Mafiascum.net

Cookie still won't acknowledge that the second miller claim is usually town and the first is usually scum.

In post 622, Chickadee wrote:Cookie's claim is provable. Doesn't prove him as town, but even if he is scum, we can use him and "get a shiny" out of it.

This isn't how you play the game Chickadee.

Okay, I'll accept that.

So, let's think about why. "Scum don't fakeclaim miller when there is already a claimed miller in the game" is your real premise, correct?

You didn't realise there was already a claimed miller in the game when you claimed miller.

Therefore that premise does not stand as a reason for why you are not scum.

In post 627, CookieDotJay wrote:Okay, I'll accept that.

So, let's think about why. "Scum don't fakeclaim miller when there is already a claimed miller in the game" is your real premise, correct?

You didn't realise there was already a claimed miller in the game when you claimed miller.

Therefore that premise does not stand as a reason for why you are not scum.

you don't fakeclaim miller without taking 5 seconds to be like hmm is there a miller claim in this game

I never said I'm not scum(although I'm not). I said he is scum. There is obviously no way to prove town on a miller other than gameplay since millers get a guilty result.

In post 626, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 622, Chickadee wrote:Cookie's claim is provable. Doesn't prove him as town, but even if he is scum, we can use him and "get a shiny" out of it.

This isn't how you play the game Chickadee.

So it's ok to leash a vig, but not an inventor.

Yea, ok.

And I think he probably did take those 5 seconds.

I think he was/is counting on people agreeing with him on this premise that he's working so hard to defend, and was fully aware that Tarkus had claimed when he did

Wow, that's a lot of WIFOM Cookie.

Or I could just be going by the premise that Miller's should instaclaim post 1. Way to try and damage my credibility.

That's exactly 1 unit of WIFOM, which is not a bad thing

WIFOM is definately a bad thing.

You're using it to dismiss an argument in a way that is not constructive at all, so sure. Well spotted. It's technically WIFOM. So is everything else in the whole of day 1

Why not try and find scum rather than save your own hide?

Well, I've found you, happily placed people who actually post, and I'm trying to save my own hide in the process.

Could you point me to a game where someone who got lynched day 1 had their reads sheeped the next day

In post 630, Chickadee wrote:

In post 626, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 622, Chickadee wrote:Cookie's claim is provable. Doesn't prove him as town, but even if he is scum, we can use him and "get a shiny" out of it.

This isn't how you play the game Chickadee.

So it's ok to leash a vig, but not an inventor.

Yea, ok.

Vig is nothing like inventing commuters and trackers T_T

You didn't find scum, you are being hyperreactive, which is much more scummy than anything I've done.

Define hyperreactive

I vote you 335, you vote me 352.

Oh so you think I omgused, okay. I thought this was gonna be about how I interact with other people in the game, for which see most of my other games.

Why is it about you rather than all the other people who joined my wagon after RC dropped that case? Heck, why not RC?

Oh and FTR that vote was at the time primarily for pressure while I placed you. I didn't really expect you to be scummy enough for me to park my vote there

So it was a token vote, and now you are token arguing with me, not arguing with me because I have done anything scummy.

That is not what I said at all nor is anything you just said the case

I'm going to bed unless you want to say something productive and new or go back to one of the conversation points you dropped when you didn't have an answer

Prod gotten, idk what's goin on rn but I'll be on late tonight or tomorrow morning. Promise

WELPPPPPPP

Yeah this is just a terrible game in general. no way that town wins. we could lynch scum and get a vig on scum and town would still end up losing this when I died.