Mafiascum.net

You guyyyyuuuuyyyyyyyyyyys

I know everyone's busy but we have to come to some sort of vote. We have like a day left to launch and no one's voting

nosferatu's tone has been pretty good this game, but I guess it's fakeable. Let's get r2r/Blair tomorrow if this flips green.
VOTE: nosferatu

I would rather launch r2r anyways

VOTE: Ready2rock

In post 627, midwaybear wrote:UNVOTE: /unvote]
VOTE: ready2rock
nosferatu doesn't feel like a good hang. Why is he scummy?

i cant be scum
my voting behavior around ydrasse spews town big time imo

thats why im so excited to see either r2r or bm give any semi-coherent reason that im scum

but i guess we're not gonna see it this day phase cause it seems like both are just gonna lurk til tmrw?

like bruh im not gonna deep dive but

In post 278, Battle Mage wrote:Scumpool
CantLynchAPuppy
Dunnstral
Ydrasse
Nosferatu**

lowkey random inclusion of ydrasse given their interactions previous to this post don't read like he has a scum read on ydrasse

In post 281, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 268, Ydrasse wrote:boring is just my personality i am sorry (and i haven't been giving games as much attention as i should have/could have this week)

also ngl reading this game feels like i'm looking at a blob of "meh" with a few light trs (hi inno, hi blair) thrown in there which makes parsing through it all feel like my brain is turning into goo. i don't know what that means mafia is doing other than either blending in or just... not playing right now which means we're all kind of half-heartedly pointing fingers at each other hoping something sticks.

that sentiment implicates nosferatu, dunn and r2r if going off of like, strictly numbers. of them i like nosferatu the most bc of that dunn/blair thing. i think r2r isn't look the best but i vibed with some of their points regarding bm thus the unvote. i don't think it's foolproof like they are town 100% of the time but i can follow their logic without having to twist and reach for it so i don't wanna vote them rn

i think i just want to vote dunn and see like. anything.

VOTE: dunnstral

In post 269, Nosferatu wrote:VOTE: ydrasse

High partner equity in Nosferatu-Dunnstral?

totally another random conclusion there maybe he thinks im chainsawing? idk

In post 282, Battle Mage wrote:Townblock assemble!

VOTE: Dunnstral

If he flips scum, Nosferatu tomorrow.

If he flips town, Ydrasse/Puppy tomorrow.

when ydrasse has same votes as dunn:

In post 309, Battle Mage wrote:we can do ydrasse tomorrow dude, need more dunn votes

why would we be voting ydrasse tmrw if he thinks dunn is scum following the above?

The tricky thing about this game is that I'd usually be looking for associatives between people in the game at this point, but we already have a flip so I can't do that as much.

I liked BM's responses to my push on him day 1, but I could be wrong. Nothing today really can give a read either way for me

Want to note since I haven't said much about puppy all game because he's been really tough for me to read this game. Hard neutral, and is a slot I'd definitely go back and iso day 3 (if I live that long)

My pool currently from most town to most scum is (trying to give some separation to demonstrate how strongly I'm reading in either direction)

- very tough for me to see this slot interacting with scumbuddy day 1 the way he did


- see above
- Been feeling pretty good about this slot all game. Still skeptical, but hasn't given me a reason to feel bad

- See above

- After my push on her I feel better. Still watching out, but not my top read anymore



- Very anti-town all game, and will feel pretty silly if we lose and he lives to the end. Blair probably had the best point against him, but hasn't been my top scumread, more anti-town

- Coming in a separate post, also want to look at these supposed pro-town interactions from day 1

OK, so the argument/case in Nosferatu’s favor on Day 1 wagons appears to be that the place that he jumped on the wagon day 1 would be inconvenient for a scumbuddy and carried the momentum towards the claim and elim.

However, this also came with no case, or pressure, or interaction with her of any kind, so I don’t think I buy it as a hard clear in the way that he seems to think. (go back and look for him interacting at all with her if you don't believe me, I don't see any aside from votes

Here are my two main points against him

In post 572, Nosferatu wrote:ya hes quivering in fear

already caught scum p much wrap it up

1) Keep in mind that at this point, I have votes on me and we are supposedly wanting to start to “wrap it up,” but then after that he’s still not wanting to vote me while still insisting that I am caught and confirmed scum, and instead:

In post 590, Nosferatu wrote:its ok ill wait as long as i need for u to publish ur scumpost magnum opus

In post 558, Nosferatu wrote:waiting for weekend to end so that battle mage can scumpost in his response so i dont have to scumhunt his ISO~~~

ready2rock wrote:Been quite torn between Blair and Dunn this whole day phase

i quite literally refuse to believe its not TvT given that dunn being scum would imply we wagoned both scum in d1 and even after being gone two years i dont have that much faith in the town meta of this site

2) The absolute insistence that over me, he’s pushing for someone that he’s too lazy to want to actually make a case on both indicates to me that he hasn’t been interested in actually scumhunting or attaching his name to a case

Say what you want about me this game, but I’ve at least been willing to give my perspective and put my cases out there, even when they haven’t been popular or gaining traction

i said this before i was being sarcastic in 572

What was 577 then? Why explain and follow up and clarifying that you think I'm the caught scum, but clarifying that you're being sarcastic about me being the caught scum?

lmao r u serious

ur so confident and yet totally wrong

i was calling u low hanging fruit

in 572 i was mocking the idea that u would try to run away from talking to blair like she was a fucking demon or something
in 577 i had to clarify i was talking abt u because u interpreted it as me talking abt bm
in 587 i made this even more obvious by saying having less posts was scummy bc u have one the lowest post counts

In post 633, ready2rock wrote:2) The absolute insistence that over me, he’s pushing for someone that he’s too lazy to want to actually make a case on both indicates to me that he hasn’t been interested in actually scumhunting or attaching his name to a case

this is literally such surface level thinking

There is a small part of me, in the deepest, darkest, most paranoid corner of my brain, that thinks that exchange sounded a lot like "Caught for the wrong reasons."

I didn't interpret 572 to be about BM, I interpreted 572 to be about me, and serious, and your opportunity to clarify, instead of explaining that you didn't scumread me or that you weren't being serious, your response was "no u r," which does not clarify anything.

As for 587, what exactly was the implication here? That someone was trying to make the case against me was wrong because they're saying I have low posts? Who was doing that? Do people use most/least posts to determine scum like that? Because I didn't see anyone doing that in this game at the very least

Is the implication that my 570 was bad and that I shouldn't be calling out lurkers? I think it was justified for where we were at in the day, plus you're using it to call out BM right now (saying that he and I are going to lurk until deadline)? And if you thought my 570 was bad, midway did too, and you're claiming to be mocking him for it, so that doesn't make sense either

lurking != low post count

it truly is not that serious bro i cant be lieve u wrote a whole paragraph pretending to understand a troll post

ik that it wasnt that intense cause mafia goon picked up on the sarcasm bro

i bet u dont even use emojis

Nosferatu is a bad wagon imo

We're running near deadline

In post 645, Umlaut wrote:

Kerset replaces Battle Mage.

big shoes to fill

What's the case on Blair? Just that you didn't like the way she pushed you? That sorta seems like OMGUS...

can the rest of the town come to play ?

preferably to vote battlemage