Page 247 of 305

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:15 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 6113, ulyana wrote:i feel like,

me/gammagooey/peta/ydrasse

right now,

but need to review
For what

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:16 am
by Taly
In post 6132, petapan wrote:
In post 6104, Taly wrote:
Gamma Emerald wrote:
In post 6093, Taly wrote:What do you wanna do,
Gamma
?
I want to write up a post on my unsub (to you guys at least), then we can discuss that idea
Whilst that’s in the works we can also do our first Heaven vote, my thing will be more important for the first Hell vote.
I see you as locktown rn, as well as Gooey because I feel like he’s really been an asset to town atp. Like, I just don’t see how his skitter/FB push could ever be a bus.
Yeah
Ggy
is behind you if I had to rank my townreads.

Like the bus seems a bit unnecessary and doesn't actually clear him if he is scum trying to accrue town cred because there's so many ways the shooting could've gone down if scum knew that's what the vote was for. And because I personally would think scum keeping their own alive is optimal in a setup with very unclear methods of limming players.
FTR gammagooey entered the game voting skitter in the blue room which would be supremely unnecessary if it were a bus + skitter spent a ton of time trying to get galron/unwnd killed (and to note, was voting him over dunn)

the slot is just town
Oh yeah this only strengthens my point.
In post 6133, petapan wrote:also, on the record, if TA is scum i think Taly and ulyana are lock town due to how saber treated them in the blue room and the last teammate is only ever in cakez/ydrasse


if it's not TA then the game is significantly harder and something really screwy is going on
Any thought that serves a
TA
Town narrative?
In post 6134, petapan wrote:probably just going to assume gamma emerald is town, only world it's even possible he isn't is in a TA-town world but then event 1 still played out in a really weird way with scum sending one of their own

actually think it looks ok for ydrasse given the event 2 voting
Elaborate on
Ydra
day 2 progression?

I think a good thing to note is that if it's
Ydra/TA
, it very well fits my gamestatw read that scum has protected each other up to this point. Do you think
Ydra
could've been protecting a partner even though she was expressing an unpopular opinion about a teammate so openly?

It almost feels quite obvious for scumplay, or perhaps this Town is just really sharp.
In post 6136, petapan wrote:
In post 4464, SirCakez wrote:
In post 4463, SirCakez wrote:oooof does skitter have me pocketed here?
said this because the POE is stronger and something about their entrance today irked me
bro...
I agree that that is an awkward take.
In post 6137, petapan wrote:
In post 5983, SirCakez wrote:Right now I'd be like

Town: Peta, Gammagooey, Gamma Emerald
Nulltown: Ydra, Taly
Null: Toog, Firebringer
Nullscum: Almost50 (mainly because I feel like his entrance here was his scum game)
Scum: Tamora's Angel, Ulyana
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
What is odd about this readslist ?

I can name a few things, but I want to hear what you think.
In post 6144, petapan wrote:trying to save firebringer last event is only AI if both cakez and TA are town otherwise a bit of a nonsense play as scum

i tihnk skitter was trying to powerwolf with cakez though (which makes me feel a little silly about the end of last event but doing so woulda been protown anyway)
Honestly I was thinking this about
Ulya
last night.

Why does
Ulya
scum vy to save a partner last minute when they can easily be flipped somehow still and sre under scrutiny?

Surface level suspicion is adequate but it doesn't hold the more you peel it back.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:17 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 6124, ulyana wrote:
In post 6123, Taly wrote:
Ulya/Ydra
Ulya/Cakez
Ulya/TA
Ydra/Cakez
Ydra/TA
Cakez/TA


Anybody have a preference for which interactions I ISO first?
all of the ones involving me are going to show i’m unpartnered and are unnecessary
Nah, prolly do those first actually
Taly

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:19 am
by Taly
Help me not tilt at this point
Gamma
, I need to be in solve mode not 1v1 mode.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:21 am
by Taly
It's weird cause I've got reasons to toenrrad
Ulya
but their reply to me even wanting to look closer to me is the sum of what I'd expect scum to do.

Or self absorbed town, I think this is still likelier true.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:22 am
by Taly
Omg my phone fucke that up.

What I'm saying is, if I were town in
Ulya's
, I would not doubtcast someone's alignment if they wanted to investigate me. That's anti-teamwork.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:24 am
by Taly
Still kinda mad.

Gotta remember that
Peta
is snuggly.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:29 am
by Gamma Emerald
I honestly feel like Ulyana might actually be scum though. There’s 2 things that I feel like point to that being the case. First, the way she’s felt like she’s been dropping a lot of aimless shade everywhere reminds of how Dunnstral
-as-Knight Beige had a weird aggro reaction to Cakez-Azure wanting to pair with me-Chartreuse. The other point is that it feels like twice now that Ulyana has put on the jets in response to pressure of some sort. Earlier in the game I criticized that she felt barely engaged and as a result her posting and engagement spiked. Now it feels like it’s gone up again, this is potentially in response to the crunch being put on her overarching plans.
This was originally gonna be a lot higher effort of a post but I felt like I needed to make it clear for Taly that the tilt might actually be a sign.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:30 am
by Gamma Emerald
That Ulyana read is also why I have Cakez as town, ftr

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:39 am
by Taly
GAMMA-


:dead:

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:47 am
by Taly
Let's work to be as cohesive as possible.

How about we do a table for who to Heven.

Place your name on the player you want to Heaven. You can go more than or even less than 4 players.

Taly:
Taly
Gamma Emerald:
Taly
petapan:
Taly
Gammagooey:
Taly
Ydrasse:

Cakez:

TA:


I want EVERYBODY to do this. We could help this base our Heaven and Hell decisions.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:47 am
by Taly
Oh wait I blocked
Ulya
from memory my bad

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 12:48 am
by Taly
In post 6160, Taly wrote:Let's work to be as cohesive as possible.

How about we do a table for who to Heven.

Place your name on the player you want to Heaven. You can go more than or even less than 4 players.

Taly: Taly
Gamma Emerald: Taly
petapan: Taly
Gammagooey: Taly
Ydrasse:
Cakez:
Ulyana:
TA:
Fixed.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:06 am
by ulyana
In post 6145, Taly wrote:
In post 6126, ulyana wrote:feel like taly knows i am town and then makes believe i might not be
Ulya
, you give me a headache sometimes.
In post 6148, Taly wrote:Ulya is probably town as you've already concluded.
this is what i meant though, it is like you make show of doing something to sort me, then conclude i am town, but then a little while later treat it as if my slot is one you still have to look closely at instead of others like why would you want to start with my interactions when peta/ydrasse would be two birds with the almost50 thing you said you wanted to look at and you and gamma emerald just say the other is town while refusing to look closely at each other’s actions and instead are like ‘let’s sort ulyana again (even though she’s town) and it doesn’t make a lot of sense to me

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:08 am
by ulyana
In post 6150, Gamma Emerald wrote:
In post 6113, ulyana wrote:i feel like,

me/gammagooey/peta/ydrasse

right now,

but need to review
For what
for heaven

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:11 am
by ulyana
In post 6157, Gamma Emerald wrote:I honestly feel like Ulyana might actually be scum though. There’s 2 things that I feel like point to that being the case. First, the way she’s felt like she’s been dropping a lot of aimless shade everywhere reminds of how Dunnstral
-as-Knight Beige had a weird aggro reaction to Cakez-Azure wanting to pair with me-Chartreuse. The other point is that it feels like twice now that Ulyana has put on the jets in response to pressure of some sort. Earlier in the game I criticized that she felt barely engaged and as a result her posting and engagement spiked. Now it feels like it’s gone up again, this is potentially in response to the crunch being put on her overarching plans.
This was originally gonna be a lot higher effort of a post but I felt like I needed to make it clear for Taly that the tilt might actually be a sign.
could have told you this is where you were going with this - why does dunnstral’s play in some other game have anything to do with my alignment? and your narrative is ??????????? here like you KNOW why i was disengaged so saying it’s scummy that i was at one point and am now more engaged is so disingenuous

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:17 am
by ulyana
In post 6157, Gamma Emerald wrote:The other point is that it feels like twice now that Ulyana has put on the jets in response to pressure of some sort. Earlier in the game I criticized that she felt barely engaged and as a result her posting and engagement spiked. Now it feels like it’s gone up again, this is potentially in response to the crunch being put on her overarching plans.
also why is this how you think scum!me functions? like is that based on anything at all? having played with scum!me (and town!me) before?

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:21 am
by Ydrasse
In post 6162, Taly wrote:
In post 6160, Taly wrote:Let's work to be as cohesive as possible.

How about we do a table for who to Heven.

Place your name on the player you want to Heaven. You can go more than or even less than 4 players.

Taly: Taly, Ydrasse
Gamma Emerald: Taly, Ydrasse
petapan: Taly, Ydrasse
Gammagooey: Taly, Ydrasse
Ydrasse:
Cakez:
Ulyana:
TA:
Fixed.

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:21 am
by ulyana
In post 6163, ulyana wrote:
In post 6145, Taly wrote:
In post 6126, ulyana wrote:feel like taly knows i am town and then makes believe i might not be
Ulya
, you give me a headache sometimes.
In post 6148, Taly wrote:Ulya is probably town as you've already concluded.
this is what i meant though, it is like you make show of doing something to sort me, then conclude i am town, but then a little while later treat it as if my slot is one you still have to look closely at instead of others like why would you want to start with my interactions when peta/ydrasse would be two birds with the almost50 thing you said you wanted to look at and you and gamma emerald just say the other is town while refusing to look closely at each other’s actions and instead are like ‘let’s sort ulyana again (even though she’s town) and it doesn’t make a lot of sense to me
and you say i am probably town but won’t consider for heaven like it just the same loop even though actually doing any of the hard work detective stuff you make show of doing gives same result - that i am town - because!!! i am town

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:33 am
by ulyana
In post 6167, Ydrasse wrote:
In post 6162, Taly wrote:
In post 6160, Taly wrote: Taly: purgatory
Gamma Emerald: hell
petapan: heaven
Gammagooey: heaven
Ydrasse: purgatory
Cakez: hell
Ulyana: heaven
TA: hell

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:37 am
by ulyana
In post 6155, Taly wrote:What I'm saying is, if I were town in Ulya's, I would not doubtcast someone's alignment if they wanted to investigate me.
also making believe this is like a one time thing and the only thing i’ve doubted with regards to your slot is ??? based on our past interactions

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:40 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 6166, ulyana wrote:
In post 6157, Gamma Emerald wrote:The other point is that it feels like twice now that Ulyana has put on the jets in response to pressure of some sort. Earlier in the game I criticized that she felt barely engaged and as a result her posting and engagement spiked. Now it feels like it’s gone up again, this is potentially in response to the crunch being put on her overarching plans.
also why is this how you think scum!me functions? like is that based on anything at all? having played with scum!me (and town!me) before?
I’ve gone on record earlier this game that this game feels like a wildly different game for you just in general

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:41 am
by Taly
In post 6168, ulyana wrote:
In post 6163, ulyana wrote:
In post 6145, Taly wrote:
In post 6126, ulyana wrote:feel like taly knows i am town and then makes believe i might not be
Ulya
, you give me a headache sometimes.
In post 6148, Taly wrote:Ulya is probably town as you've already concluded.
this is what i meant though, it is like you make show of doing something to sort me, then conclude i am town, but then a little while later treat it as if my slot is one you still have to look closely at instead of others like why would you want to start with my interactions when peta/ydrasse would be two birds with the almost50 thing you said you wanted to look at and you and gamma emerald just say the other is town while refusing to look closely at each other’s actions and instead are like ‘let’s sort ulyana again (even though she’s town) and it doesn’t make a lot of sense to me
and you say i am probably town but won’t consider for heaven like it just the same loop even though actually doing any of the hard work detective stuff you make show of doing gives same result - that i am town - because!!! i am town
There are 6 town. I'm heavening people based on the confidence and strength of my townread. Yes, this is subject to change, but I currently feel solid about my choices and that's not to outright suggest that you are scum..

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:42 am
by ulyana
In post 6171, Gamma Emerald wrote:
In post 6166, ulyana wrote:
In post 6157, Gamma Emerald wrote:The other point is that it feels like twice now that Ulyana has put on the jets in response to pressure of some sort. Earlier in the game I criticized that she felt barely engaged and as a result her posting and engagement spiked. Now it feels like it’s gone up again, this is potentially in response to the crunch being put on her overarching plans.
also why is this how you think scum!me functions? like is that based on anything at all? having played with scum!me (and town!me) before?
I’ve gone on record earlier this game that this game feels like a wildly different game for you just in general
why is this different from radio buzz other than i’ve been alive longer?

Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2021 1:44 am
by Taly
In post 6167, Ydrasse wrote:Let's work to be as cohesive as possible.

How about we do a table for who to Heven.

Place your name on the player you want to Heaven. You can go more than or even less than 4 players.

Taly: Taly, Ydrasse
Gamma Emerald: Taly, Ydrasse
petapan: Taly, Ydrasse, Ulyana
Gammagooey: Taly, Ydrasse, Ulyana
Ydrasse:
Cakez:
Ulyana: Ulyans
TA:
Is thus an accurate depixtion if your vote,
Ulya


Do you have your votes for this
Gamna
?