta]

It’s literally a coin flip whether or not there is a doc and Roden was dead man walking as soon as he claimed. It’s a stretch to TMI that

@Alianna - where is your head right now?

[Malakittens]

My issue right now with Hutmeil is his playstyle seemed to do a complete 180 overnight. He went from playing like legit newbscum to different in a way that's just bothering me.

D1 was spent fishing for information IMO.

[Alianna]

I mean, it seems as if the anti-town posting was a reaction test.

[Alianna]

Aliana - She's my TR. But nothing is set in stone of course. Just the way she responded to my "anti-town" post on D1. But as you pointed out, VCA on her somewhat deducts points from her Towniness.

Mala - As I've mentioned already, I've no current read on the slot (neutral). Basically, anyone who disliked my "antitown" post on D1 either got a TR or a neutral reading from me. Almost everyone did except for you (WD) and FG.

[Malakittens]

Which was a really stupid reaction test IMO.

but hey w/e

[Malakittens]

I should have stuck to my gut and tried to fight off the LIM on FG, but it was a hard place because the CW is Ali who i have a slight vibe for a townread on

mainly because i hate majority of this playerlist besides 2-3 ppl

[Alianna]

Which was a really stupid reaction test IMO.

but hey w/e

I don't agree with that play either, but I don't think it's necessarily scum-indicative. I can certainly see newb(ish)town trying it.

[Alianna]

If you're still here, mind answering the question in 570?

[Alianna]

So what you're saying is that Mala and BBT are highly likely scum?

Coming back to this. What I am saying is that if I am right about you being Town, and Alianna is Town and right about hutmeil being Town, then that only leaves three players for the scum to be in. 72(BBT)/Greeting seems unlikely. If Greeting is the last Townie then that only leaves 72(BBT)/Mala left over.

What do you think?

What about a Mala/Greeting pair? Mala only mentioned Greeting once and that was to TR them with zero explanation. Greeting gave a bit more of a reason, but it was pretty much all meta and though they've expressed doubt, it doesn't seem like they're actually considering voting there. 600 could easily be distancing.

[Alianna]

VOTE: Malakittens

E-2

[Alianna]

To answer your question, BBT, I probably won't be voting whiskey, but I could be persuaded. I'd like to hear why

you

want to eliminate them so badly.

[Malakittens]

Right.

I already mentioned if Hutmeil is scum then his partner was more of an inactive player/newer player {Tidus & 72}.

I don’t see greeting being scum tbh. Granted that’s a gut read and I haven’t seen greeting!scum, but I’m just feeling him playing every similar.

As far as Ali and FG which is points that Hutmeil brought up that they were partners because of the page 1&2 antics if you have ever been in the last two dead threads that I modded that’s them in a nutshell. It’s more of an NAI.

Maybe I should have stuck with my gut and ended up going after Ali rather than letting FG go, but I also was completely no sleep for days when the deadline approached. I couldn’t even think straight.

I still got a null read on 72.

I also do like BBT’s posts but idk if that’s just because I miss playing with BbT or it’s an actual read feeling

[Malakittens]

As for whiskey, I still have a townread on that slot.

[Alianna]

What do you think of hutmeil's strong desire to yeet Tidus and 72 expressed in 259, 260, and 376?

[Alianna]

I'm not saying it's impossible, but I do think it's bold if hutmeil is partnered with either.

[Malakittens]

i mean if a partner is useless then by all means hardbusyeet so i'm not going to rule them out as a partner because of a strong desire to kill

[Alianna]

i mean if a partner is useless then by all means hardbusyeet so i'm not going to rule them out as a partner because of a strong desire to kill

I was thinking more along the lines of potentially winning faster because you get to ELo a day earlier, but that's a fair point.