In post 2244, Dunnstral wrote:I think it will be more clear whether we've received a benefit when we know more about the event.
so you'd default to gamma being exempt from duel to determine after if we've received benefit?
hm, i think this makes some sense, though if gamma is a scums that leaves only 3 for us to hit 2 within with other choices
Putting my thoughts on gamma aside:
If we wanted to eliminate him, we had a chance to do so. We didn't take it. It's nonsense to try to eliminate him again using a seperate game mechanic, it would mean we wasted power
In post 6320, Taly wrote:Point 1- What do you make of their kingmaker choice then?
i thought way they reacted to pooky dieing without missing a beat or factoring into further decisions was ??? like I said at the time
trying to weigh gammagooey alignment off of unsure gamma emerald alignment for all of this feels not a good task to try to undertake because could easily see reasoning for choosing town or scum
In post 6320, Taly wrote:Point 4- I'm failing to see the significance of Toog-town being part of the duel relates to Gamma's alignment.
if gamma emerald is town, we were supposed to get benefit from sparing them, so if we can identify very likely benefit, then gamma emerald likely town, if no benefit, then scum, so trying to find benefit worthwhile though pretty defeating process because like, it’s meant to be somewhat hidden but the ones i can find aren’t even really benefits so probably aren’t it
I'd agree with this but I have no clue where to begin to trying to decipher what the benefit was. It was not meant to be clear to town. Do you have ideas?
In post 2244, Dunnstral wrote:I think it will be more clear whether we've received a benefit when we know more about the event.
so you'd default to gamma being exempt from duel to determine after if we've received benefit?
hm, i think this makes some sense, though if gamma is a scums that leaves only 3 for us to hit 2 within with other choices
Putting my thoughts on gamma aside:
If we wanted to eliminate him, we had a chance to do so. We didn't take it. It's nonsense to try to eliminate him again using a seperate game mechanic, it would mean we wasted power
GE is hammered for heaven now
let's send Uly to Hell next to ensure there's no wiggling out
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 5:30 am
by ulyana
traine le bruit dans l’espace
en premier sur la bande-son du promethee
le vautour dans la gorge
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 6:09 am
by petapan
i see your concerns with regard to gamma but i don't want to flip him this phase
i will look into it if the game is hard and my immediate targets turn out to be incorrect
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 6:44 am
by SirCakez
it doesn't even matter Gamma is already hammered to Heaven
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 6:52 am
by petapan
i guess that was bad wording but i wouldn't have wanted to even if we didn't send him
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 7:55 am
by Taly
jumps on peta's back and waits to be carried.
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 8:22 am
by Gamma Emerald
In post 6329, Taly wrote:Gamma, did Pooky's death factor in your Ceph shot?
Not really, I was highly averse to just picking something I thought was shady but hadn’t had a chance to examine through questioning and the leads that pulled up were not ones that felt worth acting on without that due process. And I think Ulyana is twisting things a bit because her questioning back when that was all happening did not feel organic at all, honestly it felt like she was in on the kill and used that to browbeat me for being slow to come to the conclusion I did.
In post 6329, Taly wrote:Gamma, did Pooky's death factor in your Ceph shot?
Not really, I was highly averse to just picking something I thought was shady but hadn’t had a chance to examine through questioning and the leads that pulled up were not ones that felt worth acting on without that due process. And I think Ulyana is twisting things a bit because her questioning back when that was all happening did not feel organic at all, honestly it felt like she was in on the kill and used that to browbeat me for being slow to come to the conclusion I did.
……………..
……………………………..
as if my team killing pooky there wouldn’t have always been because i was outvoted on the choice
In post 6329, Taly wrote:Gamma, did Pooky's death factor in your Ceph shot?
Not really, I was highly averse to just picking something I thought was shady but hadn’t had a chance to examine through questioning and the leads that pulled up were not ones that felt worth acting on without that due process. And I think Ulyana is twisting things a bit because her questioning back when that was all happening did not feel organic at all, honestly it felt like she was in on the kill and used that to browbeat me for being slow to come to the conclusion I did.
……………..
……………………………..
as if my team killing pooky there wouldn’t have always been because i was outvoted on the choice
like why would i be looking to kill pooky there…
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 10:22 am
by ulyana
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 11:59 am
by Gamma Emerald
Why wouldn’t you
He was townread, he was active, he was seemingly quite savvy to scum’s tactics
Who would
you
have voted to kill?
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:03 pm
by Morning Tweet
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:04 pm
by Morning Tweet
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:10 pm
by ulyana
In post 6342, Gamma Emerald wrote:Why wouldn’t you
He was townread, he was active, he was seemingly quite savvy to scum’s tactics
Who would
you
have voted to kill?
because pooky likes to muse about setup speculation and share music and is familiar with me and was townreading me and generally makes the game far more enjoyable for me to play regardless of alignment
like, if i were scum pooky would obviously have been valuable vehicle for me to involve myself in the game through right? and also keeps me engaged my making game less miserable
i don’t know who else is scum so it’s hard to say who i would have killed
but to say you think i likely had a hand in killing pooky is pretty ridiculous
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:17 pm
by Gammagooey
Gonna be voting peta into heaven as the final one there
Ulyana no matter what two town players have to go into hell because math - if you have a specific opinion/case you want to state on who you think is most likely scum I think that'd be a lot more helpful at this point than towncasing yourself.
Ulyana no matter what two town players have to go into hell because math - if you have a specific opinion/case you want to state on who you think is most likely scum I think that'd be a lot more helpful at this point than towncasing yourself.
I concur on both points.
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:25 pm
by ulyana
In post 6346, Gammagooey wrote:Ulyana no matter what two town players have to go into hell because math - if you have a specific opinion/case you want to state on who you think is most likely scum I think that'd be a lot more helpful at this point than towncasing yourself.
i think i’ve been pretty open about this -
like i just compiled thoughts on gamma emerald,
sircakez/tamora’s angel/gamma emerald/taly in that order probably,
gamma emerald plus equity with sircakez and taly,
ydrasse plus equity with petapan though peta objects to this and is smarter than me,
like i don’t feel 100% about anything
like you say this to me and it is like, have i been unclear about who i think the most likely mafia are? because i feel like i have talked about a lot
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2021 12:31 pm
by ulyana
actually i’d probably switch gamma emerald and tamora’s angel in the order at this point
