Open 426: *Unspecified, as of yet* -GAME STARTED DAWGS

[UberNinja]

It's time to play the Process of Elimination game.

Town:
Loranthaceae, obviously
Greywing
BK201
Blastoide

Probably town:
Arugula
Chrimi (he's trying way too hard to appear so, but I'm convinced for now)
Malakittens

This leaves:
drmyshotgun/Hyperion
roflcopter
Shiidaji
Jal

Scum is in there, guaranteed.

Guaran-fucking-teed.

FTFM



Town as fuck (don't lynch these people ever ever ever):
Loranthaceae
Greywing
Chrimi

Pretty damn town:
Blastoide
BK201

Probably town:
Arugula
Malakittens

Not in any other group, so scum is in here:
drmyshotgun/Hyperion
roflcopter
Shiidaji

Definitely scum:
Jal

[UberNinja]

That's....a really good point. I'm so proud, Uber.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jal

Finally. Fuck.


If you're scum this game I'm going to paint the walls with your brains, btw.

[Arugula]

Dw, I'm not.

[roflcopter]

not reading uber's spam yet. i wish i could say i was surprised that 2/3+ of a page is filled with his multiposting. i'll come back to it later.

[Arugula]

Only read 621, rofl.

[UberNinja]

not reading uber's spam yet. i wish i could say i was surprised that 2/3+ of a page is filled with his multiposting. i'll come back to it later.

Oh you of little faith.

[Jal]

Sooooo Jal, you want to know what problem(s) I have with you?

There are at least

three

in post #182 by itself.

Can you find them?


This hint should make it easier... they all occur on the FIRST LINE OF THE POST.

1.

It's your first post in over two days. You magically show up shortly after someone (Chrimi) says your name and votes for you. I don't have to explain why the Beetlejuice routine is scummy. Especially because you hadn't been prodded yet.

2.

This part of your post:

Going to mosey my way through this thread. Hopefully this is the last time I ever do a wall of this magnificence.

Why is this bad? Because it reeks of revisionism. The phrase "Going to mosey my way through this thread" was written at the beginning, before you had written everything else, obviously,

but

, also obviously, the "Hopefully this is the last time I ever do a wall of this magnificence" was written at the end, after the wall was already in existence. And that means you went back up and changed that part at the end. This is commonly something scum do: they make walls, and then because they're worried about everything being perfect, they go back through it and perfect little things in it to make it appear less scummy and more towny.

3.

This also applies to the first line of the post: You're looking for brownie points for making text on the page. Town shouldn't have to do that. Town shouldn't be looking for brownie points at all; they should be finding scum. And I didn't see you find anything in your post; it certainly didn't have a vote at the end of it, like any "good" town wall should.

I'm not even going to go into the rest of the reasons you are scum; this should be sufficient to garner enough sheep votes to put you into the ground.

Jal is scum, y'all. Vote her.

That post of mine is what it is. I wrote it when there was both an opportunity and time to write it. I don't remember why I wrote what I wrote, except I felt self-conscious in making a wall post when I decided going into this game I wanted to move away from that style.

No, I am not scum for that or anything else.

He hasn't done anything to make me believe he's scum, so for the time being I believe he's town. After all, it's much more likely given the town to scum ratio.

Oh times have certainly changed, haven't they? But then Uber replaces in and you're all over trying to suck up to him. Makes the mind wonder.

And it's a lot more believable if I switch my vote to someone else, is it not?

To make what more believable, exactly?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Chrimi

Okay this post also makes me 100% sure Jal is scum.
First I wanted to attack Jal with a mix of good/bad reasons to see what people would say (scumbuddy reaction test, obv), but here's the real reason Jal is scum:

Has anyone else noticed that nearly EVERY question Jal asks is framed in a way to make someone else look scummy?

It's a common scum tactic of accusing someone of being scummy, BUT, doing it in question form so it doesn't look like an accusation. It hurts other people's opinions of the person being questioned, but also gives them a chance to "redeem" themselves. In other words, its the ultimate in wishy-washy half-accusations while at the same time appearing to look like genuine scumhunting (to the untrained eye, at least). So in a game with less experienced players, it kills two birds with one stone.

Go ahead, look through her ISO. I'm not making this shit up. Here are some selected quotes for your reading pleasure.

LH, why vote Arugula over the other people you had your eye on?

LH

: You admit to things we've found scummy about you. So What? Is that supposed to clear you in some way?

Hey Greywing. What's up with voting for everyone you think is scummily associated with Chrimi except for Chrimi himself?

Oh times have certainly changed, haven't they? But then Uber replaces in and you're all over trying to suck up to him. Makes the mind wonder.

Everyone, I will try to be more active and more pro town. Usually when I play, I play to survive and I never really scum hunted before. Weird, huh, considering that is what the game is about!

Have you only been scum or something?

Arugula, do you find it at all weird that you're on a bandwagon for someone for whom you think is scummy and is backed by the other players you indicated you wanted lynched?

Now ask yourself: Why would a townie make these posts?

So, my point stands that Jal is scum and needs to be lynched.

Today.

Vote Jal, everyone.

I certainly did frame some of my questions to make LH and Chrimi look bad - because I was voting for them for looking scummy for those reasons. The quotes containing questions for Blastoide and Arugula aren't accusations or attempts at accusing them. That Greywing's quote sure was though.

Now answer my question regarding Chrimi. What of his posts made him town in your books?

[Jal]

@LH - I still don't understand your suspicion of Gunny. Why did you vote for him?
@Rofl - You don't want to read walls. That's great. Answer my question regarding Greywing.

[UberNinja]

Can't tell you why Chrimi is town. But he is.

[UberNinja]

Actually, I'll tell you. It's because of his reactions to pressure by me. Obviously.

[Malakittens]

By Hyperion's horrid vote on me back in earlier of Day 1. It gave me scum vibes due to the fact he killed a reaction test I was doing against BK. When Shotty replaced in the whole read got flipped. I can't really read Shotty at this point, so, I'm going to give a null read atm, but slightly reading town.

As for Uber's case on Jal. I can see where you are going with it because it's in fact a great point, but I'm not certain if that makes him totally scummy. I have seen players of being town doing that exact thing and wind up being lynched for it. I'm hesitant to vote there.

Mod can you poke Shii? He disappeared.

[drmyshotgun]

VOTE: Jal
Deadline sheeping.

[UberNinja]

VOTE: Jal
Deadline sheeping.

bwahahahaha

yes

[Chrimi]

Chrimi is town as well btw.

What happened to this, Uber?

You are flip-flopping like crazy and besides the bad case on Jal, have given no reason for doing so.

[Chrimi]

Yes, it's fucking UberNinja, here to somehow know who the fuck is scum automatically <3

I like how Chrimi says this until I

point the finger at him

make a terrible case, and then all of a sudden I'm scum and terrible at the game.

Haha

[UberNinja]

What exactly is your question, Chrimi?

[Chrimi]

And you're still scum. Never said terrible at the game, you're GREAT as town.

Scum? Not so much.

VOTE: UberNinja

Make up your fucking mind, your flailing over nothing is confusing the shit outta me. Stop confusing everybody, that's anti-town.

[UberNinja]

That along with your other posts later saying I was scum and screaming to high heaven that I was wrong about you, are the exact reason I have a town read on you.

Just because it's useful info doesn't mean I can't laugh at how dissonant it sounds

[UberNinja]

p-edit: oh god Chrimi stop drinking the kool aid

[Chrimi]

Have I mentioned Chrimi and Shiidaji are scum together?

Because they are.

Ignore this post

I now have a

bank read of Chrimi-town.

Shiidaji could easily still be scum though.

I posted that before I saw this.

WHAT IS THIS?!

Is that an old post you had or something? :S

[UberNinja]

Read the thread first.

Then you are free to mouth off.

But only if you vote Jal.

[Chrimi]

Bleh.

I still don't get why you called me scum with Shiidaji.

I'm on the verge on voting him but... answer this question at least.

Why the fuck me and Shiidaji? And why did you go back on it so quickly?

[UberNinja]

Posts 67 and 189 reinforced you/Shiidaji.

I still think Shiidaji is probably scum. Very likely in fact.

Vote Jal now. Thanks.

[Chrimi]

Mmm...

I could see a Shiidaji and Jal scumteam, as well...

Alright
VOTE: Jal

By himself, I really don't think Shiidaji is scum. If Jal flips scum, it wouldn't bee too hard to believe Shiidaji is though.

[Chrimi]

Uber, you better not be misleading me as fuck, I've still got my eye on you >.>