Mafiascum.net

In post 624, InsidiousLemons wrote:and

do you really think that emphatically suggesting a replacement read the thread is AtE?

they come in here saying they're going to coast (which is also how they started off the last game i played with them) and

trying multiple times to piggyback off of others' opinions

. how am i supposed to react?

In post 620, Ivyeo wrote:

In post 619, Umlaut wrote:

In post 573, humaneatingmonkey wrote:

In post 569, Umlaut wrote:Eww.

Is this a policy lynch? Or you think this was a scummy reaction?

I missed this question. Yes, I think it's a scummy reaction to respond to suspicion of oneself with "but why aren't you suspicious of these other people who did something similar?" It reads like scum indignant about being accused based on what they consider insufficient evidence.

Honestly I agree with this. I haven't really liked much from them this whole game.
VOTE: Gera

In post 621, InsidiousLemons wrote:sorry, i thought it was customary to read the thread on a replace-in. it's 25 pages dude, just put in even a modicum of effort and form your own opinions instead of trying to tie yourself to me right out the gate

In post 626, bugspray wrote:wait did vfp really imply that someone else implied that suggesting someone actually read the thread is appeal to emotion?

In post 629, geraintm wrote:i say i hate day 1s
i just want to move to day 2

In post 635, VFP wrote:

In post 629, geraintm wrote:i say i hate day 1s
i just want to move to day 2

I like Gera here.
I too want day 2!

UNVOTE: Gera

In post 527, humaneatingmonkey wrote:im now thinking you're town, gerain

In post 545, Egix96 wrote:268 from Anya feels like a towny thought, but 46 gives me the heebie jeebies. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

In post 551, humaneatingmonkey wrote:

In post 548, Egix96 wrote:You vs osuka just feels like a slapfight over something I don't understand. Apologies if there's something big I'm missing but yeah.

This is very premature, and I wonder if this is because I'm annoyed. However, I have the impression that osuka seems to be intentionally being obtuse as I argue that Lemons could be scum. If it was town!osuka, it would be explained that he has Lemons as "conftown". But it's super early in the game, and Lemons being scum is still a possibility. This is highly irregular for me. There's also that "slip" where he said gerains is a mislynch. Although, I'm not the kind of guy that puts much value to that on its own. It just doesn't seem to have a town perspective when I was having that back-to-back with him.

In post 563, humaneatingmonkey wrote:

In post 560, InsidiousLemons wrote:now me not voting gerain is bad because he's a viable wagon. i disagree that a wagon being active is a good reason to put another vote onto it, all other things being equal. this is inconsistency

gerain being a viable wagon is evidence that you would have had good information on your scum suspect by pressing more on that slot. so, your vote there would have been a good option for you NOT MY SLOT who you have previously given "towncred" for. it's not inconsistent. it's the same assertion.

In post 576, humaneatingmonkey wrote:so... your reason for not taking it more into account is that it's impossible to sort him anyway? or do you just don't believe that it's a reliable scumtell in general?