Unfortunately for scum, I think all the suspicious easy day 1 lynch people like gdog and spartan got replaced out and their replacements looked pretty townie.
Unfortunately for scum, I think all the suspicious easy day 1 lynch people like gdog and spartan got replaced out and their replacements looked pretty townie.
Yeah this helped a lot! Overall this was a super fun game. I really enjoyed playing with all of you.
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 1:04 am
by EspeciallyTheLies
In post 647, Yodavader wrote:Personally, I don't think fakeclaiming is that bad of a tactic. IMO, you do what you need to to survive the day, regardless of alignment. Whenever you fakeclaim, you always run the risk of someone CCing. So, I actually applaud Fish for the attempt, though it seems to me that Fish really wasn't into the game at this point. If it were me, I would have waited until I was L-1 with a hammer intent to fakeclaim. Since the day was just starting and we were still all trying to figure out the NK, I thought it was premature.
As scum, you have to do whatever you think will gain you the most. With 2 goons it could have been anything. Though I think claiming a PR with the newbie setup mostly ends in a scum lynch just because there’s too much risk of being CC’d. Honestly the way the wagons went I don’t know that I would have lynched fish if he’d claimed VT. Day 1 was kind of bizarre lol...
Perfect town win though. That’s fantastic. Everyone did really well.
Obviously it was all thanks to chibiie and his amazing reads uh no lol... it takes more than one person to lynch scum. I think town was able to read other town which made the PoE easier. A solid town block is one of the greatest weapons - as long as your town reads are true. This is why I generally try to townhunt first and then gauge behavior towards those people. It’s rather successful for the most part. When you realize that you can trust another player, that’s a really strong position for town.
I think scum did ok actually. Faust and gilded did a great job looking town which made them easy to read imo. That narrowed the pool quite a bit for me, and of course knowing my mason buddy was town.
Well done y’all. I’d play with any of you again for sure.
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 1:11 am
by Radja
first mafia game in a long time and glad my reads were spot on.
I'm interested to hear from Fish why he killed GildedSun.
Super fun game, would love to play with any of you again! If any of you newbies have questions and want my input, feel free to ask
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 1:58 am
by faüstiv
Chibiie was a bombscare, but didn’t play too badly I guess.
if this games taught me anything it’s that I need to stop overthinking things.
yay! also trust your town reads a little
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 6:56 am
by EspeciallyTheLies
I cannot for the life of me understand why you held on so hard to your scumread of Gilded lol - I don't even know what you were seeing in the first place.
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 9:30 am
by Farren
Well played, Town.
Trust and confidence are tools that - when used correctly - can be amazing tools for Town.
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 2:56 pm
by eth0s
GG all, it was quite a fun game to watch and moderate. The scum, mason, and personal PTs had lots of valuable information too!
Hope you all had fun, and sorry again for the late final flip. Although I bet the suspense was fun, too
Yikes in my thread movement being all over the place this game
Posted: Thu Nov 07, 2019 8:59 pm
by faüstiv
didn’t know you could have a PT.
Tbh in response to Lies - I like to question all players and make pushes on players that aren’t being pushed. In most cases, at least one mafia gets TR in the day phase. You can’t let players get complacent by not questioning them.
I did scumread fish and Farren d1 then double backed on my reads.
GildedSun had towny reactions but her progression made no sense to me, that’s why I pushed it. After Farren flipped maf I thought she was the most likely partner by logic.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
uh no lol... it takes more than one person to lynch scum. I think town was able to read other town which made the PoE easier. A solid town block is one of the greatest weapons - as long as your town reads are true. This is why I generally try to townhunt first and then gauge behavior towards those people. It’s rather successful for the most part. When you realize that you can trust another player, that’s a really strong position for town. 
