Mafiascum.net

In post 6074, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 6007, MalcolmTucker wrote:I agree Flavor is likely mafia on balance of things

this really irks me. Like what do you know about the games balance?

there's a flipped town voyer

a flipped wolf bookie

2 claimed 1x gs

a vt claim

a parity cop claim

a monkery and a masonary.

I might be forgetting some claims but I don't see how a town you, with the same info as me, can determine whether or not a vig exists based on balance.

In post 6075, Nero Cain wrote:I mean, its not spite spite like I dislike you so much that I'm intentionally ignoring the game to spite you just that I don't trust that your mena read is truthful.

In post 6074, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 6007, MalcolmTucker wrote:I agree Flavor is likely mafia on balance of things

this really irks me. Like what do you know about the games balance?

there's a flipped town voyer

a flipped wolf bookie

2 claimed 1x gs

a vt claim

a parity cop claim

a monkery and a masonary.

I might be forgetting some claims but I don't see how a town you, with the same info as me, can determine whether or not a vig exists based on balance.

In post 6078, Nero Cain wrote:pretty sure I was calling yd-butter scum before you did, not that I really care. My Malcolm thing is just that he was going to bat for Butterchurn and that "Boon is scum based on balance." just seems wildly dumb.

mena seems like a useless lurksack regardless of alignment so...

In post 6084, Save The Dragons wrote:

In post 6077, SCP 682 wrote:

In post 6075, Nero Cain wrote:I mean, its not spite spite like I dislike you so much that I'm intentionally ignoring the game to spite you just that I don't trust that your mena read is truthful.

Well I think you should try reevaling if you reached similar scumreads as me for mafia after I already outted my reads there.

Mena likes to be a lurkfuck as scum and loses a lot of steam as the game goes - and that's present here, and he has no fire in his play.

VOTE: Malcom

Let's do this, aight?

In post 5399, Nashville Dreams wrote:UNVOTE: ND

I know Mala voted a guilty claim and it's usually the right thing to do, but there are a few things that give me doubt without the guilty being fake. So I'd like to compare who wants FL dead with the VCs.

1) FL claiming at night start. While I can't see it, FL wouldn't lie there as multiple people could CC him. Well we could have a whole random neighbor bullshit but unlikely.
2) The limited kill mechanic - The amount of nightkills/heals required to believe FL is not a vig. Heals/kill stops are very unlikely n1 due to the sheer number of possible heal targets and the lack of information. At least the werewolf kill was non-existent/healed/stopped/did not occur. Given the penalty to killing, it makes it very much less likely that FL matched a scum kill target.
3) FL is consistent - Shooting someone that was impossible to eliminate despite feeling there's great evidence makes sense. It also helps his townreads.
4) Ease to lim catboi - A catboi kill, unless mafia were tunneling him all day, doesn't make sense particularly given the cost. They would know, at a minimum, there would be two slots always willing to vote catboi/RCE. Even if we supposed FL scum, he would know that a catboi elimination would always be a strategically preferred elimination.
5) Catboi alive protects FL partners - With catboi alive, it shields his teammates because of the repeated wagon unless of course FL's team was flailing like desperate chickens to eliminate catboi.

~Titus

In post 5451, The Keeper wrote:

In post 5410, SCP 682 wrote:people really intentionally ignoring the fact FL claimed vig during the night phase before any of these "guilties" came out

For what it's worth I've taken FL out of my malefactor read.

In post 5467, MonkeyMan576 wrote:Because that's exactly what he would do if he was mafia.

In post 5519, SCP 682 wrote:Look - we will have FL shoot mastina tonight

That is how we will prove it.

OK?

In post 6078, Nero Cain wrote:mena seems like a useless lurksack regardless of alignment so...

In post 5649, MonkeyMan576 wrote:I don't buy FL's kill conditions.

In post 5674, The Keeper wrote:

In post 5625, MonkeyMan576 wrote:DOesn't make sense that vig kill condition is related to possible scum being alive.

In post 5626, MonkeyMan576 wrote:Like, you can kill, but if a scum player in your monastary dies you can't kill anymore?

That's actually a perfectly valid vig gate.

In post 6096, Menalque wrote:This game just isn’t and hasn’t been fun for ages but I feel that repping out ruins game integrity so I’m sticking with it at minimal activity hoping that either I get limmed or that enough people get limmed that I start wanting to play again