Newbie 1356 (OVER)

[RadiantCowbells]

@Moderator, hey dawg, usually when a newbie game resumes I get a private message. I didn't get one in this instance so I didn't know the game was resumed.

Vote: Dexter

I currently suspect that Freezing is busing his partner but I am not entirely certain. Dexter, however, I am fairly sure about.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

This is me not voting and thus not being scum with RC, FH, or zoggoth.

[dexter9264]

FH "knows" I'm scum and RC is "fairly certain" that I'm scum.
Please give reasoning?

RC is starting to worry me a bit. It seems like he just jumps on whatever wagon is going on at the moment. I'm on my phone now, but once I get to a computer I'll look more into it.

DDDP is town. And there is definitely at least one scum in FH and RC

[freezing-hell]

Yup. So DDDP is definitely town. But RC definitely scum.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: RC

[freezing-hell]

No town would jump on that wagon, because A) No reasoning that I gave B) It would allow a quick hammer from scum that would win them the game.
Ergo, RC is 100% scum

[freezing-hell]

Oh - and that also kinda means that Zoggoth is the last scum, likely.

[dexter9264]

Goddamn was that all a test? Scared the crap out of me.

But yeah I still can't get to a computer. But in sure you guys get the idea. Just off the top of my head, I remember RC messing around D1, then D2 he just votes Mist after saying he "thought about it". I don't remember who RC was voting when Varsoon was lynched, but it's possible he could have hopped on to the likely wagons. And then this thing that just happened with RC jumping right on.

The fact that RC hopped on and there was no quicklynch means either FH and RC are both scum (I doubt it now that FH is seeming more and more town to me) or that RC and Zoggoth are scum. RCscum probably wanted to get a quicklynch in, except his scumbuddy Zoggoth didn't show.

[dexter9264]

Since we know DDDP is town, and I know I'm town, there's only really a few possibilities left.

FH and RC - I really doubt this is it. I just can't see a scum team doing something crazy like what's going on between FH and RC right now

FH and Zoggoth - it's possible but FH actually seems much more town to me after what he just did. And that would mean we have an idiot RCtown

RC and Zoggoth - this is the one I think it is. RC's scummyness and uselessness, along with Zoggoth's constant lurking. Also RC jumping on so that he and Zoggoth can quicklynch.

[freezing-hell]

Yeah. Okay. Dexter is obv town now as well. Hurray! We won in Lylo

[freezing-hell]

UNVOTE:
Just making sure. Dex, DDDP. You agree that atleast RC is scum?

[freezing-hell]

Goddamn was that all a test? Scared the crap out of me.

Yeah it was, sorry mate. What I did was really irresponsible though, and it could've cost us the game.

[dexter9264]

Yeah RC is definitely scum. There was absolutely no town motivation for his vote on me.

On the other hand, there is soooo much scum motivation. No matter who he's with there's scum motivation.

Lets say RC and DDDP are scum. RC's vote sets up the quicklynch.
Now if RC and Zoggoth are scum. RC's vote sets up the quicklynch again.
RC and FH are scum. They hope some dumbass town hammers when FH and RC give their evidence
RC and Dexter are scum. RC is bussing

Literally every single team with RC in it gives him a reason to vote.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

No town would jump on that wagon, because A) No reasoning that I gave B) It would allow a quick hammer from scum that would win them the game.
Ergo, RC is 100% scum

Your logic assumes a degree of competency from RC that I haven't seen established yet. It doesn't mean you're wrong but I'm not willing to assert that as fact without further analysis.

[Zoggoth]

@DDDP, it also assumes that RC expects me to actually post.

To be honest, I agree with Freezing Hell on RC's vote looking scummy, but I don't agree that it entirely clears Dexter of suspicion. If there was a Dexter/RC scum team, it could be argued that;
1. If Dexter is hammered, RC looks more town, and all he would have to do is work out who trusts them, and kill someone else.
2. FH switches and RC is lynched, Dexter is confirmed town in FH's eyes, making D4 a win for scum.

Some justification from RC for his vote would be really helpful right now.

[RadiantCowbells]

I explicitly said Dexter was my strongest scum read yesterday.

I am nearly positive at this point that the scumteam is FH + Dexter.

I am fine voting either of them.

[freezing-hell]

No you didn't.

I read DDDP and Dexter as most town. I would not support a lynch on either at this time, even to stop a NL.
I have a null read on Freezing-Hell and Zoggoth. I would prefer not to lynch either of those at this time, but they would be preferable to a NL.
I have a slight scumread on Mutley. I would support a lynch on him at this time if Mist is not getting lynched.
I read Mist7676 as most scum. I would (and am) support(ing) a lynch on her at this time.

[RadiantCowbells]

Right, right.

Mixed up mutley and etc.

Is this better?

Vote: Freezing-hell

[RadiantCowbells]

Actually I'm not going to do that.

Vote: Dexter

Confirmed scum.

Lynch him or me today.

[RadiantCowbells]

Note that Dexter is subtly making FH look townier to try to get the lynch onto me instead of him.

[dexter9264]

Note that Dexter is subtly making FH look townier to try to get the lynch onto me instead of him.

That's cause FH is town. No scum would do something as ridiculous as he did, and there was actually like no reason scum would take such a huge gambit when they're in lylo

Also you say you mixed us up, but what's written is written. Whether or not you truly did mix us up, you did not actually sy you thought I'm scum.

So I think the team is RC and Zoggoth. Zoggoth thinks its RC and me. Ish what DDDP thinks. And FH thinks its RC and Zoggoth? So really, even tho we may disagree on the actual team, we all agree RC is scum right?

[freezing-hell]

Confirmed scum.

How is he confirmed scum????????????

[dexter9264]

Ebwop: idk got autocorrected to ish. My bad

[RadiantCowbells]

If Dexter was town then he would know that FH voting him and me voting him means we both have to be scum.

[RadiantCowbells]

So, theoretically, you should be fine with a lynch on either of us. You claiming town is logically untenable with your claim that I am likely scum but FH isn't.

[freezing-hell]

If Dexter was town then he would know that FH voting him and me voting him means we both have to be scum.

This doesn't make sense.