In post 624, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:@furtive, what do you think about what Enchant is suggesting? Do you think Ff should out but obviously NOT claim targets?
I’m seriously reconsidering switching my vote to Porkens. But first, I want to hear more discussion about what Enchant is suggesting.
Are you in favour of ff outing or you think it’s best that they stay hidden? I haven’t yet made up my mind on that, so I want to hear opinions on that other than Enchant’s.
If Porkens is Firefighter, yeah say that. Otherwise I'm tunnelled as hell!
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 8:25 am
by Enchant
In post 624, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:@furtive, what do you think about what Enchant is suggesting? Do you think Ff should out but obviously NOT claim targets?
I’m seriously reconsidering switching my vote to Porkens. But first, I want to hear more discussion about what Enchant is suggesting.
Are you in favour of ff outing or you think it’s best that they stay hidden? I haven’t yet made up my mind on that, so I want to hear opinions on that other than Enchant’s.
In post 624, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:@furtive, what do you think about what Enchant is suggesting? Do you think Ff should out but obviously NOT claim targets?
I’m seriously reconsidering switching my vote to Porkens. But first, I want to hear more discussion about what Enchant is suggesting.
Are you in favour of ff outing or you think it’s best that they stay hidden? I haven’t yet made up my mind on that, so I want to hear opinions on that other than Enchant’s.
If Porkens is Firefighter, yeah say that. Otherwise I'm tunnelled as hell!
I think the same should probably apply to Ircher as well and maybe Scrrrrbear but haven’t made up my mind on that yet. I think that could be a reasonable compromise. I don’t think ff should claim if they are not amongst those three.
In post 624, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:@furtive, what do you think about what Enchant is suggesting? Do you think Ff should out but obviously NOT claim targets?
I’m seriously reconsidering switching my vote to Porkens. But first, I want to hear more discussion about what Enchant is suggesting.
Are you in favour of ff outing or you think it’s best that they stay hidden? I haven’t yet made up my mind on that, so I want to hear opinions on that other than Enchant’s.
What YOU think
Just answered. My current PoE is Ircher/Porkens/Scrrrbear and I think if any of those are ff, particularly Ircher or Porkens, I’m in favour. If ff is ANYONE ELSE, I think they should probably relain hidden, since I have no intention of voting for anyone today not in those three.
I don’t think it helps us for ff to out if they are not amongst Ircher/Porkens/Scrrrbear. Main reason for them to out is that we don’t accidentally miselim them and we aren’t going to lim anyone else, soif if it’s not in those three, arsonists don’t really need to know who it is.
As you already pointed out, ff shouldn’t claim targets which obviously goes without saying and just puts an unnecessary target on their back, so I would advise ff to claim if they’re getting run up. Ff doesn’t have better reads than trees, so I don’t see how it’s helpful for ff to out if they’re not at risk of being miselimed.
This is wise. @furtive, I don’t understand why you’re trying to rush the vote?
Vanders, Scrrrbear, Ircher and Herta haven’t even posted yet. What if you’re wrong? You were on Pooky in LOST. I think Porkens is pretty scummy but not enough to ram a lim through before everyone has even gotten a chance to post.
This is wise. @furtive, I don’t understand why you’re trying to rush the vote?
Vanders, Scrrrbear, Ircher and Herta haven’t even posted yet. What if you’re wrong? You were on Pooky in LOST. I think Porkens is pretty scummy but not enough to ram a lim through before everyone has even gotten a chance to post.
Don't have to ram it through, but I'm not changing
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 8:59 am
by Don Draper x Mistress
That’s fine, I’m not opposed. I just want to hear from everyone and not rush the day. Remember there are txo arsonists and it would be awesome to catch both today and that’s why we need to hear from ideally EVERYONE.
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 9:09 am
by Don Draper x Mistress
To be extremely clear if Enchant looks to be in any danger, I will ram it through because he is so obviously not arsonist.
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 9:19 am
by Porkens
Oh really? Why such a strong read? I don’t like their posting style this game
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 9:21 am
by Don Draper x Mistress
In post 640, Porkens wrote:Oh really? Why such a strong read? I don’t like their posting style this game
Why what makes them scummy to you?
And what are your thoughts on furtive pushing you and what Enchant said about Ff?
In post 259, Titus wrote:Scum will favor lurker pushes here. Lurkers are more likely to give up if miseliminated. Only if scum can't get a lurker will they push active people. Hence why I FoS Bear there.
Do you think Scrrrdbear 'couldn't get' Enchant/Porkens? I'm still voting Porkens
Not without yelling and dominating.
There's also the fact that Enchant is obvtown.
Do you really expect Bear to be able to push a case where little to no evidence exists and there's meta evidence for town Enchant?
Porkens might be an easier sell but still would require a dramatic shift.
Third, hard pushing a lurker might draw them to play. Scum want lurkers to lurk.
Titus said she was obvtown reading that slot, yet you vote him and reference Titus, why? Does it not concern you at all, that you are literally the only player pushing Enchant?
In post 259, Titus wrote:Scum will favor lurker pushes here. Lurkers are more likely to give up if miseliminated. Only if scum can't get a lurker will they push active people. Hence why I FoS Bear there.
Do you think Scrrrdbear 'couldn't get' Enchant/Porkens? I'm still voting Porkens
Not without yelling and dominating.
There's also the fact that Enchant is obvtown.
Do you really expect Bear to be able to push a case where little to no evidence exists and there's meta evidence for town Enchant?
Porkens might be an easier sell but still would require a dramatic shift.
Third, hard pushing a lurker might draw them to play. Scum want lurkers to lurk.
Titus said HE was obvtown reading that slot, yet you vote him and reference Titus, why? Does it not concern you at all, that you are literally the only player pushing Enchant?
In post 622, Enchant wrote:Firefigher should claim and lead town as conftown. His "protections" are unneeded now.
It's likely that FF was doused anyway. I am not sure how gasolines view me, but they probably didn't douse me either (i would't honestly).
And i am not FF
. Therefore, it raises chances that FF is already doomed and should claim for atleast some benefit.
Any late, and arsos probably counterclaim/win already.
I don't think this is pro-town but I like you doing this
Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2022 10:57 am
by Vanderscamp
In post 624, Don Draper x Mistress wrote:@furtive, what do you think about what Enchant is suggesting? Do you think Ff should out but obviously NOT claim targets?
I’m seriously reconsidering switching my vote to Porkens. But first, I want to hear more discussion about what Enchant is suggesting.
Are you in favour of ff outing or you think it’s best that they stay hidden? I haven’t yet made up my mind on that, so I want to hear opinions on that other than Enchant’s.
I don't think we really need it to happen, I don't think we're so uncoordinated that we won't be able to come together unanimously to kill someone without a confirmed town, partially because I think you're very town and I agree with you that I want to kill Ircher.
I don't think it's a guarantee that FF has been doused yet and I'd rather reduce the information the scum team gets regarding whether they should douse tonight.