DHSDSM beta: Game Over.

[J-Scope]

Not sure what FD means, since I wasn't trying to vote him earlier. Anyway, we'll have to see if a kill got through today. If not, we'll still get another chance even if nyball is not scum. But I think he is scum.

And I think other scum is Zaphod.

Vote: nyballosulgniirkps

[Saunt Adelaus]

Twilight, Day 6!

Nyball 4 - Jahudo, Ojando, PoketheAlpaca, Nyball
Frog Dodging 3 - Zaphod, Nyball, Ortohoops

Nyball - A Doctor (Pro-town) was Lynched!

It is now twilight. Twilight will take X hours from the hammer vote (X is already determined, and less than 24 hours). Votes and Actions will not be counted during twilight. I'll announce the end of twilight with another post. Feel free to talk in the meanwhile, day 7 will begin soon.

[ortolan]

I think we should dine on frogs' legs

[Saunt Adelaus]

Start of Day 7 - you have 2 weeks from this post.

With 6 players alive, it is 4 to Lynch.

[Jahudo]

I still don't believe 4 docs, and I still think the lack of kills are due to protections, so Frog seems the clear choice.

[Zaphod Beeblebrox]

Let's try again.

vote: FrogDodging

[J-Scope]

Vote: Frog Dodging

[Ojando]

There cannot be 4 doctors. I really hated how Jdodge tried to guide my protect out of the way.

vote: Frog Dodging

[PoketheAlpaca]

There can't be 4 doctors. The choice is obvious

I think we should dine on frogs' legs

Pass the salt

Vote: Frog Dodging

[populartajo]

Hi.

[PoketheAlpaca]

That might have been the worst simulpost ever. I hope you sent your action before I voted.

[JDodge]

Gogo town quicklynch loss!

[Saunt Adelaus]

Frog Dodging, Doctor, was lynched.
Zaphod Beeblebrox, Townie, was endgamed
Orto-Hoops, Latvian Mafia Godfather, was endgamed

PokeTheAlpaca, Ojando and J-Scope, Bulgarian Mafia Doctors, win the game!

[ortolan]

damnit

if they didn't all get a protect in in time (although I assume they did) I still could have killed one of them (I would have gone for J-Scope)

I thought Frog was scum instead of J-Scope because of his reaction to nyb's claim and his own doctor claim. I should have guesssed that scum wouldn't claim 2 out of 3 doctors though. I just didn't expect that many town doctors.

I would have thought the fact there were three town doctors made the scum's job of fitting in very easy pretty much (plus they can just protect one another every round to stop cross-kills).

[Jahudo]

Yay! Good game everybody, and great work team bulgaria!

for RW. At least you know it was mostly a scum driven wagon and you had me pegged from the beginning.

Thank you for modding these two games Adel and Claus!

[ortolan]

I probably should have tried to get Ojando lynched actually, I strongly suspected he was scum with PTA after my kill on PTA didn't go through and he claimed to protect him repeatedly; and then when my kill on Ojando didn't go through (despite no-one claiming to have protected him) it was confirmed he and PTA were scum together.

[ortolan]

good game, well done to the Bulgarians

[PokerFace]

GG orto. Me and yos had you pegged as latvian for the longest time. I will admit there were times we debated you being it in our scum quick topic but 80% of the time the rest of the group saw my logic for why it was you. We were all very worried you were a Mafia Role blocker. That sort of thing could have really hurt us.

BTW to all those that thought I was scum because I was wasting too many posted. That type of acusation did not apply to the Bulgarians. We were all doctors and could not kill. Thus we had no motivation to waste posts. If anything we wanted to game to take a long time so our protects would last longer. Ironically SWSWC death that cleared me also didn't apply to me because there were 2 scum groups. Yes rules said "One group of 3 Mafia" Our group had 3 while yours had 2. Talk about a wierd loop hole. SWSWC death made us go nuts in the QT realizing we had more baddies in the game. I'm down with posting the QT link if everyone else in the group is also down. I won't be posting it until the give their blessings

Latvians either needed one of them to be a RB or one of the 3 town docs needed to be a RB I think to better balance things or at least lower our chances

7 Town (3 docs 2 trackers)
3 Bulgarian docs can't kill because oath of hypocracies
2 Latvian GFs that can kill
2 SKs

[ortolan]

BTW to all those that thought I was scum because I was wasting too many posted.

We actually didn't think you were scum at all until the kill on you didn't go through

[PokerFace]

@Claus,

it probably would be a good idea to change the title hear and or pm the dead players so that they all know its over. May also be time to unlock/necro the alpha game since they are both over and there are some things that probably need posted in both games.

Thanks for picking up where Adel left off Claus. Thanks Adel for a really interesting game and setup.

I was originally mad I was in a scum group that could not kill. I felt like I was a survivor. Those roles are boring and inspire lurkage. Then SWSWC dies and things got incredibly interesting and more fun for me. The Scum QT is very long and we did try to guess other peoples roles. Most of the time we were wrong but we did think FD was a doc when Ojando saw FD call them town for pretty much no reason. I guess the crumb didn't apply despite it being right. Didn't think Yos and incamn would be trackers. Had Yos down as a possible power role but not as tracker. His change from thinking I was scum to thinking I was town was odd. Did he track me somewhere and realize I couldn't kill? RW has to explain why he went after FD after protecting them. I seriously thought they were scum with that claim. I think we may have thought RW was a vig before any SK's showed up for some early kill speculation they did. When SWSWC died and the 2 scum group thing was figured out I proudly said the following in our QT.

I love you Adel and I wish you were still a chick! Ha Ha!

GG and great fun to all

[ortolan]

I wanna see your qt

[PokerFace]

BTW to all those that thought I was scum because I was wasting too many posted.

We actually didn't think you were scum at all until the kill on you didn't go through

You actually thought I was town?

Was there ever a time you suspected the entire other group was all docs? I seem to remember you saying something like that at one point so I guess I'm asking how far in advance you thought the other group could not kill

[Adel]

Thanks for picking up the game Claus.

I messed in in Alpha... Spring pulled off an awesome claim in alpha, claiming tracker,

but was really vanilla in Alpha

, and was only a tracker in Beta. Her breadcrumb'ed claim was good enough that I made a mod error, my bad.

[PokerFace]

I wanna see your qt

Like I said tons of speculation. Only got You as scum and FD as possible doc right.

Thinking RW was a vig was so far off.
Definatly did not think Nyball was a doc. 3-4 town docs did sound crazy
Thinking Yos was scum for my meta read was also so far off
Later thinking they had some power was at least a better thought.
Trying to out guess an Adel setup was alot harder for me and Tajo than ABR's Black Fang setup where I actually did guess them all right down to the character names.

I'll only show the QT if rest of the group thinks its ok. I have absolutly no problem posting it but if they do I would respect their privacy

[PokerFace]

Thanks for picking up the game Claus.

I messed in in Alpha... Spring pulled off an awesome claim in alpha, claiming tracker,

but was really vanilla in Alpha

, and was only a tracker in Beta. Her breadcrumb'ed claim was good enough that I made a mod error, my bad.

You mean incamn was only a tracker here and there were only 2 in alpha? Wow