Mafiascum.net

Looking back, you are right. I confused PV with silavor.

So does that change your conclusions?

Cirno wrote:Is it the antelope thing? I don't care about the antelope thing.

Why not?

>So does that change your conclusions?
It invalidates my complaints about ek's silavor case.

>why not?
Just to make sure I'm not confusing things again, we are talking about vezok claiming antelope, and then [insert name of deceased here] flipping antelope and town, thereby confirming vezok as town, right? I just don't think it is a stretch to assume antelope would be the town role in a game with this theme.

But how do you feel about Silavor himself?
b

Cirno wrote:>So does that change your conclusions?
It invalidates my complaints about ek's silavor case.

So you acknowledge that EK's Silavor case was based on something else. How do you feel about the actual case?

Cirno wrote:>why not?
Just to make sure I'm not confusing things again, we are talking about vezok claiming antelope, and then [insert name of deceased here] flipping antelope and town, thereby confirming vezok as town, right? I just don't think it is a stretch to assume antelope would be the town role in a game with this theme.

Fair enough, though I think it's unlikely.

>But how do you feel about Silavor himself?
I still think he is town.

>So you acknowledge that EK's Silavor case was based on something else. How do you feel about the actual case?
I don't think it is an outright misrepresentation anymore and no longer have a reason to attack it. That said, I disagree
with the bits concerning the slip and don't care about the rest.

Cirno,

How do you feel about a player (silavor) who says they were acting scummy on purpose to catch scum?

Can you buy that as a legitimate strategy?

From recollection, silavor said he was stupid posting to find scum and I think that is different from acting scummy to find scum. As I don't find silavor's posts particularly scummy, I am not particularly bothered by the claim.

How is stupid posting different from acting scummy? Clearly we all found his "stupidposting" scummy enough to wagon him.

>How is stupid posting different from acting scummy?
In one case, one is posting stupidly. In the other, one is posting like scum. For an example of the former, see DK.
>Clearly we all found his "stupidposting" scummy enough to wagon him
Your opinion has nothing to do with mine.

So you believe he was stupidposting on purpose as a plan?

@Cirno: Why exactly do you believe pacman, vezo, and Elvis are scummy?

What exactly is your read of Silavor? Do you believe his plan was to catch scum?

EBWOP: Sorry, you gave a read on Silavor. Ok Cirno, instead, why do you believe Silavor is town?

You are so scum.

vezokpiraka wrote:

unvote
vote silavor

You are so scum.

It seems like he is the best lynch right now, but deadline isn't there yet.



I wonder what he would do when he gets on, if I was him I would claim.

I'm nowhere near L-1.

Why would I claim?

L-2 is pretty close to L-1. I think. I haven't played many games so I could be wrong about that.

HEY WHILEIM HEAR LETS GET SHIT DONE

LlamaFluff wrote:

He was always such a peaceful critter, maybe not the most gifted in the world, but peaceful nevertheless. Now he is gone.

PeregrineV - Antelope - Townie - Scavenged Day One

Random…there are so many other better targets. This telsl us little to nothing.

GreyICE wrote:Or I said it's a good shot because killing a lurker with less posts than I have is solid play for a vig? Hate hero vigs who decide that they will kill all the scum no one can touch, and kill all the obvtownies.

Vote: Fate

why was his opinion worth a vote? was it scummy?

Flavour Analysis wrote:
Anyways, now Vezo and Pacman are semi-cleared.

how? (edit: answered in 608)

Llamarble wrote:That kill felt really random.
I don't think Fate's town.
VOTE: Fate

I should probably justify my reads at some point.

you are providing little content...please stop..why is this play pro-town?

Seacore wrote:Not really happy with the target of that kill but then again, I'm really only skimming this game. Still happy with where my vote is.

why are you happy with your vote if you are skimming? this post seems fluffy and has a weak justification.

DeityKabuto wrote:

Seacore wrote:Not really happy with the target of that kill but then again, I'm really only skimming this game. Still happy with where my vote is.

Do you or anybody have an idea of who might have vigged the guy?

strange question. what is the purpose of it and why did you direct it at seacore?

elvis_knits wrote:Hey Hez, Silavor is scum.

if I didnt think you were town, I would question why you are pandering to Hez.

Llamarble wrote:VOTE: Cirno

I would also be okay with a wagon on Llanarble

Finding the Amrun/EK/Cirno exchange interesting….good questioning.

Fate wrote:HEY WHILEIM HEAR LETS GET SHIT DONE

UNVOTE
VOTE: SILAVOR

claim time.

Sorry, I suck sometimes until I find the pulse of a game, if that makes any sense.

Tempted to just quickhammer Silavor before he fakeclaims. "I was purposely stupidposting" reminds me of BGG, except Silavor is not bgg.
Why purposely stupidpost?
That wall smells of scumwall. Grey why is he town again?
Sketchy wagon should count against him not for him since if there aren't CWs scum are likely bussing.

Zel1nk is town.

ZeL1nK wrote:also pacman is town

Is a 3 minute later addendum to a post.
Feels like a real observation rather than something scum would fake when they weren't already planning to.

Well then.

Llamarble wrote:Tempted to just quickhammer Silavor before he fakeclaims.

Hope I didn't steal your thunder.

DA FUCK?!

Smh