In fact now that I look closer at it I wonder why you didn’t say “you can die, scum”.
Why the urgency to change your vote upon replacing in? Were you fully caught up with the game?
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 2:25 am
by GuyInFreezer
Yeah that was supposed to be L-1 vote.
Later I realized that Mac voted him too.
I love how you're not even considering my "case" on A_Stone.
Anyway, keep talking. I'm outing my report when time comes.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 2:44 am
by GuyInFreezer
and no, by that time I only read late d1 and d2.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 2:47 am
by goodmorning
Well who was right about Stone?
That's right, IT WAS ME EVERYBODY. Nobody else, JUST ME. I don't even care that I was wrong about Mac, this feels really good and I think Mr E is still Scum.
Still haven't worked up a case though, for personal reasons.
@GIF: Why do you give a shit what Mr E thinks about your wrong cases and why, if you are what you seem to be implying you are, haven't you just outed "your report" already? This is LyLo.
@2: What are your feelings about RC?
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 2:51 am
by GuyInFreezer
Because the hammervote is the only thing he is addressing + LyLo.
Uh, I feel like this game has been kind of turned on its head. GIF, you mentioned you had a report? That's kind of a big deal at this point. I suspect you investigated goodmorning, yes? That's the only real suspect I have left here is why I am pressing for it now. If goodmorning is innocent, then I really need to read over the entire game again.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 3:52 am
by goodmorning
You still think I'm Scum? Yawn. I realise my play has been underwhelming this game, but really, so has yours.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 4:02 am
by RedCoyote
Don't give me that weak stuff, goodmorning. I think your game has primarily consisted of asking everyone else questions instead of providing serious analysis of your own creation.
I would not classify my play as underwhelming. Perhaps I have not been accurate in all my predictions, but I've at least given it an honest try. And I'm certainly not guilty of coming into the game on D3 bragging about calling one dead player correctly as town. I mean, what do you expect to get credit for in that? You know who else can brag about predicting alignments correctly? Scum. Because they know all the alignments. So it's certainly not beyond goodmorning to see a strong wagon forming on AS during D2 and position herself against it knowing that it will flip town.
Again, all this is potentially moot based on what GIF has to say, but my initial read coming into today is I have strong townreads on GIF and MER, a somewhat safe townread on ², and a scumread on you.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 6:37 am
by goodmorning
In post 669, RedCoyote wrote:Don't give me that weak stuff, goodmorning. I think your game has primarily consisted of asking everyone else questions instead of providing serious analysis of your own creation.1
I would not classify my play as underwhelming.2 Perhaps I have not been accurate in all my predictions, but I've at least given it an honest try.3 And I'm certainly not guilty of coming into the game on D3 bragging about calling one dead player correctly as town.4 I mean, what do you expect to get credit for in that?5 You know who else can brag about predicting alignments correctly? Scum. Because they know all the alignments.6 So it's certainly not beyond goodmorning to see a strong wagon forming on AS during D2 and position herself against it knowing that it will flip town. 7
Again, all this is potentially moot based on what GIF has to say, but my initial read coming into today is I have strong townreads on GIF and MER, a somewhat safe townread on ², and a scumread on you.8
1. You don't think asking people questions is a good way to get information?
2. I would.
3. Have you? I've been looking over your ISO. There is not enough substance on anyone other than Stone to fill a thimble.
4. You certainly aren't.
5. Credit? I'm not looking for credit, I'm bragging. It pleases me greatly when I find that I was right and everyone else was wrong. Nothing else to it.
6. Except that's not a prediction. You're right that it would be a good play for one Scum to contradict literally everyone else for towncred upon flip, but it would be a pretty piss-poor one (IMO) to subsequently rub the entire Town's wrongness in their faces.
7. I've publicly positioned myself on the Stone = Town side of things since 348. That is the middleish part of D1. There is some slight implication here that you're not paying much attention to the game in-thread.
8. How in the world did you come to find a strong Townread on Mr E of all people?
@Everyone:
Would you consider RC's play underwhelming? This seems to be a point of contention between us.
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 6:38 am
by goodmorning
In post 667, RedCoyote wrote:If goodmorning is innocent, then I really need to read over the entire game again.
Also forgot this: when do you intend to do that? If my innocence is proven by my lynch then we lose. Strange, eh?
If GM is by chance town he would be the obvious intended mislynch for today.
Yeah, I don't know what to think. I was so sure A_stone was scum. It's been a long time since I've been this wrong - I think I have to reevaluate everything basically.
- b
Posted: Mon May 27, 2013 6:59 am
by ²
In post 659, GuyInFreezer wrote:Are you seriously thinking that I intentionally hammered him?
That's right, IT WAS ME EVERYBODY. Nobody else, JUST ME. I don't even care that I was wrong about Mac, this feels really good and I think Mr E is still Scum.
Still haven't worked up a case though, for personal reasons.
@GIF: Why do you give a shit what Mr E thinks about your wrong cases and why, if you are what you seem to be implying you are, haven't you just outed "your report" already? This is LyLo.
@2: What are your feelings about RC?
You being right about A_stone does not make you town.