Thoguh it was "policy lynch" which was unsuccessful.
No one asked me about Lelouch's thought of alignment beforehand.
Wishes-I-Can-BSlap: Mb53
I did not say he was scum for lurking.. Did I?
Ahoy, I thought scum wouldn't look that scummy.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 10:57 am
by mb53
Tragedy wrote:I did not say he was scum for lurking.. Did I?
Here you go:
Thil wrote:what else do you actually have on me to call me scum?
Tragedy wrote:@Thil: Just the lurking.
_____________________________
Tragedy wrote:No one asked me about Lelouch's thought of alignment beforehand.
You can only comment on THE BIGGEST THING THAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE GAME when other people ask you to?
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 10:59 am
by Tragedy
Calling him scummm... Right.
Calling ON him due to lurking.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 11:02 am
by mb53
Tragedy wrote:I finally made my decision that Espeonage > mb53 > Thil
Here is another place where you call him scum.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 11:05 am
by mb53
And if that isn't calling him scum (which it is), why do you think he is town?
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 11:06 am
by Tragedy
I did not say he was town either.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 11:12 am
by GhostWriter
Tragedy wrote:Thoguh it was "policy lynch" which was unsuccessful.
No one asked me about Lelouch's thought of alignment beforehand.
Oh, cut all that crap out. You called him scummy. Multiple times. You remarked about how he was going to die when he "defended" himself. You did everything a person would do when voting someone they find scummy, except actually voting him. If you thought it was a policy lynch, you really stayed off it after all that admission him being scummy? Noted. So happy when you flip red.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 12:17 pm
by Dekes
GhostWriter wrote:And don't give me this shit about needing to answer about my town reads.
Except I don't condemn anyone on the Lelouch wagon for being on it. And I commited to the wagon by commenting on it.
Your play on the other hand reeks of "I told you so" in case, Espeonage ever does in fact flip town without having ever to justify your town read afterwards. You just casually commented on Espeonage, the biggest wagon at the time (four days since the last vote count, geeze), calling him most likely town without any indication why and then continued to refuse to give a reason even after multiple people asked you several times and instead you deflect onto other persons. I take it, you think, mb is most likely town as well?
Fine, I'll cave. I'd be down with lynching Tragedy first. But not before everyone is caught up. I don't want another lynch with half the people not having expressed their actual and up-to-date opinion.
And one more thing, the fact that so many people are looking only at Tragedy (even if she brought most of it on herself) on nowhere else today will make this wagon a juicy one to look back at on Day 3.
Kadersalad wrote:
Bunnylover wrote:I'm here and glad that their is only 25 pages that I have to read .
Don't Worry, I gave up along time ago.
Will we still be graced with your opinions on the game?
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 12:20 pm
by Dekes
@Bunny
Don't comment on Lelouch and whether you agree with his lynch or not. It won't net you any brownie points. If you want to talk about the Lelouch-wagon talk about the people on and off it. Lelouch is dead and has flipped, there's no need to give your read on him and it won't give us any info.
- 6 - Pinky and the Brain , SSBF, thil13, mb53, Ythan, GhostWriter - (L-4)
Xtoxm
- 1 - Espeonage - (L-9)
danakillsu
- 1 - Bunnylover - (L-9)
Players not voting:Kadersalad, Lucresia
Deadline is May 5th at 10:30 EDT.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 12:45 pm
by GhostWriter
Dekes wrote:I take it, you think, mb is most likely town as well?
Yep.
Fine, I'll cave. I'd be down with lynching Tragedy first. But not before everyone is caught up. I don't want another lynch with half the people not having expressed their actual and up-to-date opinion.
Agreed.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 1:13 pm
by Tragedy
GhostWriter wrote:
Dekes wrote:I take it, you think, mb is most likely town as well?
Yep.
...And why?
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 1:24 pm
by Bunnylover
Dekes wrote:@Bunny
Don't comment on Lelouch and whether you agree with his lynch or not. It won't net you any brownie points. If you want to talk about the Lelouch-wagon talk about the people on and off it. Lelouch is dead and has flipped, there's no need to give your read on him and it won't give us any info.
That what I'm doing, which is why I have scum vibes on Dana and TMH because of their involvement in Lelouch-wagon.
TMH pushed it like extremely hard, scum not wanting to surrender their perfect mislynch.
Dana for voting for that percentage comment.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 2:09 pm
by thil13
Every time I see a catch up post from a replacement, I always see somebody calling it scummy. Would someone answer why that is for me? It doesn't really make sense to me...
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 2:21 pm
by GhostWriter
Immediate pressure to gauge reaction and build/solidify reads.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 2:29 pm
by thil13
so it's just a psychological ploy
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 2:53 pm
by Ythan
My laptop might finally be through. I'm at the library now, and I might be stuck with this/stat class.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 3:02 pm
by GhostWriter
thil13 wrote:so it's just a psychological ploy
No. It's the game. Half the time, it's serious questioning. But not always. They weren't there for much of what the rest of the players went through, they have a fresh, sort of "outsider looking in" mentality to it. Helps put the game back into perspective.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 4:52 pm
by Espeonage
Another Prod dodge. Will get to MS in a day or two.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 9:52 pm
by RedCoyote
P&tB 586 wrote:
SO MAKE A GODDAMN VOTE.
Yeah, Tragedy, it's pretty silly to not be voting anyone at this point, especially when you made it clear that you have suspects who deserve it.
---
GW 614 wrote:Tragedy is attempting to pass off lurking as a major scumtell when it actually isn't.
In relation to whom? Espeonrage?
Does this mean you're not comfortable with the wagon on Espeonrage?
---
I really like SSBF's post 617. This is a nice summation on the case against Tragedy. Enough so that I'm willing to throw my weight behind this wagon over Espeonrage's.
---
thil 663 wrote:Every time I see a catch up post from a replacement, I always see somebody calling it scummy. Would someone answer why that is for me? It doesn't really make sense to me...
What do you not understand? lewarcher and SSBF were both pretty clear in their criticisms.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 11:48 pm
by thil13
It's not just this game though, I've seen it in other games and I'm wondering if there is any point in having one if people are just going to call you scummy for it.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2011 5:53 am
by crazypianist1116
Hey guys sorry I haven't been around. Easter took up some time and schoolwork has been getting really difficult.
This game however is stalling and I'm breaking bloc to unstall it. UNVOTE: VOTE: Tragedy
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2011 6:54 am
by lewarcher82
Tragedy wrote:
Calling him scummm... Right.
Calling ON him due to lurking.
this post is ridiculous.
Tragedy, basically you *never* defended Lelouch, but you opposed the wagon on him. You voted thil for lurking but you *never* stated it was his lurking that makes him scummy to you... When I read this post of yours, I was actually laughing irl.
Ythan wrote:
danakillsu wrote:@ Bunnylover
Let me just ask you this. Reading Lelouch's iso, what do you think was scummy about him? I of course realize that Lelouch was town, but tell me in detail where you think the scumtells were. It might shed some light on my supposedly terrible vote.
Um are you asking BL to explain your vote for you?
I like this post by Ythan. It's the closest thing to goodposting he did so far, and dana *is* scummy.
mb53 wrote:So much scum in this game that need to die... adding bunny to my list, catchup post full of fluff and useless information
Tragedy wrote:@Mb53: Where did the strong scum read on me come from?
Ok, case ahoy!
Spoiler: Page by page case
Page 1-2: RVSness
Page 3: fluff.
Page 4: Still RVS tunneling
Page 5: Clarifies that her vote on DBE is still RVS
(notice that you are doing
nothing
while everyone else is actually contributing?
Page 6: OMG A GAME RELEVANT POST (sort of). Says that lelouch shouldn't play newb card.
Page 7: casts slight suspicion of lew
Page 8: Still says that she wants her RVS vote on DBE
Page 9:
Page 10: Votes lurker and tells him to contribute (lol)
Page 11: Woohoo, actually gives a legitimate scum read (on dana) (took you long enough)
Page 12: Clarifies that the only reason thil is scum is lurking (really, thats all you got?)
Page 13:
Page 14:
Page 15: Responds to suspicion with "Love you, hoppster <3"
Page 16:
Page 17:
Page 18: Says that town should have lynched the lurker rather than the suspicious person (lol)
Page 19: Says that she thought it was clear lelouch was town VI rather than scum (COUGH COUGH, AFTER THE LYNCH)
Page 20: Calls espeonage out for not defending lelouch more before the lynch (COUGH COUGH, PAGE 19)
Page 21: Says that newbies should defend themselves (lol page 20)
Page 22: Casts suspicion on crazy (still no vote)
Page 23: Says that she wants to pressure thil into posting (still no vote?)
Page 24: FINALLY VOTES espeonage
for not saying why he thought lelouch was town earlier
to sheep voting block
TL;DR
TRagedy is doing pretty much nothing: trying to get by voting lurkers for not contributing (Har har, hypocrite), sheeps voting bloc using meh/hypocritical reasons. Also voting DBE early game was bad.
finally mb53 is back, with a case. It's not like this is a case with a lot of new content, but it's better than he did so far... Question for you, mb53: were you really surprised when trag said lelouch was obvtown on page 19? Did you think she thought he was scum?
----
@crazypianist: I believe Tragedy and Espeo are both scum. I also think that if Espeo dies first, tomorrow we will have a lot to work with, because Tragedy posted and will post more
content
words so far, while Espeo is very avoidant... I would still pick Espeo first.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2011 7:27 am
by GhostWriter
RedCoyote wrote:
GW 614 wrote:Tragedy is attempting to pass off lurking as a major scumtell when it actually isn't.
In relation to whom? Espeonrage?
Does this mean you're not comfortable with the wagon on Espeonrage?
Her most used "scumtell" has been lurking. She makes big deals about it. Espeonage is simply the most recent case. I meant in general.
But, no, I do not like the Espeonage wagon. I disagree with it, as stated before.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2011 8:35 am
by Tragedy
GhostWriter wrote:Immediate pressure to gauge reaction and build/solidify reads.
Uh huh.
Sounds like he's been saying I wa scum since day One then comes back Day Two with his case which has nothing new on it but just plain arguing with me to look town, which mostly involves proving my thoughts wrong with contradictions.
Mostly because of lurking an some ignorance.
Ahoy, why did one post of thil is meant to be townie but he just does some OMGUS apart from the pressuring to get active and some bluffs and truths..
Also..
.